When we were good

[Straight Sets Simon 23,113]

- this was the first of three games which we needed to win to make finals, having lost 7 in a row.

Amazing to see Melbourne beating the likes of Ablett, Bartel, Kelly and Johnson. I still maintain our team was pretty good back then.

[Guest]

Watching the 2010 highlights was kind of bittersweet. It showed what we could have been had we been developed properly. There was a verve and spunk in our play when we were 'on'.Now, it seems that any spirit has been beaten out of the boys. Very sad.

It should be mentioned though that those videos didn't show some of the pantsings we received from 2008 to 2011.

[Roost It 1,434]

Highlight for mine was Whitten Oval 1987

Haven't sung the song with a train load of strangers that many times and with that much passion since.

Great days

[CHAMP 347]

My God angrydee you are as old as me.

I was there as well, standing on 26oz beer cans in standing room in front of my Dad so i could see.

which end were you?

Long gone now mate over half a century.

we are living on past glories long gone.

A good thing your Dad didn't have half-a-dozen bottles in his kit bag.

[Guest]

I will say this again about the Daniher era... Anyone who praises the debacle post 2007 and says that ND's era was an unmitigated disaster is a muppet. Frustrating at times but I will say it was actually nice to look forward to going to the footy instead of walking away feeling numb and embarrassed to be a Demon.

[CHAMP 347]

Highlight for mine was Whitten Oval 1987

Haven't sung the song with a train load of strangers that many times and with that much passion since.

Great days

Yes that and the glorious sequence which followed. Just a shame that it ended so tragically.

Eishold's 'goal', which anyone's Grandma could have slotted, would have done it.

[cowboy_from_hell 2,390]

2010. So up and down but the players did play with freedom. We needed to fine tune our defense but we had what I thought was something to work with. We would lose to our 2010 side by 100 plus. Also Brad Green was such a good player and that young bloke in the number 4 seemed to show a bit up forward. What happened to him?

[Demon Dynasty 16,000]

Was sitting about 15 rows back at the Punt rd. end.

Wet arse no fish and a memory that still warms me 53 years later.

I pity our current younger supporters - the few that are there- in 50 years what will their football going memories be?

They'll have the inept one's memorable after match pressers to look back on. Worst coach I've seen since Denis Jones.

Now now Angry, don't be too harsh on the late Denis Jones. Even he had the jump, ever so slightly, on Neeld.

The 3 worst win loss records of any MFC coach (during home & away/regular season) in order are:

3. Denis Jones: 1978

Matches 22 Wins 5 Draws 0 Losses 17 Percentage 22.73

2. Eddie Drohan: 1910

Matches 18 Wins 4 Draws 0 Losses 14 Percentage 22.22

1. Mark Neeld: 2012 to present

Matches 29 Wins 5 Draws 0 Losses 24 Percentage 17.24

Edited May 15, 2013 by Rusty Nails

[stinga81 210]

Good thread.

*Gets out DVD of 87 Elimination Final*.

Presses play.

Night on the couch sorted.

[Demon Dynasty 16,000]

Our last Senior Premiership at any level. I'll never forget Giles off the ground handball to Bailey for the winning goal. Nor having to scale the metal fence on the boundary without slipping off on a dewy night feeling a sense of surprise, shock but also great elation! From memory I think they call it...WINNING!

[ youtube ]

[ /youtube ]

[Deano74 156]

It hasn't always been like this.

Post videos and news articles here of the better times.

Dees comeback vs freo

Dees sticking it to Essendon

2000 Qualifying Final

2000 was a great year, except for the Big one.

You notice the mix of stars and the young Green and Bruce.

Makes you think how would someone Like a Watts go, given he was in the same side, Besides the Ox, Yze, etc

[deeko 937]

Those who think its too soon to sack Neeld MUST WATCH THIS TAPE! YES YOU MUST.

