Neitz, Green back this week. Bell & Bruce to miss again

[WonnaJurah 5]

Here's my 5 cent's worth -

Out: Davey,

In: Neitz (Bell if Neitz not fit)

[classy dees 42]

Here's my 5 cent's worth -

Out: Davey,

In: Neitz (Bell if Neitz not fit)

That leaves, Neitz, Robbo, Miller, PJ, White, Garland, Frawley, Carroll, Bizzell, Dunn and Newton all in the team. we will run out of legs by qtr time.

Have to bring in one of Moloney, Green or Bruce in. Just goes to show how moronic Davey's actions were. any thought of leadership group status should be thrown out the door. we're in strife already and then he goes and settles a gripe of his, at the expense of the team. Bruce, McLean, and Macca often get tagged, but they never do such stupid things. hope the club rip into him.

[Rhino Richards 1,467]

Classy,

Davey was not leadership material prior to that anyway. His immaturity during the elimination final lasy year proved that.

Moloney still cant run out a VFL game and given what he has been through, I would not risk him. If Green and Bruce are not fit, I would consider playing Heath Neville. We may as well see what he is like.

[Yze_Magic 3]

In - Moloney, Ratten

Out - Davey, Riley

[old55 23,687]

In - Moloney, Ratten

Out - Davey, Riley

I heard Ratten thinks Sylvia is a dud

[Bring-Back-Powell 14,939]

Ins - Holland, Neitz, Bruce

Outs- Davey (susp), Garland, Buckley.

Neitz was a test last week, so should be right to go. Just stick him in the goal-square if he's only 70%. The kids need the skipper out there.

Bruce should be right to go, considering he only just failed a fitness test last Friday.

Big Bad Benny Holland has kicked multiple goals in the magoos the last fortnight, so deserves a promotion. Give him the job on Petrie or create a mis-match in our forward line.

Davey obviously out.

Garland's too raw.

Buckley's had a taste for 2 weeks. Back to the VFL for some solid game time.

Think they'll give Moloney 1 more week in the 2's.

[sylvinator 96]

Garland and Buckley should be kept in the team.

both will be on our list next season and they must develop by players in the seniors. it will hold them in good stead for next year. this year is shot, the focus should be developing the likes of buckley and garland!

one change for me...

out: davey

In: Bruce (if 100% fit)

Green, Bell and Neitz can have one more weeks break. no need to rush them back at all. Moloney should play 2 more game for sandy working up to 80% game time and then to come back and play the last 5 games of the year to get him cherry ripe for the preseason and next year.

holland should stay in the ressies so the Miller can have a real opportunity to prove himself as a big bodied defender. We will never know if he could have made it if he doesnt get a proper shot. Holland will be ok, he's a good depth player and will remain on our list as depth next year. Miller must get his go as a defender. its only for our beneifit to see if he's capable of making it at afl level. Same goes with CJ

[Forest Demon 4,681]

can someone just sort this out for me. if nieta comes in this week and plays from here in, when does that make his 300th.

does one more game out mean it would be against the pies????

[QueenC 74]

one change for me...

out: davey

In: Bruce (if 100% fit)

That one works for me as well........

But the questions stands, what if Bruce hasn't come up yet?

holland should stay in the ressies so the Miller can have a real opportunity to prove himself as a big bodied defender.

Riley basically said that Miller would be given the however many weeks left, to trial as a defender, in the post-match press conference after the Brisbane game.

And as such I can't see him being dropped now, despite what happened in the first quarter last weekend.

[Bring-Back-Powell 14,939]

can someone just sort this out for me. if nieta comes in this week and plays from here in, when does that make his 300th.

does one more game out mean it would be against the pies????

I'm fairly sure he's on 295 games.

Therefore if he plays this week, he'll play his 300th V Collingwood. What a night and an occassion that will be.

If he misses this week, then he'll play his 300th V Freo at Subi...what a non occassion that will be

On that basis I hope they rush him back this week!!

Or do people think they'll rest him for the majority of the season, so he can play his 300th next year, when the season's well and truly alive?

[Forest Demon 4,681]

cheers mate

i would prefer next year, but i dont think they will end someones season for milestones reasons, i will settle for the pies

[QueenC 74]

Or do people think they'll rest him for the majority of the season, so he can play his 300th next year, when the season's well and truly alive?

