1 minute ago, Engorged Onion said:

my you are provactive....

Did you bring my bins in today?

6 hours ago, binman said:

Sorry, but that doesn't make sense. Or at least doesn't to me.

I am very much looking forward to Joel Smith returning from injury. I think he will be come a very good addition to our side if he can stay fit.

But i (and i assume others who share that sentiment) am not suggesting Smith's availability is a prerequisite for success in 2020. I think it will help but that's just hunch.

Smith may not even end up being in our best 22, might do or may not shake the injury curse. Whatever the situation ends up being with Smith, i'm still confident of making finals in 2020. 

Pretty easy to make sense of - you think he has AFL qualities, and I don't.  Not sure why the confusion.

I feel the same way about Smith as I do both Wagners.  If they play regular senior footy in 2020, we're clearly bottom 4 material again.

Binman, you really need to raise your standards.

12 minutes ago, Sorry kids said:

Did you bring my bins in today?

um no, um yes, um i don''t know what you're getting at.

2 minutes ago, Engorged Onion said:

um no, um yes, um i don''t know what you're getting at.

 

5 minutes ago, The Chazz said:

Pretty easy to make sense of - you think he has AFL qualities, and I don't.  Not sure why the confusion.

I feel the same way about Smith as I do both Wagners.  If they play regular senior footy in 2020, we're clearly bottom 4 material again.

Binman, you really need to raise your standards.

I am in the edge with Smith. Think it may come down to coaching and finding a position. Its no good tying a whole lot of positions for someone who has come to the game late in life. Keep it simple. Backline-spoil. Forward line-strong leads,go for your marks, bring ball to ground. Work hard on kicking skills.

12 minutes ago, Sorry kids said:

Plenty of blokes fight with friends. Its not a symptom of concussion unless its a very complicated case

Read the article instead of making ill informed, superficial comments. He and his docs would have a better knowledge of his condition than you. Pull your head in (again).

On 10/8/2019 at 5:36 PM, Satyriconhome said:

Joel developed OP, one of the few 'injuries' that takes a while to manifest itself fully 

If 2 posts on Instagram of him doing gym sessions is anything to go by Joel should be ready for Day 1 pre season

It doesn't.

Plus I can't see any pictures on his insta from the gym

7 minutes ago, BAMF said:

It doesn't.

Plus I can't see any pictures on his insta from the gym

 

9 minutes ago, Moonshadow said:

Read the article instead of making ill informed, superficial comments. He and his docs would have a better knowledge of his condition than you. Pull your head in (again).

Where is the article you reference talking about the condition that causes him to fight his mates Moon

18 minutes ago, Moonshadow said:

Read the article instead of making ill informed, superficial comments. He and his docs would have a better knowledge of his condition than you. Pull your head in (again).

Head still in its place. Kindly tell me where this article is Moondog.

51 minutes ago, Sorry kids said:

Plenty of blokes fight with friends. Its not a symptom of concussion unless its a very complicated case

Mate if you watched Insight last night you would realize  it is a very complicated case. The bloke nearly jumped in front of a train at richmond station FFS. The multiple concussions have changed his whole personality. Fighting with friends is just one small part of it.

10 hours ago, chook fowler said:

looked much better up forward than down back. Could be a difficult match up as a third tall.

Fritsch has the 3rd tall role locked down to my thinking...

Where does Smith fit?

39 minutes ago, rjay said:

Fritsch has the 3rd tall role locked down to my thinking...

Where does Smith fit?

Defensive forward, if he's going to make it.

1 minute ago, demonzz said:

Mate if you watched Insight last night you would realize  it is a very complicated case. The bloke nearly jumped in front of a train at richmond station FFS. The multiple concussions have changed his whole personality. Fighting with friends is just one small part of it.

Just to be clear, are you talking Joel or Shaun Smith.

16 minutes ago, Sorry kids said:

 

Where is the article you reference talking about the condition that causes him to fight his mates Moon

The article is from the show last night. Shaun smith, Barnes  and a couple  of rugby players who are fu,,,ed up due to concussion. 

 

6 minutes ago, demonzz said:

The article is from the show last night. Shaun smith, Barnes  and a couple  of rugby players who are fu,,,ed up due to concussion. 

 

Cheers, Yeah ok. I was commenting on Joel Smith, as per thread until it crossed to Shauns case. apologies, yes a complicated one for Shaun.

27 minutes ago, Sorry kids said:

 

Where is the article you reference talking about the condition that causes him to fight his mates Moon

Read the article. Look for the Shaun Smith concussion thread. It's not hard. The article is about his concussions and the depression he thinks resulted from it. Try not to reveal too much ignorance in your responses to it. Or watch Insight (you know, that SBS channel you usually only stop at if it's raunchy).

FMD. I give up, I've had enough .

Here's the thing: I'm putting you on ignore. Please DO NOT reply to me ever again and I will continue to ignore you. Better still, put me on ignore as well. If 'Land had 'ignore in quotes' button I'd hit it too. Please god let this happen soon!

Do not respond to this post. I will not read it. You would be responding to no one.

I see the irony in this being partly about depression with my post. 

21 minutes ago, demonzz said:

The article is from the show last night. Shaun smith, Barnes  and a couple  of rugby players who are fu,,,ed up due to concussion. 

 

Cheers, Yeah ok. I was commenting on Joel Smith, as per thread until it crossed to Shauns case. apologies, yes a complicated one for Shaun.

2 hours ago, The Chazz said:

Pretty easy to make sense of - you think he has AFL qualities, and I don't.  Not sure why the confusion.

I feel the same way about Smith as I do both Wagners.  If they play regular senior footy in 2020, we're clearly bottom 4 material again.

Binman, you really need to raise your standards.

Sorry to disappoint you chazz.

But your initial comment still doesn't make sense.

In that comment you imply a correlation between looking forward to Joel Smith playing and our chances of success in 2020. No such correlation exists and no one has suggested it does. Except you.

Your above explanation (ie we dont agree on his ability) is a completely different point.

Edited October 9, 20196 yr by binman

Demnonlanders could you do me a favour and keep an eye on Moonshadow. He is not himself lately. The way he is carrying on you would like I was Inspector Clouseau and just took his job. One minute he is telling me to pull my head in in anger, second warning, the next he is praying to God for help. Poor soul. Anyone know if he goes to Goschs Paddock for training?

55 minutes ago, rjay said:

Fritsch has the 3rd tall role locked down to my thinking...

Where does Smith fit?

That’s assuming Weed will play. It will be interesting to see how he looks in the preseason.

58 minutes ago, rjay said:

Fritsch has the 3rd tall role locked down to my thinking...

Where does Smith fit?

Fair point. But I think they are playing different roles. Smith is more s defensive forward.

Edited October 9, 20196 yr by binman

1 hour ago, BAMF said:

It doesn't.

Plus I can't see any pictures on his insta from the gym

He posted them in his story at the top  video vision to show him doing the gym work   try looking there

The Shaun Smith reminds me of the movie Concussion starred by Will Smith. If anyone has seen it you would know it's a brilliant but yet scary reality about the after effects of concussion in the NFL. It seems like it's having an effect on former players like Greg Williams, John Barnes and Shaun Smith.

1 hour ago, A F said:

Defensive forward, if he's going to make it.

HIs old man thinks he should be playing that position.

11 minutes ago, WERRIDEE said:

HIs old man thinks he should be playing that position.

And my old man thinks I should play in the ruck.

His tackling as a burst off the mark seems to be his best trait. If he can land some tackles, keep the ball inside 50 and kick 20 goals for the year, he'll be a player. Let's see.