The Clash Jumper farce

[Leoncelli_36 2,264]

I know that many think this topic has been flogged to death..but this clash Jumper situation needs to be fixed. On Saturday we wore a predominantly white jumper. A jumper that looked more like st kilda ..we incorporated a colour that clashed more. I then sit down Sunday to watch the Eagles v Dogs and see that they are wearing all red. The same all red the AFL supposedly banned us from wearing as they deemed it a dark colour. I realise nothing can be done about it this season but we need to get firm on this issue. We are the team of the red and blue..i dont care if its red with blue yoke or blue with red..we are not white and never had been..well apparently once in 1858 according to schwabb ..i want the footy club for once to stand up. A red jumper would eliminate all clashes. Richmond, Footscray, Collingwood, Essendon have all held firm..we should not compromise our brand. Fix it please !

[old dee 23,787]

I know that many think this topic has been flogged to death..but this clash Jumper situation needs to be fixed. On Saturday we wore a predominantly white jumper. A jumper that looked more like st kilda ..we incorporated a colour that clashed more. I then sit down Sunday to watch the Eagles v Dogs and see that they are wearing all red. The same all red the AFL supposedly banned us from wearing as they deemed it a dark colour. I realise nothing can be done about it this season but we need to get firm on this issue. We are the team of the red and blue..i dont care if its red with blue yoke or blue with red..we are not white and never had been..well apparently once in 1858 according to schwabb ..i want the footy club for once to stand up. A red jumper would eliminate all clashes. Richmond, Footscray, Collingwood, Essendon have all held firm..we should not compromise our brand. Fix it please !

Yes it has.

Lets move on and concentrate on winning games.

Do that and the clash jumper will look great.

[Moonshadow 17,676]

The clash jumper worked on Sat night. It clashed.

[Gipsy Danger 1,067]

I just want to see a clash jumper that you can actually recognise that Melbourne is playing

[Gorgoroth 12,947]

I love clash jumper topics, some usually gets banned for a week.

(Runs off to make popcorn)

[binman 42,896]

I know that many think this topic has been flogged to death..but this clash Jumper situation needs to be fixed. On Saturday we wore a predominantly white jumper. A jumper that looked more like st kilda ..we incorporated a colour that clashed more. I then sit down Sunday to watch the Eagles v Dogs and see that they are wearing all red. The same all red the AFL supposedly banned us from wearing as they deemed it a dark colour. I realise nothing can be done about it this season but we need to get firm on this issue. We are the team of the red and blue..i dont care if its red with blue yoke or blue with red..we are not white and never had been..well apparently once in 1858 according to schwabb ..i want the footy club for once to stand up. A red jumper would eliminate all clashes. Richmond, Footscray, Collingwood, Essendon have all held firm..we should not compromise our brand. Fix it please !

I don't really mind the white jumper but how stupid was it to have a clash jumper that clashed? Why wouldn't common sense prevail and we wear our standard jumper which doesn't clash with the saints. Or have two clash jumpers? Id on't mind the red idea but what about our current training jumper which looks great and would have been perfect against the saints. Correct me if i'm wrong but don't EPL teams have more than 1 clash strip?

[Dr. Gonzo 24,207]

It shouldn't be too difficult to just reverse our jumper so it is red with navy blue yoke. Would eliminate clashes and preserves our jumper to the greatest extent possible considering a change must be made. The thing that gets me is it's all well and good to not care during the H&A season but if we ever make another GF I want it to be in our traditional navy blue and red yoke not whatever white design they come up with that year.

[Red N Blue Society 165]

Thanks for bringing this worthwhile subject up.

That mostly white Clash jumper is an abomination & belongs with the horrid Grey one we produced. The Bin.

It really.... Really Irks me..

Are we Sydney or are we Melbourne?????? Looks alot like a some other team.

Get rid of it ASAP Melbourne Footy Club!!! I cant believe its still used.

The training top would be much more ideal...states MFC on the front and has red & blue....NOT WHITE!

We are not the dogs....we are not Sydney....clean it up MFC for Demons sake!

Peter Jackson...Glenn Bartlett...If your reading please look into this and replace it!

[old dee 23,787]

I love clash jumper topics, some usually gets banned for a week.

(Runs off to make popcorn)

I love fresh popcorn

[All the Jacks 99]

Toumpas kick to Saints player in the open was enough for me..wearing that clash jumper against St Kilda. Why add white to our jumper making us red, navy and white against red, black and white?

I like the reverse idea I think

[biggestred 5,076]

agree. only saw the last 10 mins but I definitely saw a couple of occasions players kick or handball to a saint - or go to and realise it was a saint not a dee. a mostly red jumper would have solved that.

or, gee, just the one that worked for the last 150 years?

[old dee 23,787]

I am remind of tilting at windmills

[Gipsy Danger 1,067]

I don't really mind the white jumper but how stupid was it to have a clash jumper that clashed? Why wouldn't common sense prevail and we wear our standard jumper which doesn't clash with the saints. Or have two clash jumpers? Id on't mind the red idea but what about our current training jumper which looks great and would have been perfect against the saints. Correct me if i'm wrong but don't EPL teams have more than 1 clash strip?

Don't the Western Bulldogs have two strips? Pretty sure they have a red jumper with a blue and white hoop and also a white one with blue and bed hoops

[Canberra Demon 159]

Don't the Western Bulldogs have two strips? Pretty sure they have a red jumper with a blue and white hoop and also a white one with blue and bed hoops

Yup the have the three..

[Gorgoroth 12,947]

I love fresh popcorn

Grab a chair, I got plenty.

[Gipsy Danger 1,067]

Yup the have the three..

Yeah I meant to say 2 clash strips and obviously the home jumper

[Sir Why You Little 37,033]

Don't get me started.

[old dee 23,787]

Don't get me started.

Please hold fire wyl.

For your blood pressures sake go and make a cuppa

[Bring-Back-Powell 14,817]

Yeah I've always the thought the white clash jumper was the key reason why we're so crap....

[old dee 23,787]

Yeah I've always the thought the white clash jumper was the key reason why we're so crap....

Oh thank you BBP

[binman 42,896]

Yeah I meant to say 2 clash strips and obviously the home jumper

Ta, Then why don't we have 2 (or even 3) clash strips? As i said everyone seems to love the new training jumper so why not that one? It is blue with the red MFC insignia. To avoid a clash with say Carlton you could have a second clash strip with red and a blue MFC insignia. Eveyone happy and the club getting some more money from merch. Simples.

[Satyriconhome 10,857]

Maybe if you are lying on your side and didn't notice the black shorts on the St Kilda players

[biggestred 5,076]

actually the only problem with ours (apart from the white) is the big blue patches under the arms. get rid of these and they would really be different.

[Satyriconhome 10,857]

Ta, Then why don't we have 2 (or even 3) clash strips? As i said everyone seems to love the new training jumper so why not that one? It is blue with the red MFC insignia. To avoid a clash with say Carlton you could have a second clash strip with red and a blue MFC insignia. Eveyone happy and the club getting some more money from merch. Simples.

Actually chap the training jumper is outselling both other jumpers at the moment, considering one myself

[Ted Lasso 19,507]

We also need a new logo