Holland out, Neaves in

[Spirit of the Demon 256]

Late change to the squad according to melbournefc.com.au in their match preview

http://prod.www.melbournefc.cfour.com.au/D...mp;newsId=38371

[dazzledavey36 55,498]

im guessing PJ will be played forward if neaves comes in? well good luck to him he deserves it and has worked really hard this pre season.

go dees

[DEES 0]

i reckon it would have been better if they'd given a newton a chance instead. 3 ruckmen is too many and we seem to have a lot of defenders. if we brang newton in, he could have had a taste of afl, which could help him develop faster. but i hope neaves does well anyway

[Jaded No More 68,974]

Really happy about that.

Dutchy has no match-up tomorrow, and with the current humidity, going in with 3 ruckmen is a good move.

Anybody know the final 24?

[Demon Jim 149]

i reckon it would have been better if they'd given a newton a chance instead. 3 ruckmen is too many and we seem to have a lot of defenders. if we brang newton in, he could have had a taste of afl, which could help him develop faster. but i hope neaves does well anyway

Brang? Did I miss something at school?

[deestroy08 0]

If you can understand the general jist of what someone is saying (or trying to say), then why bother picking on them for their spelling mistakes? I don't know what it is but some people on this site continually do it when in reality, it's pointless - it's a footy forum, not an English lesson.

[occo 2]

If you can understand the general jist of what someone is saying (or trying to say), then why bother picking on them for their spelling mistakes? I don't know what it is but some people on this site continually do it when in reality, it's pointless - it's a footy forum, not an English lesson.

AGREE COMPLETLY. too many members on here take this too seriously, like its meant to be a report. However i have spoken abou this in the forum several times and some of these members very serious supporters. You cant chance their view.

Edited by Mod Fan

[Whispering_Jack 30,992]

The FD must be contemplating playing Neaves because I don't see why they would have named a replacement for Ben Holland at all. Either that or they're sending him a message that he's getting close.

As for replacing Holland with Newton, I don't think it would be a good idea. Based on all of the information I've received from those who saw him in Tuesday's practice match, his (Newton's) performance was very much below par. The message they would want to give him from that is that if he wants to play in the big time, he's got to produce some good form to justify it first.

[Dappa Dan 2,188]

Yeah, I'm happy about that too. Crownies if you can afford them, but I'll take Carlton Draught.

If you can understand the general jist of what someone is saying (or trying to say), then why bother picking on them for their spelling mistakes?

Because some of the people here spend a LOT of time on these boards. You can't skim through a members post as quickly if you're deciphering what they're trying to say. If there's the odd typo (teh instead of the) or spelling error on a huge word, or even a bit of poetic license (Toigs, Caaaahlton, Terry Wallet) then most can cope, but there are some who don't have the respect for fellow posters to do the right thing and go over what they've written and quickly correct it. One of the problems is that the posters making the really glaring errors aren't the ones who have to read those posts.

Example, which one would you prefer to read -

Mlebourne had a realy good year this seeson i thought neeta was really good and arron was awesome,, brad greens kicking has ben pretty bad too i think brock is is a champ and hes going to be their when the borwnlow is read out in big numbers go deesy ou rock I h8 essendon

or

Melbourne had a really good year this season. I thought Neitz was really good and Aaron was AWESOME. However, Brad Green's kicking has been pretty bad.

I think Brock is a champion, and he's going to be there when the Brownlow is read out. And in big numbers too.

Go demons, you guys ROCK!

P.S. I HATE Essendon.

Like you say, it's not the end of the world, but then people aren't ABUSING you by pointing out a spelling error. They're just being cheeky and having a bit of fun. If they were being insulting, then you'd probably be entitled to be a bit miffed, but the way this board is run, the offending post would hardly see the light of day.

Incidentally, half the time I type it ends up like the first example above before I go through it and make it easier to read.

Just from my point of view, I reckon Whispering Jack, Rhino, Jaded and the long lost Hannabal know how to type a thoughtful, entertaining post, among others. You only need to compare some of the worse posters on here with some of the abovementioneds' larger posts to see which ones are easier to read, and understand.

Just my 2 cents worth.

[Spirit of the Demon 256]

The FD must be contemplating playing Neaves because I don't see why they would have named a replacement for Ben Holland at all. Either that or they're sending him a message that he's getting close.

I watched the Carlton v Essendon game played at the same venue yesterday and IMO, Essendon's main problem was that it was top heavy with big men and didn't have enough mids to compete with Carlton especially in the first half. IMO therefore, we don't bring in Neaves but rather go for an extra midfielder because the Hawks are very strong in that area.

[Jarka 767]

I must be on my own planet as I have yet to see anything in PJ that suggests that he will make it as a ruckman, to me he is purely a tall forward. I think Neaves has already taken the 3rd ruck position away from him.

[Jaded No More 68,974]

I still can't find the final 24 for this afternoon.

Surely the AFL site, if it wasn't such a mess, could lend itself to sorting out the final team.

[Bang Bang Bang 5,839]

The team won't be known until the first bounce. Well thats what has happened in previous years anyway.

[Rhino Richards 1,467]

I must be on my own planet as I have yet to see anything in PJ that suggests that he will make it as a ruckman, to me he is purely a tall forward. I think Neaves has already taken the 3rd ruck position away from him.

The same weaknesses that curse PJ as a ruckman will undermine him as a tall forward

[Jarka 767]

The same weaknesses that curse PJ as a ruckman will undermine him as a tall forward

Yeah, we shouldn't be pinning our hopes on this bloke. If he comes good then it's a bonus.

[Spirit of the Demon 256]

Yeah, we shouldn't be pinning our hopes on this bloke. If he comes good then it's a bonus.

We were absolutely smashed in the rucks and in the middle in the last 30 minutes of play. We have a definite problem with our rucks but our midfield will be better when Brock and Beamer are back.

We also have to cut out those dinky little short handpasses in the middle of traffic which were so predictable and often intercepted and then set up Hawthorn goals. It was an embarrasment to the coaching panel.