I am fairly hopeful that they won't be rushing him back for anything.......

If he is not fit, and playing will only cause further damage, in a season that is over then honestly I dont see the point.

He will play his 300th just maybe not as soon as we (and he probably) would have hoped.

Just my opinion, of course !!!

[Gorgoroth 13,019]

Leave him out for 2 more and play it v carlton in round 22, so then we should at least salute on the skippers 300th

[classy dees 42]

Classy,

Davey was not leadership material prior to that anyway. His immaturity during the elimination final lasy year proved that.

RR, fwiw i never believed he was and agree with you, i was just commenting on the perception that football department seems to have about his 'leadership ability'. specifically in an "On The Coach" interview with ND last year (i think perhaps even 05) he said that davey was a potential future captain.

[Rhino Richards 1,467]

RR, fwiw i never believed he was and agree with you, i was just commenting on the perception that football department seems to have about his 'leadership ability'. specifically in an "On The Coach" interview with ND last year (i think perhaps even 05) he said that davey was a potential future captain.

Take your point Classy.

I tend to take those sort of answers given in those forums with a sceptical grain of salt.

It all started when Everett was a young feral bogan at StK and after every time if ran amok, the StK executive stressed how they saw him as a future leader. Nothing further from the truth.

[Sydney Pennski 299]

Leave him out for 2 more and play it v carlton in round 22, so then we should at least salute on the skippers 300th

Do we really want Neita's 300th game to be remembered in connection with what could be a game dedicated to supertanking?

No, play in the Sandy team that day. Let him play game # 300 v. Collingwood.

[Rhino Richards 1,467]

Do we really want Neita's 300th game to be remembered in connection with what could be a game dedicated to supertanking?

No, play in the Sandy team that day. Let him play game # 300 v. Collingwood.

Sydney, From what we saw last time, MFC would have to flood away from the ball to stay even (not ahead) of Carlton.

It would be a greater disgrace to play David Neitz at Sandy. He is either fit to play or he is not.

[Rogue 585]

B: Frawley, Carroll, Ward

HB: Miller, Bizzell, Brown

C: Dunn, McDonald, Wheatley

HF: Sylvia, Bate, Newton

F: C. Johnson, Robertson, Holland

FOLL: White, McLean, Jones

I/C: P.Johnson, Godfrey, Buckley, Bruce

EM: Garland, Moloney, ???

IN - Bruce, Holland

OUT - Davey, Garland

It seems we struggled for options up forward, and Holland gives us someone who will at the least create a contest. Having someone like him down there also means Newton & co get a 'lesser' defender. Holland might not be around much longer, but he's been in good form for Sandy (in the best two weeks ago, kicked 3 on the weekend).

As others have said, Garland is still learning the game. I think Club and player will benefit if he goes back to Sandringham. Riley's flagged Miller's opportunities in defence, so he'll stay in the team. Guys like CJ, and Buckley, to a lesser extent, are further along and should be persevered with.

If Bruce doesn't come up we might need to bring Moloney into the team.

[Nicho 1]

Out: Davey

In: Bruce

Might as well wrap any blokes that are not 100% fit in cotton wool ready for a big 08.

Blokes like Moloney should get thier bodies right for next year.....

I dont want to tank and i know wants to win as many games so his chance to coach full time increases but honestly it is not in our best interest to win 4 games for the rest of the year and get pick #6 when we could easily play the kids and possibly get pick #1.

Out biggest worry is Carlton. If they dont win a another game they will still pick 1 and Richmond 2... There are only 2 standouts in this years draft..........

[Dappa Dan 2,188]

Classy,

Davey was not leadership material prior to that anyway. His immaturity during the elimination final lasy year proved that.

Whether or not you agree he was leadership material, he was certainly mooted as a potential captain or vice captain some time ago.

His antics in the Saints final were more or less a first, and his subsequent interview suggested even he was surprised that he'd reacted the way he did. Add to that the fact that in both the Saints final, and on the weekend, he came back on and lifted his team.

If Davey is not leadership material now, it's because perhaps he has something to learn. If EVERY player who misbehaved was disregarded as a future captain, we wouldn't have some of the skippers we have in the league now... Hall being a good example.

