The Serhat Temel Thread

[hillie 41]

can't say i'd be to unhappy with either temel or panos with pick 18 if we go the two midfielders with one and two. also, if lovett finds his way to us in the pre season draft, i think that would offset the opportunity cost of jetta with pick 18. think then we really would have the makings of a pretty good side. add the class mids, pace in the midfield to give davey a chop out and maybe allow him to roam the forward 50 a bit more, and the power forward to complement watts in the coming years. correct me if i'm wrong but i think lovett's the same age as davey. think a change of scenery would be good for him, just as long as his off field issues don't negatively impact our indigenous boys.

[e25 5]

Was on TAC Cup FutureStars today and is an impressive lad. Will be a definite player.

I rate him as a FF, but I still don't think he's quite right for our team.

Doubt he'll still be on the board at 18 though, so it won't be a decision we have to make.

I have a feeling the Doggies will pick him up.

[jayceebee31 761]

Was on TAC Cup FutureStars today and is an impressive lad. Will be a definite player.

I rate him as a FF, but I still don't think he's quite right for our team.

Doubt he'll still be on the board at 18 though, so it won't be a decision we have to make.

I have a feeling the Doggies will pick him up.

Have you seen him play. If so, and I rate you as a judge-he will be a player. Yep- I acceopt the Bullies may pick him up however,Scott, Crocker etc.. were there yesterday and quite impressed- He will be a player. The most impressive tall in the TAC finals overall. BY FAR.Unfortunately feel now- Pick 18 will not get him.

If you haven't seem him live- you will have the opportunity to watch him on Foxrel live next Friday night.

[Guest straussski]

it would be great if we get him... i tink he is one of the best tall fowards in the draft

[Carn dees 108]

This is why im hoping we can trade for another 2nd round pic, would be great to be able to get two of carlisle temel or griffiths.

[e25 5]

This is why im hoping we can trade for another 2nd round pic, would be great to be able to get two of carlisle temel or griffiths.

I'm blindly hoping that Carlisle or Griffiths slide massively due to injuries and we can get both, or one and Panos, Talia, Temel...

Suffice to say, I think we need to load up on bigs.

[jayceebee31 761]

I'm blindly hoping that Carlisle or Griffiths slide massively due to injuries and we can get both, or one and Panos, Talia, Temel...

Suffice to say, I think we need to load up on bigs.

That is the truest thing you have stated in a long time- talls we need. Again as you have stated earlier along with two top midfielders. Or maybe a top midfielder and a tall as our first two picks?

I'd prefer Scully/Trengrove -- Temel,Carlisle(you will see them both next Friday,or Panos)- Hey?

Edited September 20, 2009 by jayceebee31

[e25 5]

That is the truest thing you have stated in a long time- talls we need. Again as you have stated earlier along with two top midfielders. Or maybe a top midfielder and a tall as our first two picks?

I'd prefer Scully/Trengrove -- Temel,Carlisle(you will see them both next Friday,or Panos)- Hey?

Serhat Temel, Jake Carlisle, Aaron Black, Daniel Talia, Matthew Panos, Ben Griffiths... there seems to be a bevy of them, so we're sure to get a good big.

Just remains to be seen whom.

And I am by no means an expert on them, having seen not one of these guys live.

(oh, but our first 2 picks will be midfielders, no doubt)

[jayceebee31 761]

Serhat Temel, Jake Carlisle, Aaron Black, Daniel Talia, Matthew Panos, Ben Griffiths... there seems to be a bevy of them, so we're sure to get a good big.

Just remains to be seen whom.

And I am by no means an expert on them, having seen not one of these guys live.

(oh, but our first 2 picks will be midfielders, no doubt)

Interesting to note that Hutchie on Footy Classified believes we should pick a midfielder and a tall in our first two picks.

Maybe Scullt/Temel ?

[Demon Disciple 12,152]

yeah well who gives a crap about what Hutchy thinks. There are no talls in this draft worthy of pick 2, i would say that Trengove and Martin are miles ahead of any tall.

Scully and Trengove for me thanks. Scully is academic, and i reckon Trengove is bridging the gap between the two of them. Trengove is a must IMO.

