Top 5 draft picks

[alpha33 277]

Colin Wisbey Pyeman on the Black & White Extreme Bulletin Board suggested these as the top five draft picks if the draft were held now (bearing in mind that it's a long way out):-

1 Melbourne - Tom Scully

2 Melbourne - John Butcher

3 Richmond - Kobi Stevens

4 Fremantle - Kane Lucas or Anthony Morabito

5 West Coast - Anthony Morabito or Kane Lucas

Edited June 5, 2009 by Whispering_Jack
Alpha33 apologises. He misread the way the site is formatted and thought it was Wisbey.

[Hannabal 4]

Colin Wisbey on the Black & White Extreme Bulletin Board suggested these as the top five draft picks if the draft were held now (bearing in mind that it's a long way out):-

1 Melbourne - Tom Scully

2 Melbourne - John Butcher

3 Richmond - Kobi Stevens

4 Fremantle - Kane Lucas or Anthony Morabito

5 West Coast - Anthony Morabito or Kane Lucas

Scully is an absolute lock at no.1 this year no matter who has the pick.

[Roost It 1,434]

Colin Wisbey on the Black & White Extreme Bulletin Board suggested these as the top five draft picks if the draft were held now (bearing in mind that it's a long way out):-

1 Melbourne - Tom Scully

2 Melbourne - John Butcher

3 Richmond - Kobi Stevens

4 Fremantle - Kane Lucas or Anthony Morabito

5 West Coast - Anthony Morabito or Kane Lucas

That reads very sweetly

[MadAsHell 4,088]

Colin Wisbey on the Black & White Extreme Bulletin Board suggested these as the top five draft picks if the draft were held now (bearing in mind that it's a long way out):-

1 Melbourne - Tom Scully

2 Melbourne - John Butcher

3 Richmond - Kobi Stevens

4 Fremantle - Kane Lucas or Anthony Morabito

5 West Coast - Anthony Morabito or Kane Lucas

Don't think Christensen will be top 5?

[Carn dees 108]

Don't think Christensen will be top 5?

hmm i would of thought so

[Viney_12 1]

hmm i would of thought so

nah you would be looking at guys like Kobey Stevens, Morabito who have bigger and harder bodies over Allen. He looks like top 10 atm but

[Strawbsodwyer 0]

west coast are going to be a problem not winning two more games, might be melbourne pick 1& 3

[Clintosaurus 6,437]

West Coast will win 2 more.

Should we try and trade for another top 5 pick? Christensen or Lucas would be good, as well as Scully and Butcher.

[Axis of Bob 10,219]

If you look at the EBnW website, it's actually not Wisbey's top 5 picks at all. It's the top 5 picks of some random guy and Wisbey just so happens to have posted in the same thread.

These aren't Wisbey's picks.

[Ryan Dee 140]

West Coast will win 2 more.

I agree, I think they are good enough to win 2 out of 11 games consiering they play richmond, fremantle, US and im sure they will upset another team.

[drdrake 3,037]

If WCE get pick 1 or 2 they will take the best West Aussie, Kane Lucas is also a very very good midfielder.

[Pipefitter 2,015]

I don't think west coast are any danger of taking butcher. West coast haven't gone after any big forward types in the worsfold era. Sumich was the last proper full forward they had.

[grazman 6,434]

If you look at the EBnW website, it's actually not Wisbey's top 5 picks at all. It's the top 5 picks of some random guy and Wisbey just so happens to have posted in the same thread.

These aren't Wisbey's picks.

thanks for the clarification Bob, I thought it was a little strange, Colin keeps his cards pretty close to his chest nowadays, and even in the past, he'd only publish his rankings close to or after the draft.

[Jarka 767]

thanks for the clarification Bob, I thought it was a little strange, Colin keeps his cards pretty close to his chest nowadays, and even in the past, he'd only publish his rankings close to or after the draft.

