Just now, DubDee said:

While Rowell is on 34 votes, there is only one defender above 5 votes

Time to change the voting panel to a panel of footy experts

Coleman medallist can’t crack a top 5 finish.

Half back flankers rarely rate a mention, despite being some of the most influential players of the modern game

1 minute ago, DubDee said:

While Rowell is on 34 votes, there is only one defender above 5 votes

Time to change the voting panel to a panel of footy experts

They still will favour midfielders.

1 minute ago, spirit of norm smith said:

3 votes. J.Viney v Saints.

16 tackles. Dominated. Deserved the three.

👏👏👏👏

I loved his effort in that game, but NWM single handedly won the Saints that game.

He scored a perfect 10 from the coaches in that game.

Max has done really well. What a champion

Max Just equaled his best

4 minutes ago, DubDee said:

While Rowell is on 34 votes, there is only one defender above 5 votes

Time to change the voting panel to a panel of footy experts

Really?

Jeremy Cameron was all Australian captain over Jordan Dawson.

Let’s not do that either.

Edited September 22, 2025Sep 22 by GawnOfTheDead

Oh no Daicos

Perhaps they should re-nickname Nick Daicos ‘The Little Bridesmaid’?

I get the impression that Nick Daicos thinks he’s entitled to a Brownlow.

Naicos didn’t win. Bailey Smith didn’t win.

All is good and holy in the world.

Just now, Ethan Tremblay said:

I get the impression that Nick Daicos thinks he’s entitled to a Brownlow.

I get the impression he’s entitled. Full stop.

As much as I loathe the Pies, I actually do feel for N Daicos. Cameras all over him, and he is showing grace and respect. Must be tough to be 2nd three years running.

It's good to see someone different winning it.

Well done matty.

Christ dill rake a breath

Always the bridesmaids never the bride has never been more appropriate

A win for the red head community

Just now, Maldonboy38 said:

As much as I loathe the Pies, I actually do feel for N Daicos. Cameras all over him, and he is showing grace and respect. Must be tough to be 2nd three years running.

He’s a very good media performer and always well spoken and respectful. I’ll give you that.

But he’s a filth player and hence it brings me great joy to see him lose 3 years in a row.

Good result

Get ready for an awkward AF speech

Maxy finishing on 23!!! Best for his career!!!!

Why congratulate NDaicos? He is just one of hundreds that didn't win it.

Ah suffer in ur jocks faicos,and stuff you feral filth collingwoid,

What the [censored]? Goyder congratulating Daicos when he didn't even win.

Can't wait for the Pies fan melts when they realise Nick lost to a guy who regularly eats grass...

3 minutes ago, Jaded No More said:

I get the impression he’s entitled. Full stop.

I think both.

Great result.

AFL is a disgrace. They’re giving Rowell his speech and still say “sorry Nick”.

Shouldn’t be mentioning anyone but the winner. Disgraceful.

1 minute ago, red and blue forever said:

Maxy finishing on 23!!! Best for his career!!!!

Highest ranking non midfielder if I’m not mistaken

What a freak

Pies fans will blame the umpires. The irony.

Well done Maxy.