If we want a tall there will be one available out of Butcher, Panos, Carlisle, Griffiths, Black and even Temel, come pick 18 (if we haven't upgraded).

Of those talls, the last 4 would be most likely to be around when it's our turn to pick. I wouldn't mind getting more info on Black

Edited September 20, 2009 by Demon Disciple

[e25 5]

Hutchy is an idiot. He'd have us pick Kepler Bradley over Chris Judd.

Moron is only good for being a pest and rumour-mongering.

[Yencks 8]

so out of the tall options we have

temel

griffiths

carlisle

panos

talia

(daw)

[e25 5]

so out of the tall options we have

temel

griffiths

carlisle

panos

talia

(daw)

Aaron Black

John Butcher (i think he's a serious chance to be still available at 11)

[jayceebee31 761]

so out of the tall options we have

temel

griffiths

carlisle

panos

talia

(daw)

There are some others to be considered although, I think, late picks or rookies. Playing tonight are:

CASBOULT, INNES,MITCHELL FOR STINGRAYS

MITCHELL, LAWTON FOR CANNONS.

HOWEVER IT IS TEAMING DOWN HOWEVER WITH THE ROOF SHOULD SHOW GOOD SKILLS. WATCH TONIGHT.

AWAIT YOUR FOLLOW UP THOUGHTS.

[The Great One 99 125]

Is playing in the TAC Grand Final on Fox1 now. Already kicked a goal.

He is a big unit.

[The Great One 99 125]

Make that 2

[jabberwocky 2,301]

Really really like this kid. Big, strong boy with good hands and a strut. His stocks are rising.

[Carn dees 108]

Best forward on the ground imo, gees ive seen carlisle once.

[Dee Fan 3,247]

Best forward on the ground imo, gees ive seen carlisle once.

Kicked 3 to half time as has Mitchell for the Cannons another big unit with good hands.

[Dappa Dan 2,188]

Listening on the radio... Boy oh boy can this guy still be around pick 11? If not, at very least it knocks the other quality down a peg. Quick question for those who have been watching this year and today... Is he ahead of Butcher now?

Edited September 25, 2009 by Dappa Dan

[Dee tention 616]

Pick 18 at the most!

[Dee Fan 3,247]

Listening on the radio... Boy oh boy can this guy still be around pick 11? If not, at very least it knocks the other quality down a peg. Quick question for those who have been watching this year and today... Is he ahead of Butcher now?

Mitchell looked OK he is big and mobile good hands, might be worth a look. Temel finished with 5 goals for the day.

http://www.afl.com.au/news/newsarticle/tab...49/default.aspx

Edited September 25, 2009 by RobbieF

[jabberwocky 2,301]

Pick 18 at the most!

Very, very impressed. I can't comment on any of the other boys but this kid looks the real deal. He moves well his hands are good and he is big and strong.

196 cm gorilla forwards who move well aren't that common..... and he performs in finals under pressure. I think the has kicked 20 goals in 3 games?? Has an air of confidence about him too.

Doesn't move to far from goal so either that is his role or he is limited by his fitness. I would be very pleased to see him on our list.

[ChaserJ 5,096]

Mitchell looked OK he is big and mobile good hands, might be worth a look.

Mitchell's a potential gun, but bottom age, possible Gold Coaster next year.

[jayceebee31 761]

Just got home from the game-- good game great effort from Calder coming from 7th. Geat to see my man-TEMEL-KICK 5.

I REALLY CAN SEE HIM IN THE RED & BLUE. i THINK MALONEY CAN TEACH HIM TO BOX AND WOW IS ALL I CAN SAY.Mitchell played a great game too- they both play well together - but I can see WATTS/TEMEL pairing. THE GOOD THING ABOUT THEM BOTH IS THEY CAN PLAY FF OR CHF AND WILL MOVE UP THE GROUND IF NEEDED.

Serhart is a done to earth guy but will give his all. Good body now but can be built up beautifully. I am waiting and looking forward to Nuggat Jones report.

Edited September 25, 2009 by jayceebee31