4 hours ago, ProDee said:

Wasn't that Silvagni he outmarked ?

He outmarked Silvagni. 

But he outbodied Casboult in a 1 on 1 marking contest 30m out in the 2nd quarter. 

Pound for pound. 

2 minutes ago, Deestroy All said:

He outmarked Silvagni. 

But he outbodied Casboult in a 1 on 1 marking contest 30m out in the 2nd quarter. 

Pound for pound. 

Yeah, just saw the photo on the Foxfooty article re Jetta.

Great article by Anna Harrington.  I've liked a few of her articles.

He got 1 coaches vote. That is criminal.

Its likely that Bolton didnt give him a single vote.  Sad.

10 hours ago, monoccular said:

Don't insult idiots!

Don't argue with them either. They will bring you down to their level, then bet you with experience.

13 minutes ago, Devil is in the Detail said:

Don't argue with them either. They will bring you down to their level, then bet you with experience.

Or, to put it another way...

"Arguing with idiots is like playing chess with a pigeon...

...No matter how good you are, the bird is going to crap on the board and strut around like it won anyway"...!!

14 hours ago, ProDee said:

Wasn't that Silvagni he outmarked ?

Nah, I remember that one too but pretty sure in the Punt Road pocket the ball was kicked into a  bunch of players. Nev came from behind and spoiled Casboult - I said outmarked but it was a spoil. Hard to do for a small bloke...

13 hours ago, DemonAndrew said:

Idiot Richmond supporter just tried to tell me he should've been pinged for holding the man on Simpson

Idiot Richmond supporters are idiots

The way I saw it was that Simpson turned to try and block Jetta

2 minutes ago, jnrmac said:

Nah, I remember that one too but pretty sure in the Punt Road pocket the ball was kicked into a  bunch of players. Nev came from behind and spoiled Casboult - I said outmarked but it was a spoil. Hard to do for a small bloke...

He has a remarkable vertical leap. Hence why he can compete with the bigger markers.

13 hours ago, bingers said:

He also has Frostie to thank for helping him out.

Exactly.  Frost went to cover Thomas and massively helped Nev out.  Nev's reaction time to spot Simpson running past and get over to cover him, then out-body him and win the ball was outstanding.  Great defensive team play that almost certainly saved the game for us.

Nev named in AFL Team of the Week.  His form is becoming hard to ignore!

3 hours ago, Vagg said:

Or, to put it another way...

"Arguing with idiots is like playing chess with a pigeon...

...No matter how good you are, the bird is going to crap on the board and strut around like it won anyway"...!!

Can I use that Vagg? Very good mate.

3 minutes ago, old dee said:

Can I use that Vagg? Very good mate.

LOL.  Absolutely!  (I can't claim credit for it anyway.  Found that little gem on Facebook!  - 'bout all FB is good for, mind you, tossing up the occasional gem like that!)

16 hours ago, Skuit said:

I pose this question: what makes Nev such a good player from a defensive perspective? Is it his balance or centre-of-gravity? Strength and tenacity? Positioning or body-work? Steady nerves and execution? He just biologically (as to AFL) seems to have no right to be as good as he is.

I've seen a lot of blokes look at him, and they say to themselves "no, too tough for me"

Jetta has been doing this stuff for three years now, it's only that this one particular play was at a crucial stage that everyone is taking notice.

... which I have been having a running arguement about with some Blues [censored] at work for 2 days now. 

Will not accept that the contest with Simpson at the end was fair, or the "illegal interference" on Thomas in the play just before that.

I just laugh at him, as I did when he claimed we were gifted 5 umpire goals from directly in front while they had none...  

Delusional to the point where I dont even bother trying to argue anymore. Just nod and smile

1 minute ago, JTR said:

... which I have been having a running arguement about with some Blues [censored] at work for 2 days now. 

Will not accept that the contest with Simpson at the end was fair, or the "illegal interference" on Thomas in the play just before that.

I just laugh at him, as I did when he claimed we were gifted 5 umpire goals from directly in front while they had none...  

Delusional to the point where I dont even bother trying to argue anymore. Just nod and smile

we certainly were gifted some goals but not by the umpire, but by poor defensive play by carlscum players

3 hours ago, BigFez said:

Exactly.  Frost went to cover Thomas and massively helped Nev out.  Nev's reaction time to spot Simpson running past and get over to cover him, then out-body him and win the ball was outstanding.  Great defensive team play that almost certainly saved the game for us.

I couldnt go unfortunately. Wish i could. I so much prefer watching footy live. I sit at the top od the ponsford where i would have seen what simpson had ahead of him if he won that ball.

The tv angle shits me. Just a tight focus, including the replays. Why not at least on the replay show the down the down the ground shot.

Ivw heard 3 diff versions of what was ahead of simpson from the media. Can someone who was tell me for certain please?

16 hours ago, TheCurseisBroken said:

8:53 of this video

 

 

58 minutes ago, binman said:

I couldnt go unfortunately. Wish i could. I so much prefer watching footy live. I sit at the top od the ponsford where i would have seen what simpson had ahead of him if he won that ball.

The tv angle shits me. Just a tight focus, including the replays. Why not at least on the replay show the down the down the ground shot.

Ivw heard 3 diff versions of what was ahead of simpson from the media. Can someone who was tell me for certain please?

Check 8:50 ish of this video

3 minutes ago, Devil is in the Detail said:

 

Check 8:50 ish of this video

They were OUT!

47 minutes ago, BigFez said:

They were OUT!

I watch that video this morning and couldn't believe how important that play was.

53 minutes ago, Devil is in the Detail said:

I watch that video this morning and couldn't believe how important that play was.

Defenders get it tough. A forward kicks the wiinning goal and is a hero. A defender saves a match losing goal and is doing his job.

1 hour ago, Devil is in the Detail said:

I watch that video this morning and couldn't believe how important that play was.

I knew they were out watching on the TV, but I didn't realise just how out they were.  Nev loses that one on one and they could have strolled in and raffled the goal.

4 minutes ago, Uncle Fester said:

I knew they were out watching on the TV, but I didn't realise just how out they were.  Nev loses that one on one and they could have strolled in and raffled the goal.

Nev actually went to ground. If Frostie hadn't come in, Carlton were away. Having said that, Nev's second effort once he got to his feet was great. I think it was a joint effort, but Frostie's efforts seem to have been overlooked.  

2 minutes ago, bingers said:

Nev actually went to ground. If Frostie hadn't come in, Carlton were away. Having said that, Nev's second effort once he got to his feet was great. I think it was a joint effort, but Frostie's efforts seem to have been overlooked.  

Not by me. Loved the shrug and the afterburners. Belief in himself when everything was on the line. I'm really loving the trade deal that got us him, ANB and Omac.

3 hours ago, JTR said:

... which I have been having a running arguement about with some Blues [censored] at work for 2 days now. 

Will not accept that the contest with Simpson at the end was fair, or the "illegal interference" on Thomas in the play just before that.

I just laugh at him, as I did when he claimed we were gifted 5 umpire goals from directly in front while they had none...  

Delusional to the point where I dont even bother trying to argue anymore. Just nod and smile

 

The Jetta contact with Thomas was a legitimate attempt to go for the ball. Besides Thomas won the ball and handballed it to Simpson. Simpson initiated contact with Jetta. Nothing to complain about there.