These days he only posts the Collingwood selections, after the draft. He, along with several others, are a big loss to bigfooty.

[dee-luded 2,958]

If WCE get pick 1 or 2 they will take the best West Aussie, Kane Lucas is also a very very good midfielder.

If West Coast get 1st or 2nd pick, they will have another shortly after. Because either Melb or Rich must be close after that.

Then they could grab 2 top picks. Poss Scully & Morabito.

[Hannabal 4]

If WCE get pick 1 or 2 they will take the best West Aussie, Kane Lucas is also a very very good midfielder.

If they get pick 1 why would they overlook the best kid in the country ? And in recruiting circles there's presently a clear standout.

If they get pick 1 they'll choose Scully.

[cooko 124]

If they get pick 1 why would they overlook the best kid in the country ? And in recruiting circles there's presently a clear standout.

If they get pick 1 they'll choose Scully.

agreed.. no team is going to pass on scully when he puts up numbers like he does and he controls every game! lucas might be a local boy for west coast.. but they arent going to pick him just on that reason.. yes lucas is very good.. but scully is a freak!

[hillie 41]

I agree, I think they are good enough to win 2 out of 11 games consiering they play richmond, fremantle, US and im sure they will upset another team.

i wouldn't want to be counting on this if it came down to a month of footy to go and they 'need' one more to avoid the priority pick

[Al`s DEMONS 0]

West Coast will win 2 more.

Should we try and trade for another top 5 pick? Christensen or Lucas would be good, as well as Scully and Butcher.

trade who ?

[jnrmac 18,954]

If the Dees take Scully that will be another private schoolboy taken as a first round pick. That'll be two years running.

I don't want this to be a private vs public school bagging session but historically private school recruits haven't been seen to have the hunger for success that perhaps others may have. There is none that I can see in the list of Number 1 draft picks since 1985. And before people say Brendan Goddard, Caulfield Grammer isn't a real private school!

Luke Ball was touted as the No 1 pick but the Hawks chose Hodge because he was seen as more 'hungry' and had a bit of mongrel about him.

Can anyone think of other highly successful private school kids??

[durango 1,976]

If the Dees take Scully that will be another private schoolboy taken as a first round pick. That'll be two years running.

I don't want this to be a private vs public school bagging session but historically private school recruits haven't been seen to have the hunger for success that perhaps others may have. There is none that I can see in the list of Number 1 draft picks since 1985. And before people say Brendan Goddard, Caulfield Grammer isn't a real private school!

Luke Ball was touted as the No 1 pick but the Hawks chose Hodge because he was seen as more 'hungry' and had a bit of mongrel about him.

Can anyone think of other highly successful private school kids??

Chris Judd went to Caulfield Grammar

[Binmans PA 26,053]

Chris Judd went to Caulfield Grammar

He was in my house too. Brett Deledio was also in my class in year 12. Both reasonable players. Private vs. Public school is a poinltess debate, as it's by no means a measure of how good a player is.

[Guest sticksmorton]

Caulfield Grammer isn't a real private school!

ummmmmmm yes it is.

[Guest sticksmorton]

I don't want this to be a private vs public school bagging session but historically private school recruits haven't been seen to have the hunger for success that perhaps others may have.

LIKE WHO??????????????

[jnrmac 18,954]

I was talking specifically about number one picks and Watts and Goddard are the only ones as far as I can see. Judd was pick 3.

Scott Clayton who knows a bit about recruiting is on record as saying that the private school system doesn't prepare players anywhere near as well for AFL as the TAC Cup or some of the other leagues. They are not as mature in body as they are not playing against men like Bryce Gibbs did in SA at age 15.

And BTW it was a joke abut Caulfield Grammer. Maybe I should have put or or whatever! This is not a slagging session of private vs public but more a curiosity. Given there are 24 number one picks and only two to date have come out of the private school system. Scully would make it three and two in a row to Melbourne.