2 minutes ago, leave it to deever said:

Can someone please explain to brayshaw he doesnt have to shout all the time...thats what mics are for.

Hard with all the crowd

4 minutes ago, Demonstone said:

Why do some posters spell Geelong with a "J"?  I just don't get it.

Cos its chock full of jerks.

4 minutes ago, leave it to deever said:

Can someone please explain to brayshaw he doesnt have to shout all the time...thats what mics are for.

Can someone please explain to leave it to deever that he can press the mute button and that he is not being forced to listen to the commentators.

Just now, Demonstone said:

Can someone please explain to leave it to deever that he can press the mute button and that he is not being forced to listen to the commentators.

Gee tx. Sarcasm intended.

Just now, Demonstone said:

Can someone please explain to leave it to deever that he can press the mute button and that he is not being forced to listen to the commentators.

Yeah, but then you'd miss the crowd cheering !! 

Toby should be safe.

Commentators so keen to condemn him they failed to notice that Danger started to squat to tackle but his left leg slides out from under him.  Had he not slid the elbow/arm would have got Danger in the chest.  

Also Fritsch got off on something similar (the forearm).  The Tribunal set a precedent in the recent Buddy case of accepting similar incidents as evidence so they will have to accept the Fritsch decision.

#tobyplayson

Edited August 6, 20214 yr by Lucifer's Hero

1 minute ago, bingers said:

Yeah, but then you'd miss the crowd cheering !! 

And them "loving it"

Ohhhhh  BT 🥴

1 minute ago, Lucifer's Hero said:

Toby should be safe.

Commentators so keen to condemn him they failed to notice that Danger started to squat to tackle but his left leg slides out from under him.  Had he not slid the elbow/arm would have got Danger in the chest.

Also Fritsch got off on something similar (the forearm).  The Tribunal set a precedent in the recent Buddy case of accenpting similar incidents as evidence they will have to accept the Fritsch decision.

#tobyplays on

I think Careys correct in saying that now Danger has gone to hospital tg is gone.

6 minutes ago, leave it to deever said:

Cos its chock full of jerks.

Jerklong?

8 minutes ago, Demonstone said:

Gee, thanks.  

Uhm.., it’s Jee, thanks. 

2 minutes ago, Lucifer's Hero said:

Toby should be safe.

Commentators so keen to condemn him they failed to notice that Danger started to squat to tackle but his left leg slides out from under him.  Had he not slid the elbow/arm would have got Danger in the chest.  

Also Fritsch got off on something similar (the forearm).  The Tribunal set a precedent in the recent Buddy case of accepting similar incidents as evidence so they will have to accept the Fritsch decision.

#tobyplays on

I felt that for the action Fritta was very lucky, but given recent results with the tribunal he should be fine. A lot more split second than Buddy who shifted the ball to the other arm in order to elbow the tackler. 

Consistency says that he shouldn’t get suspended. 

1 minute ago, WalkingCivilWar said:

Uhm.., it’s Jee, thanks. 

Generally speaking, perhaps.  Please be gentle with me on this.

10 minutes ago, leave it to deever said:

I think Careys correct in saying that now Danger has gone to hospital tg is gone.

In play + reasonable to try fend off + Danger slipped =  No case to answer.

As comparison:  Hawkins had no case to answer with his (well disguised) elbow to the head of May.  I can't remember the rating but probably, careless, high (head), high impact as May was hospitalised and missed a week.  Toby assessment should be the same.

 

Go Giants!!

Edited August 6, 20214 yr by Lucifer's Hero

4 minutes ago, Pates said:

I felt that for the action Fritta was very lucky, but given recent results with the tribunal he should be fine. A lot more split second than Buddy who shifted the ball to the other arm in order to elbow the tackler. 

Consistency says that he shouldn’t get suspended. 

So surely that says he will.

PS Selwood just chose to bump Taylor head high - but I guess the Selwood rule will apply and he will be fine (or at worst fined).

Can we please lure Tg?

1 minute ago, Lucifer's Hero said:

Go Giants!!

Go Jiants!!  

Selwood head high bump. 
 

“oh he’s probably okay”

”accidental”

here we go again

Gee, I think this really could be an upset.

Go giants.

1 minute ago, Lucifer's Hero said:

In play + reasonable to try fend off + Danger slipped =  No case to answer.

As comparison:  Hawkins had no case to answer with his (well disguised) elbow to the head of May.  I can't remember the rating but probably, careless, high (head), high impact.  Toby assessment should be the same.

 

Go Giants!!

As I recall Hawkins wasn't even cited - the media didn't go all over it so Christian didn't even have to have a look.

 

Can someone work out if Geeling lose tonight what does that mean in terms of how many wins we need to secure top 4?

Edited August 6, 20214 yr by dazzledavey36

Man, BT’s not even attempting to hide his disappointment when the Giants goal. 

Maggots doing their best - Guthrie clearly rode him in the back - "free kick Geelong".

2 minutes ago, dazzledavey36 said:

 

Can someone work out if Geeling lose tonight what does that mean in terms of how many wins we need to secure top 4?

Don't even think of it - win the bloody lot.

For a much lauded defence, Geelong have conceded a lot of goals out the back tonight.

2 minutes ago, dazzledavey36 said:

 

Can someone work out if Geeling lose tonight what does that mean in terms of how many wins we need to secure top 4?

The same amount as before the game started. It affects the chances of making top 2.