Christian Petracca

[Roost it far 8,225]

Club’s got some work to do. He’s completely untradeable. We’d sink like a rock if we did that deal. 

[Ted Lasso 19,459]

28 minutes ago, dazzledavey36 said:

I too was in the Lever camp but he just makes far too many mistakes and brain fades, especially this year.

I then had ANB as my next option but we know that won't be the case :(

Same boat Daz, i thought it'd be Gus to be honest, he just felt like he was our heart and soul since the 2021 flag, honestly it sounds strange but of the young guys, Van Rooyen nearly looks the most likely. 

[picket fence 17,126]

There is an old HAWKWIND song called

"YOU BETTER BELIEVE IT"

well I DO!

[John Crow Batty 8,863]

7 minutes ago, adonski said:

Which clubs actually have the capacity to trade for him?

Freo springs to mind, they're entering their window and have 3 x first round picks. Odds of me winning tattslotto probably better than Trac being a dokkah in 2025 though.

Hawks would be keen. But sounds like they're committed to bringing Barrass in which'll swallow up their picks.

GCS - see Freo

Most of the other Vic clubs either don't have picks (Pies), or do have picks but are in rebuild mode (Richmond). Then you have the teams in no mans land like Saints and Essendon which wouldn't be too exciting. 

As I said before not many clubs would risk paying a fortune for a champion player who has suffered a very serious injury and his future playing ability is still unclear. We won’t get top draft picks and he won’t get top dollar as in his current contract with us if he goes.

Edited August 15 by John Crow Batty

[adonski 12,040]

Just now, John Crow Batty said:

As I said before not many clubs would risk paying a fortune for a champion player who has suffered a very serious injury and his future playing ability is still unclear. We won’t get top draft picks and he won’t get top dollar as in his current contract with us. 

Lol I reckon many clubs would pay a fortune for him regardless of his recent injury

[Roost it far 8,225]

Just now, Ted Lasso said:

Same boat Daz, i thought it'd be Gus to be honest, he just felt like he was our heart and soul since the 2021 flag, honestly it sounds strange but of the young guys, Van Rooyen nearly looks the most likely. 

Too young and doesn’t need the pressure of leading us during this

[frankie_d 1,471]

On 14/08/2024 at 12:27, Deelectable said:

... Love Selwyn Griffith to look further afield paving the way for Darren Burgess return.  Unfortunately I think that's unlikely...

The loss of Burgess has been keenly felt, I reckon. He was the instigator of leaving Jackson on the field at the end of the third quarter (Bang, Bang, Bang) - Goody just sort of agreed and broke the news to Max. Our injuries and our management of them - I don't know enough to compare Griffith and Burgess, but I do know that we have had plenty of problems with injuries 2022 onwards. Getting Burgess back (dream on) would be a major victory for the club.

[Ted Lasso 19,459]

2 minutes ago, Roost it far said:

Too young and doesn’t need the pressure of leading us during this

I agree, but we are low on options, outside of Gawn and Viney, it's unclear who the next in line would be at this point, Lever is a good leader but not sure he's the right fit, Trac, who knows where he's at, don't think Salo is really a leader either, plus not fit all the time

[Gawndy the Great 9,011]

3 minutes ago, Ted Lasso said:

Same boat Daz, i thought it'd be Gus to be honest, he just felt like he was our heart and soul since the 2021 flag, honestly it sounds strange but of the young guys, Van Rooyen nearly looks the most likely. 

He does have something but putting him up now would ruin him. 

Gawn will have to stay for at least 1 more year I think. Bring Rivers into the LG and move Trac out.

[Roost it far 8,225]

Just now, frankie_d said:

The loss of Burgess has been keenly felt, I reckon. He was the instigator of leaving Jackson on the field at the end of the third quarter (Bang, Bang, Bang) - Goody just sort of agreed and broke the news to Max. Our injuries and our management of them - I don't know enough to compare Griffith and Burgess, but I do know that we have had plenty of problems with injuries 2022 onwards. Getting Burgess back (dream on) would be a major victory for the club.

You’re rewriting history although I’d agree he was good at his job. We still have very few soft tissue injuries and it appears our preseason MAY of seen some poor application from some players. Others have noted that the Burgess method may have a time limit. Consistently playing through injury with our heavy contest method may of just burnt us out. Who knows?

[adonski 12,040]

I understand your captain doesn't need to be your best played but Ricardo Lever simply isn't good enough

[Demonsterative 3,020]

7 minutes ago, frankie_d said:

The loss of Burgess has been keenly felt, I reckon. He was the instigator of leaving Jackson on the field at the end of the third quarter (Bang, Bang, Bang) - Goody just sort of agreed and broke the news to Max. Our injuries and our management of them - I don't know enough to compare Griffith and Burgess, but I do know that we have had plenty of problems with injuries 2022 onwards. Getting Burgess back (dream on) would be a major victory for the club.