Davey's leadership credentials have taken a beating, but he's still going to be in calculations in coming years. You think these 2 matches off aren't going to hurt him as the only player suspended? If you were to take a positive spin, there's even a chance that this may be the making of him. His team needs him now more than ever, and he's the only one to blame.

If people think he's NEVER going to make a leader you're simply scapegoating... and you're small minded.

[Rhino Richards 1,467]

If people think he's NEVER going to make a leader you're simply scapegoating... and you're small minded.

In order to be a captain/vice captain it is usual that the player should possess and display evidence of on field leadership. Davey may be skilful in bursts but I have not witnessed any significant leadership qualities during his time at MFC. He is immensely popular with supporters (especially kids) but appears rather meek on field.

Davey has also been unable to curb his frustrations in other games beside the St Kilda and Brisbane games. They were just two very bad examples.

It is concerning that Davey would be surprised he acted that way against St Kilda as he is readily upset in games where decisions go against him. His petulant behaviour could have cost us a final and if not the deeds of others we would not have won. He came back and performed when the game was already won.

More importantly his form this year has been poor and his development has plateaued or gone backwards. He struggles in the midfield to win contests and his apologists are saying he should be played in the forward line only. A potential limiter to leadership if ever there was one.

You are right he has alot to prove. Lets just see if he can make it as player with a broader skill set before we anoint him with a role he has shown little capacity for.

For mine, McLean, Bate, Rivers and Jones strike me as more leaders than Davey.

You claims of scapegoating are wrong and the small mindedness may actually be yours.

[Gouga 570]

I don't see why Davey can't be in the leadership group sometime in the future. But I agree it will require him to work on his increasing undiscipline acts.

We all know where Barry Hall has been and where he is now.

As far as team selection is concerned, we have to face the fact that a couple youngsters will be dropped this week.

If fit Bell, Bruce, Green and Neitz all deserve a game. And Riley deserves the oppurtunity to coach them. Assuming all are fit I believe that Buckley, Garland and Newton (although I hope not) could miss. I'd like to think it was Brown, Godfrey and Ward to miss but that just isn't going to happen.

B: Bell, Carroll, Ward

HB: Bizzell, Miller, Frawley

C: Bruce, Green, Wheatley

HF: Bate, Dunn, Sylvia

F: Brown, Neitz, Robertson

R: White, McDonald, McLean

I/C: Godfrey, C Johnson, P Johnson, Jones

In: Bell, Bruce, Green, Neitz

Out: Buckley, Davey (susp.), Garland, Newton

[Gouga 570]

It now looks more like...

In: Bell, Neitz

Out: Davey (susp.), Garland

http://ninemsn.sportal.com.au/default.aspx...ay&id=31386

[Bring-Back-Powell 14,939]

In: Bell, Neitz

Good ins!

We never get thumped when the skippers in the side.

[Rogue 585]

More importantly his form this year has been poor and his development has plateaued or gone backwards. He struggles in the midfield to win contests and his apologists are saying he should be played in the forward line only.

Those who think he's a forward are Davey 'apologists'?

Oh dear. Hyperbolic.

The Demons are set to regain two senior players – skipper David Neitz and much-improved defender Daniel Bell – for their clash with the Kangaroos at Telstra Dome on Sunday.

Riley said the return of the club captain would no doubt be a huge boost for his young side.

"All his injuries were realistically collision injuries, they weren’t of that age nature or that age bracket so he’s looking great and he’s really keen to go," he said.

"It was a magnificent effort and it was well documented how he got himself up and played in Neale’s last game against the Bombers and he’s now had three weeks off, (he's) really refreshed and really keen to get out there and lead the team."

Midfielder Cameron Bruce will spend another week on the sidelines with a hamstring injury while Byron Pickett is resigned to playing with VFL side Sandringham until his form warrants senior selection.

Based on this information, my revised team is as follows -

B: Frawley, Carroll, Ward

HB: Bizzell, Miller, Bell

C: Dunn, McDonald, Wheatley

HF: Sylvia, Bate, Newton

F: C. Johnson, Neitz, Robertson

FOLL: White, McLean, Jones

I/C: P.Johnson, Godfrey, Buckley, Brown

EM: Garland, Moloney, Holland

IN - Bell, Neitz

OUT - Davey, Garland