Nakia Cockatoo

[DeeSpencer 25,477]

If you want to hear a Collingwood supporting bogan talk crap about Cockatoo - https://soundcloud.com/paigecardona/afldraft-podcast-bolters-sliders

[deeko 952]

Gee it's a toughy and im glad it's not me making the decisions. Brayshaw seems a safe blur collar pick and after that it just seems a lottery more than ever this year with bits and pieces players.

Do you risk it in on a possible one hit wonder?

I definitely like the kid from the video and will continue watching his career unfold no matter where he ends up.

I wonder also if he may have been the reason we tried to upgrade pick 23 to 12?

[rpfc 28,263]

He has something about him from that footage.

Some big decisions and development ahead...

[ignition. 1,463]

If you want to hear a Collingwood supporting bogan talk crap about Cockatoo - https://soundcloud.com/paigecardona/afldraft-podcast-bolters-sliders

Hahaha I tried but I couldn't get past the first few minutes.

[spirit of norm smith 16,292]

Nakia Cockatoo... the unlikely #3 may be becoming more likely by the day.

Watch the highlights again. He is Judd crossed with Burgoyne.

A punt ... yes. A risk worth taking ... yes.

[Uncle Fester 2,848]

We could do worse. and have before.

I'd be happy with us taking the chance. Big, strong, fast and a dash of x factor. What's not to like?

[GIRO 63]

I bet we won't take him and he'll be the best player from this years draft plays like dustin martin with more speed !!

[jabberwocky 2,301]

Bearing in mind that the game was against an U17 team albeit the best ones in the land.

Edited November 11, 2014 by jabberwocky

[Demanding Success 298]

Bearing in mind that the game was against an U17 team albeit the best ones in the land.

This is a huge factor. People talking about his one game. This was not against even the best players of his own age group. Not against picking him if the recruiters who have much more detail on him think he is the right pick. But don't get to carried away on how good he looks from one game against junior opposition. I also can't think of a single top 3 pick from the NT. Or even a top 10 pick. There have been some terrific players from the NT but they are coming from along way back in elite development.

[Demon3 2,541]

No thanks, and I know all picks are speculative, but for me its Brayshaw and McCartin.

[jabberwocky 2,301]

This is a huge factor. People talking about his one game. This was not against even the best players of his own age group. Not against picking him if the recruiters who have much more detail on him think he is the right pick. But don't get to carried away on how good he looks from one game against junior opposition. I also can't think of a single top 3 pick from the NT. Or even a top 10 pick. There have been some terrific players from the NT but they are coming from along way back in elite development.

It's all fun and games being a recruiter. In that one game Cockatoo treats his opposition with contempt, out-muscling them and out running them, he clearly had physical dominance over them. So a recruiter has to decide how much of that was due to the age difference and how much of that will transfer to AFL level in time. It's why anyone who says we must take this player or that player can't be taken seriously. There are so many factors to consider when selecting these kids.

Unlike RPFC though I don't necessarily see the inexact science of recruiting of 18 year olds as a massive problem The intrigue of it all adds something to the game for me. Clubs have shown that if you recruit and develop well you can rise quickly. We just haven't done it well in recent times. We can whinge about the system or get better at it. A lot of people wil beg to differ with me, but the team who makes the recruiting decisions make or break the club. Bailey and Neeld as coaches never stood a chance.

If you were ordering a player purely on a MFC needs basis then Cockatoo is the type. Line breaking mid who uses pace and strength to clear the contest is what we lack. That said we still take best available.

Over to you Jason.

Edited November 11, 2014 by jabberwocky

[rpfc 28,263]

Unlike RPFC though I don't necessarily see the inexact science of recruiting of 18 year olds as a massive problem The intrigue of it all adds something to the game for me. Clubs have shown that if you recruit and develop well you can rise quickly. We just haven't done it well in recent times. We can whinge about the system or get better at it.

I would do both.

The AFL is constantly trying to improve the game, if they spent half as much energy improving the recruitment and contract infrastructure they would the game immeasurably by having more even teams.

[jabberwocky 2,301]

I would do both.

The AFL is constantly trying to improve the game, if they spent half as much energy improving the recruitment and contract infrastructure they would the game immeasurably by having more even teams.

I think we can agree to disagree even though I see some merits in raising the draft age by a year and spending an extra year in the TAC.

We are the poster boy for being a poor club that recruits poorly, and there are others like Port Adelaide have shown what can be done. I don't think raising the draft age is necessarily going to assist equalisation.

[rpfc 28,263]

I think we can agree to disagree even though I see some merits in raising the draft age by a year and spending an extra year in the TAC.

We are the poster boy for being a poor club that recruits poorly, and there are others like Port Adelaide have shown what can be done. I don't think raising the draft age is necessarily going to assist equalisation.

The bottom clubs get the highest picks and raising the draft age will allow clubs to have a better idea of the talent they are selecting.

The bottom teams get better players than those above them, and then are able to compete.

And evenness of the teams is a bit different to the equalisation argument. Although it is linked.

I was more pointing out that the number of blow outs affects the entertainment value of the game and having a greater spread of talent will of course help that.

[Bossdog 2,002]

Nakia Cockatoo... the unlikely #3 may be becoming more likely by the day.

Watch the highlights again. He is Judd crossed with Burgoyne.

A punt ... yes. A risk worth taking ... yes.

Wow......You can tell this by watching a 3 min highlights package......Just WOW.....

[skills32 229]

This kid has good credentials; plays for Southern Districts in Darwin,

Yep the same team that Jako played for. And not Mark Jako either.

[DeeSpencer 25,477]

I'd avoid Indigenous players from remote backgrounds. Or even those with heavy ties to remote backgrounds. Maybe even anyone from Alice Springs.

Josh Simpson, Zephi Skinner, Jurrah, Wona now Barry. For those with homes and hearts in communities it's a lot to leave behind.

If Cockatoo is from down town Darwin just like Matty Whelan and Davey or from Bunbury in WA like Jetta then I don't think his go home risk is that significant.

There's no AFL team that plays in Darwin.........

Well besides us!

[Nasher 33,607]

I've just purged the thread.

If you racially stereotype, expect your post and all ones after it to be deleted. Some may think racial stereotypes don't equal racism - well I think it does and will moderate accordingly, and this is not up for debate.

Cheers.

[Machsy 2,858]

would gladly take this kid at pick 3

Surely he is a better option than both McCartin and Lever

Yes, surely...

FFS.

[Grapeviney 9,712]

Thread's been purged a second time. If you want to keep arguing the point (or fill up the thread with other nonsense), you're in for a holiday.

Nasher's post was pretty clear, as is the thread title.

[Bitter but optimistic 22,219]

Thread's been purged a second time. If you want to keep arguing the point (or fill up the thread with other nonsense), you're in for a holiday.

Nasher's post was pretty clear, as is the thread title.

Are you sir echo grape?

[Bitter but optimistic 22,219]

I've just purged the thread.

If you racially stereotype, expect your post and all ones after it to be deleted. Some may think racial stereotypes don't equal racism - well I think it does and will moderate accordingly, and this is not up for debate.

Cheers.

I realize this a privately owned site Gnasher but subjective interpretations of what is racist and what are not are dangerous, potentially inflammatory and can in fact give credence to [censored]. Let the [censored] expose themselves - most people are reasonable and will see through the [censored].

[Biffen 12,940]

Not all [censored] are racist .

[Bitter but optimistic 22,219]

Not all [censored] are racist .

Indeed Biff, but unfortunately the [censored] don't get it!

[DeeSpencer 25,477]

To all the racists in this thread. I think Cockatoo will have the final word.