mo64

Petty is one of the few players on our list that can take a contested pack mark up forward. With our "long bomb" game plan, Petty is essentially untradeable, unless the Crows send Fogarty or Thilthorpe our way, along with pick 10.

The difference is GC and Brisbane aren't trying to offload them. Required players obviously hold more value.

Pick 33 for a 29 yo player who spent half the season in the VFL and is no longer required seems like overs.

Can't see Crows trading Fogarty unless it's a straight swap for Petty.

Were we incompetent for having to trade Jackson last year? Go home factor was the reason in both cases. And by your reckoning the AFL gifted us 2 first round picks. Your takes on North and GC are illogical.

The departures of Hibbo, Harmes and Dunstan would have been factored in when we re-signed our stars. We probably factored in Melksham leaving until he had a resurrection. But unless our cap is really tight, we should be in the market for a free agent next year.

The club told him that he's free to find a new home, so his trade value is nominal. Future 3rd seems about right.

It never happens that way. A deal with Sydney will get done.

I like Harmesy, and I hope he has as distinguished career at the Dogs as Mitch Hannan.

For balance, how about naming all the 1st round draftees that GC have lost over the years? Off the top of my head Lynch, Prestia, Caddy, May, Wright, Brodie, and I'm sure there's others.

North having so many 1st rd picks is partially due to losing their no. 1 selection Horne-Francis, and getting multiple picks in return. Some people need to move on.

The compo is not that hard to understand. If you're a [censored] team down the bottom, you'll get higher compo. Hawks got SFA for Buddy. That's how it works.

It's perplexing because the match committee didn't have the confidence to select him when a like for like player in JVR was suspended. We named him as sub and then didn't bring him on despite T Mac giving us donuts. Schache is not a young kid. We should know his strengths and weaknesses by now. If we're not going to play him with all the injuries we had to KPFs, then why is he still on the list? Being cheap and a solid citizen doesn't cut it. Two of the best young KPFs in Larkey and Mitch Lewis were drafted very late. If Schache rots at Casey for another year then I think his list spot is best used by taking a fly on a young kid or a State League player.

Please no. You want a player who's desperate and motivated to play in a succesful side, and hopefully play in a premiership team, aka Ben Brown. If Hawkins is holding out for more money, then we'll be just be topping up his super.

GC probably have the same philosophy as us. Get a deal done early and move on to the next one. Plus these discussions would have been going on for weeks.

You are massively over valuing Grundy. Even with pick swaps included with Grundy, pick 11 will never be on the table. We want him out of the club, so there'll be no hardball. A pick around the mark for what we paid is what we can expect back in return.

Spargo is not a high pressure forward and doesn't have the goal scoring potential of Billings. When in form, the ceiling of Billings compared to Spargo is like chalk and cheese.

Really like this move. Exactly the right fit for us. Cheap, young, developing forward/ruck. No expectations of him being a world beater, but can't be any worse than both Jackson and Grundy have been as forwards for us over the past 2 seasons. Thankfully there'll be no fan or media scrutiny if he's playing at Casey.

Pass. Since his debut season, he's struggled with injuries and form. After his performance in the finals, I'm not surprised Port are trying to offload him.

Well his trade value didn't go up by spending half the season at Casey. Media are just stating the obvious.

We'll have to draft a mature aged ruckman from the State Leagues, which is what we should have done last year. We'll also need to trade for a forward/ruckman like Lobb.

Not surprising given what happened to Preuss and Grundy.

Message to Jason Taylor. No more Rangas. Next thing we know Bowey will request a trade to his old man's club St. Kilda.

Comparing Watts to Clarry? I've seen it all!!!!

At the end of the day, they have either given up on him or not. His on-field form was hardly diabolical. As we've seen with DeGoey and Dusty, off-field issues are reparable.