Round 21 (Non MFC Games)

[ILLDieADemon 804]

Collingwood 91 point loss to Richmond doesn't make the Loss last week so bad.

[Straight Sets Simon 23,113]

Nick Riewoldt on his own in the forward fifty for over a minute as he didn't unnecessarily push up the ground. No Geelong player went near him and after a quick turnover and long kick Riewoldt took an easy mark and goal.

Why do forwards feel the need to push up the ground if they are just going to run back to the forward line anyway?

[monoccular 17,413]

How bad was that "deliberate" against Saints just before ¾ time? It was a pretty crappy but rushed kick when off balance. I guess the umpire's coach will say - "correct decision" when it was just plain wrong. Fortunately didn't cost a goal.

When did penalties for incidents become dependant on whether the victim was injured or not, surely the role of the MRP is to hand down penalties to stop dangerous actions. I'd say it's more luck that apWingard was not seriously injured last night. But because no injury he will get off Scott free. Meanwhile Trengove gets 3 for a beautiful tackle that left Dangerfield groggy

You forgot the penalty that they initially applied to young Viney when Lynch carelessly became sandwiched between a braced Jack and Georgiou. 3 weeks as I recall even though Jack just stopped and was impacted.

http://www.afl.com.au/news/2015-08-21/five-talking-points-hawthorn-v-port-adelaide

"As Wingard was chasing down a ball deep in the Power's forward line, Hodge appeared to catch the Power star high. And to add a wrinkle of complexity to the MRP's job, at the moment of impact Wingard was up against the behind post, with the force of Hodge's bump appearing to knock his head into the post."

Remember, that is -

"appeared to"... "catch" ... him "high".

That's what we're calling a deliberate hip-slam to the back of the head made to an off-balance bent over player while not competing for the ball and requiring a change of momentum to make contact.

One of the things most obvious in that gif is the way Hodge clearly set himself to the angle then pushed off from his left foot. In fact, watching the feet, you can see that he jumped into Wingard's head, rather than simply continuing to run.

I would be interesting to hear someone argue that was his intended trajectory and Wingard being in the way was an accident, because if Wingard wasn't there, Hodge has just spontaneously changed direction in order to jump into the behind post.

Maybe the Hawks are back to their [redacted] habits of old?

Not "back to"......continuing.

Nick Riewoldt on his own in the forward fifty for over a minute as he didn't unnecessarily push up the ground. No Geelong player went near him and after a quick turnover and long kick Riewoldt took an easy mark and goal.

Why do forwards feel the need to push up the ground if they are just going to run back to the forward line anyway?

I totally agree.....the ultra defensive game would change, by necessity, if forwards did this, especially strong fast agile ones. A bit reminiscent of "Pagan's paddock" when Carey was at his peak. We could do the same with Hogan particularly if we get more guys like Salem who can give a long accurate kick off half back.

[titan_uranus 24,970]

Nick Riewoldt on his own in the forward fifty for over a minute as he didn't unnecessarily push up the ground. No Geelong player went near him and after a quick turnover and long kick Riewoldt took an easy mark and goal.

Why do forwards feel the need to push up the ground if they are just going to run back to the forward line anyway?

We've started doing this more. In the last three weeks against Collingwood, North and the Dogs, it looked to me like we were making a clear effort for our forwards to stay forward of halfway, and when the ball was in the middle, inside the forward 50.

[titan_uranus 24,970]

Wowee. They've definitely assembled an impressive young list over the last few drafts.

Five of their current top six possession getters - Steven (25), Riewoldt (32), Montagna (31), Gilbert (29), Geary (27).

They're playing well, exceeding expectations, but let's not forget they are being driven this year by a much older core which contended for flags 4 years ago (add to those players Fisher (33), Dempster (31) and Armitage (27); Scheider (31) also played well when on the senior list).

[Gorgoroth 12,920]

Great game so far.

[monoccular 17,413]

Stevie J staging for a free - didn't con the maggot that time.

[SaberFang 7,151]

Saints 3:30 away from ending Geelong's finals dream.

Come on Saints!!!!

[SaberFang 7,151]

NOT COCKATOO! AHGHHH!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! NO!!!!!!

[monoccular 17,413]

Saints just couldn't buy a goal - and now cats hit the front.

Too much defence.

[Henrietta Lumbago 331]

Stevie J staging for a free - didn't con the maggot that time.

Geelong spare man back, take note melbourne.......

[Gorgoroth 12,920]

Going to be a draw.

[monoccular 17,413]

OMG - draw! Cats have stolen the Tigers' spot at 9.

[daisycutter 29,603]

who woulda thunk.......that complicates the finals run

[Henrietta Lumbago 331]

Pretty happy for the Saints, I have liked the style of footy they have played this year...similar to Melbourne supporters, haven't seen a flag in donkey's years...

[MadAsHell 4,212]

Cats now need to win their last two and hope one of North or Adelaide drop all their remaining games.

Pushing up hill!

[Chook 15,012]

That was one of the most interesting games of footy I’ve watched this year. I love the draw.

[Sir Why You Little 36,963]

See ya Catters...

[Straight Sets Simon 23,113]

I loved watching Holmes, he acquitted himself quite well too.

[Schneider 220]

Last week v Adelaide will be interesting

[Hellaintabadplacetobe 4,294]

Lions percentage copping a hammering. Blues will be nervous.

We are certainties tomorrow!

[SaberFang 7,151]

Saints were robbed at the end. A blatant 50 metre penalty not paid despite a Geelong player running over the mark by a clear 5m, then Bartel running over the line after Savage's behind.

You'd be filthy if you were a Sainter.

[Hellaintabadplacetobe 4,294]

Saints were robbed at the end. A blatant 50 metre penalty not paid despite a Geelong player running over the mark by a clear 5m, then Bartel running over the line after Savage's behind.

You'd be filthy if you were a Sainter.

Yep saw them both.

What about the arm chop on Riewoldt by Bartel i think with 4 mins left inside 50, absolute shocker and the commentators did not even mention it.

[Henrietta Lumbago 331]

It sounds like most of us wanted the Sainters to get up...

[Bombay Airconditioning 6,346]

Stevie J staging for a free - didn't con the maggot that time.

I thought he was staging too but the replay showed he copped high contact from the legs of a StKilda player running past. Wasn't much in it but the umpiring in recent weeks is all over the shop.