A fitness guy having match day responsibility. Is this the case or common practise? 
 

Serious question. 

[KozzyCan 764]

7 minutes ago, frankie_d said:

The loss of Burgess has been keenly felt, I reckon. He was the instigator of leaving Jackson on the field at the end of the third quarter (Bang, Bang, Bang) - Goody just sort of agreed and broke the news to Max. Our injuries and our management of them - I don't know enough to compare Griffith and Burgess, but I do know that we have had plenty of problems with injuries 2022 onwards. Getting Burgess back (dream on) would be a major victory for the club.

Where did you hear this? This seems like a bit of an overstep for the fitness guy.

[Dr. Gonzo 24,204]

13 minutes ago, watchtheeyes said:

The fact people are saying we should actually trade Petracca is wild.

Wild.

It's like some kind of self sabotage because they don't think we deserve nice things

[pitmaster 3,519]

I don't rate 'Fly' who has been incredibly lucky to be a premiership coach but he can GAGF with this garbage about puling Trac over to the filth: "“I’d bet he’d look good in black and white. I’ve got a car park here he can have too if he wants it,” McRae said in response to photoshopped images circulating of Petracca in the Collingwood guernsey.

 

[Dr. Gonzo 24,204]

11 minutes ago, picket fence said:

There is an old HAWKWIND song called

"YOU BETTER BELIEVE IT"

well I DO!

There is another one called "YOU SHOULDN'T DO THAT"

[adonski 12,040]

1 minute ago, pitmaster said:

I don't rate 'Fly' who has been incredibly lucky to be a premiership coach but he can GAGF with this garbage about puling Trac over to the filth: "“I’d bet he’d look good in black and white. I’ve got a car park here he can have too if he wants it,” McRae said in response to photoshopped images circulating of Petracca in the Collingwood guernsey.

 

It's conceivable that Trac could be a Pie in 2025...if Collingwood didn't waste a top 10 pick on a plodding small forward in Lachie Shultz

[pitmaster 3,519]

11 minutes ago, frankie_d said:

The loss of Burgess has been keenly felt, I reckon. He was the instigator of leaving Jackson on the field at the end of the third quarter (Bang, Bang, Bang) - Goody just sort of agreed and broke the news to Max. Our injuries and our management of them - I don't know enough to compare Griffith and Burgess, but I do know that we have had plenty of problems with injuries 2022 onwards. Getting Burgess back (dream on) would be a major victory for the club.

This is an entirely new take on what happened. Max's account is that he told Goody to let the kid run while he was hot. I tend to believe that version since it was the one told closest to the event.

[John Crow Batty 8,863]

9 minutes ago, Roost it far said:

You’re rewriting history although I’d agree he was good at his job. We still have very few soft tissue injuries and it appears our preseason MAY of seen some poor application from some players. Others have noted that the Burgess method may have a time limit. Consistently playing through injury with our heavy contest method may of just burnt us out. Who knows?

We did burn out badly in finals after very strong seasons in 22/23.

[Gawndy the Great 9,011]

3 minutes ago, pitmaster said:

I don't rate 'Fly' who has been incredibly lucky to be a premiership coach but he can GAGF with this garbage about puling Trac over to the filth: "“I’d bet he’d look good in black and white. I’ve got a car park here he can have too if he wants it,” McRae said in response to photoshopped images circulating of Petracca in the Collingwood guernsey.

 

That club. Grr. I wait for the day that something tragic happens.

[Demonsterative 3,020]

1 minute ago, John Crow Batty said:

We did burn out badly in finals after very strong seasons in 22/23.

Was this due to injury or fitness? My recollection was non fitness based  injuries

[KozzyCan 764]

Even if we got Burgess back I don't think we'll ever have the kind of luck we had injury wise in 2021. Everything went right for us that year.

[loges 6,767]

This is so disappointing on so many levels.

[Fork 'em 6,983]

5 hours ago, WalkingCivilWar said:

I believe Jaded said ‘Boring’ not ‘mentally unhinged’ 😁

Says you.
The irony 😂

 

Edited August 15 by Fork 'em

[BoBo 2,941]

20 minutes ago, Demonsterative said:

A fitness guy having match day responsibility. Is this the case or common practise? 
 

Serious question. 

There was ‘the weapon’ at Essendon. Use to stand on the boundary line with Hird and be very involved. 
 

I remember the week he was banished to sitting in some corner somewhere. 
 

Good times.