Jack Trengove re-injures his navicular (2014) - trade deal off

[Pennant St Dee 13,316]

Something huge is in the wing i believe ( just a feeling) but this is way more than just kids in the draft

Remember. roos is ONLY COACH FOR 2 years more.

This is the pivotal draft.

Next week.

That he is but he must also consider by getting in older players and getting us a few more wins over two seasons only to miss out on two kids who could end up being guns and seeing us and his chosen successor fall backwards would not look good either.

I don't see us giving up 2 & 3 unless we have some absolute guns coming in which I struggle to see with just those two picks even Pick 12 added to those picks isn't going to get us 2 guns IMO

[Coup Cooper 610]

That he is but he must also consider by getting in older players and getting us a few more wins over two seasons only to miss out on two kids who could end up being guns and seeing us and his chosen successor fall backwards would not look good either.

I don't see us giving up 2 & 3 unless we have some absolute guns coming in which I struggle to see with just those two picks even Pick 12 added to those picks isn't going to get us 2 guns IMO

Pick 2 3 and 12 and toumpus for Danger? And a say adelaides first round?

I have no mail or any info.. Just throwin it out there? I'd take it given the draft is no garrantee!

[InVINCEable 358]

Pick 2 3 and 12 and toumpus for Danger? And a say adelaides first round?

I have no mail or any info.. Just throwin it out there? I'd take it given the draft is no garrantee!

Take out Toumpas and Pick 3,and don't ask for Adelaides first rounder.

[beelzebub 23,385]

Something huge is in the wing i believe ( just a feeling) but this is way more than just kids in the draft

Remember. roos is ONLY COACH FOR 2 years more.

This is the pivotal draft.

Next week.

he is hanging around though...

but he will want the team up and running before id imagine

[Demon3 2,541]

not sure we need to be giving away Toump and Watts and Trengove.. 1 of.. and I think sadly Jack T is the one we should dangle. I look at Jack T and just think he is not that damaging, sad as it is.

To quote every footballer's fav movie, its time "to get busy livin, or get busy dyin" we need to get busy living!

[drdrake 3,187]

4 more days of this, then we start to speculate on the draft choices. Good clubs make big decisions to improve their list, this is one. Same as the Bulldogs they should trade out Griffen, the reward for him will be overs by trading with GWS and long term they will win out of this deal.

If we trade Jack we will win in the long run, no idea but it has it's merits. You would want pick 12 plus Richmonds second round pick for Trengove and our second round pick. That then gets you another first round pick plus a mid second round pick which will be enough to land Frost from GWS.

What we then do with picks 2,3 and 12 who knows.

If we finish up on Thursday with Harry O, Garlett, Frost, Stretch and picks 2, 3 and 12 and lose Frawley, Clark and Trengove, are we winners or losers?

[Guest]

4 more days of this, then we start to speculate on the draft choices. Good clubs make big decisions to improve their list, this is one. Same as the Bulldogs they should trade out Griffen, the reward for him will be overs by trading with GWS and long term they will win out of this deal.

If we trade Jack we will win in the long run, no idea but it has it's merits. You would want pick 12 plus Richmonds second round pick for Trengove and our second round pick. That then gets you another first round pick plus a mid second round pick which will be enough to land Frost from GWS.

What we then do with picks 2,3 and 12 who knows.

If we finish up on Thursday with Harry O, Garlett, Frost, Stretch and picks 2, 3 and 12 and lose Frawley, Clark and Trengove, are we winners or losers?

Marginal winners. But this will not be the case - Prepare yourself for a big few days.

[binman 44,180]

Marginal winners. But this will not be the case - Prepare yourself for a big few days.

Will we be marginal, middling or big winners when the trading dust settles?

[Guest]

Will we be marginal, middling or big winners when the trading dust settles?

When trading draft picks, you can never be certain.

That being said, I can confidently state that at the end of the week, we will feel like winners. Have faith.

Edited October 12, 2014 by Guest

[Oneday 248]

Trenners coming up on trade radio in a few minutes

[Guest]

Trade radio summary on Trengove:

"If I were Richmond, I'd rather Sam Blease."

"I don't think he fits in the best 22 with Matt Thomas"

"A lot to give up for a guy who has played 2 games in the last 18 months" (He played 2 games this season, and 20 games last season)

Quality listening.

Edited October 12, 2014 by Guest

[What 18,810]

Trade radio summary on Trengove:

"If I were Richmond, I'd rather Sam Blease."

"I don't think he fits in the best 22 with Matt Thomas"

"A lot to give up for a guy who has played 2 games in the best 18 months" (He played 2 games this season, and 20 games last season)

Quality listening.

they are morons

Nathan Brown is a [censored]

[Mousey 47]

Is Trengove actually coming on this trade show? I need to know cause this is extremely hard to listen to

[Gipsy Danger 1,067]

Trade radio summary on Trengove:

"If I were Richmond, I'd rather Sam Blease."

"I don't think he fits in the best 22 with Matt Thomas"

"A lot to give up for a guy who has played 2 games in the best 18 months" (He played 2 games this season, and 20 games last season)

Quality listening.

In fairness by the time round 1 rolls around it will be 2 games in 18months

[rpfc 28,837]

In fairness by the time round 1 rolls around it will be 2 games in 18months

Yes, but that is idiotic reasoning; Luke Hodge would not have played a game from October to March.

That's 5 months!

Get a game you hack!

[daisycutter 29,795]

In fairness by the time round 1 rolls around it will be 2 games in 18months

that is being w-a-y too generous........they are cretins

[Gipsy Danger 1,067]

Yes, but that is idiotic reasoning; Luke Hodge would not have played a game from October to March.

That's 5 months!

Get a game you hack!

big difference between 5 months off for pre season and 18 months, 2 games and a career threatening foot injury.

I agree with Browny, how do the tigers benefit bringing a bloke like Trenners into the side?

I'm hoping like hell we will keep him.

[Sir Why You Little 37,239]

he is hanging around though...

but he will want the team up and running before id imagine

But this is the draft to get the motor running. It has to be.

We cannot have another year like the last 8.

[Sir Why You Little 37,239]

big difference between 5 months off for pre season and 18 months, 2 games and a career threatening foot injury.

I agree with Browny, how do the tigers benefit bringing a bloke like Trenners into the side?

I'm hoping like hell we will keep him.

Trenners is no good to anyone if he cannot play. I am still trying to work out why the previous coach and medical staff flogged him through 2013 when we all knew he wasn't right.

[S.R.J 418]

If we trade Trengove and land a big fish as part of the process. Is anyone going to remember his name if all of a sudden we start winning? We need to shake our list up for this to happen.

[DemonTux 97]

haven't been able to find any discussion (possibly because I'm a touch lazy, and the Boyd news railroaded my last attempt) but is 3 and 12 enough for pick 1?

Edited October 13, 2014 by DemonTux

[beelzebub 23,385]

If we trade Trengove and land a big fish as part of the process. Is anyone going to remember his name if all of a sudden we start winning? We need to shake our list up for this to happen.

In sure they'll remember his name. As to caring however !!!

[Tyson_Viney_Toumpas 269]

4 more days of this, then we start to speculate on the draft choices. Good clubs make big decisions to improve their list, this is one. Same as the Bulldogs they should trade out Griffen, the reward for him will be overs by trading with GWS and long term they will win out of this deal.

If we trade Jack we will win in the long run, no idea but it has it's merits. You would want pick 12 plus Richmonds second round pick for Trengove and our second round pick. That then gets you another first round pick plus a mid second round pick which will be enough to land Frost from GWS.

What we then do with picks 2,3 and 12 who knows.

If we finish up on Thursday with Harry O, Garlett, Frost, Stretch and picks 2, 3 and 12 and lose Frawley, Clark and Trengove, are we winners or losers?

I think winners but its so hard to judge.

Trengove & Clark haven't played many games in 18 months. Frawley hasn't been his best & then you never know what you're getting from the draft.

I happy to set us up for 10 years with picks 2 & 3. I think Petracca & Brayshaw are rated a lot higher than TS & JT.

Could go either way with a win or loss, but we have to get it right eventually.

[thevil1 421]

I think Petracca & Brayshaw are rated a lot higher than TS & JT.

They sure as hell are as of 2014, but as juniors? Really?? Cause Scully had huge wraps on him a year out from being drafted & Trenners was supposedly the best SA junior since Buckley. Edited October 13, 2014 by thevil1

[jackaub 1,402]

I think winners but its so hard to judge.

Trengove & Clark haven't played many games in 18 months. Frawley hasn't been his best & then you never know what you're getting from the draft.

I happy to set us up for 10 years with picks 2 & 3. I think Petracca & Brayshaw are rated a lot higher than TS & JT.

Could go either way with a win or loss, but we have to get it right eventually.

Winners by a country mile