It's Enough to make one sick. Look at Trengove taking huge marks, Watts outstanding, Stef Martin perhaps best on ground,Moloney terrific, Gysberts ok. So many of the present players performing as they did then, but can't now. Just watch it and realize we have some very good players, despite what the coach has done to the list. Watch the gameplan.

Urge EVERYONE TO WATCH IT! PLEASE!!!

They looked so confident against Essendon and wanted to take the play on! No wonder so many of us were getting ahead of ourselves, there was so much to look forward to. I was there that night with three mates who follow the bombers and I remember leaving and they were all talking about how we are surely to become the next AFL powerhouse!

Was so exciting with goal hungry forwards like Green and Jurrah (I mean goal hungry in a good way and how you want your pocket/flankers to be) we had an awesome up and coming midfield with Gys absolutely starring that night, Moloney smashing through walls and what about Trenners hanger! Where did that come from? WHERE DID THAT GO????

Thanks for the posting of these videos, reminds me why I have such a sick obsession with this club

[Straight Sets Simon 23,113]

I don't think people realise just how big of a loss Jurrah has been. Personal issues aside, he needed to work on his fitness and defensive side of his game bit but I think that (like many things) was overplayed by Neeld.

EDIT: What I notice from the Essendon game in 2011 is that a lot of what Melbourne does is one first option. No one is trying to do too much and there often is a teammate nearby in a good position and and on the move.

Edited May 15, 2013 by Clint Bizkit

[Deetective Sgt. Taggert 380]

I remember being out collecting firewood in 1993 and listening to the radio to the Dees thrash the tigers by 20 goals.

Still sticks in my mind as I remember the battle between the flashy gun full forward Allen Jakovich and my fav player at the time ruck rover Andy Lovell for the most goals of the day. All day they went goal for goal and finished with 8 apiece.

Would love to find footage of that one.

Here's the stats of the game, few names in that list that invoke some good memories

http://stats.rleague.com/afl/stats/games/1993/111419930822.html

My earliest football memory is watching this game. I was sitting right near the cheersquad and never had so much fun in my life! In fact, I was reflecting on this game after we kicked 12 in the last quarter against GWS as I don't reckoned I'd cheered so much since then...

[stueyspencer no12 73]

great phrase!

I remember the game very well. In 1958 it rained on the morning of thei GF and we lost to a very untalented side. Again in 1960 we were by far the best side in the comp.

In 1960 I had a Sat morning job cleaning up in a city milk bar. Imagine my concern when in late morning it rained. Indeed there was a huge thunderstorm. "this will let the bastards back into it I thought". As it turned out it was wonderful, delicious! I don't think the Pies scored until the second quarter. They kicked their 2nd goal in the last quarter. Very sweet revenge.

[stueyspencer no12 73]

I will say this again about the Daniher era... Anyone who praises the debacle post 2007 and says that ND's era was an unmitigated disaster is a muppet. Frustrating at times but I will say it was actually nice to look forward to going to the footy instead of walking away feeling numb and embarrassed to be a Demon.

You are dead right Colin. It was a great run. From 1987 until 2006 we played finals 13 times. Without checking I think 2 grand finals

And 5 prelims. I get bloody irritated with those who say tlhe club has been hopeless for 50 years.

[Deetective Sgt. Taggert 380]

Videos I've stumbled across over the years:

- this was the first of three games which we needed to win to make finals, having lost 7 in a row.

- this was the second of those three games we needed to win.

Whatever you views on Daniher as coach, you gotta love his pure elation on beating the dogs. Heart warming stuff.

[ashdemons22 235]

The famous night when we got the label the future powerhouse team. Beating the undefeated Brisbane with the two key forwards Fevola and Brown. The two great hope kids Scully Trengrove starring that night. Such hope, What a long time ago round 5 2010 feels like.

[Norm Smith's Curse 2,078]

Highlights for me were just about every game of the 2004 season watching Scott Thompson carve it up time and time again in the midfield. Yze was always kicking goals from outrageous positions. I think big al Nicholson was still around.

one particular memory I enjoyed was a game in 2004 against Carlton where we won by over 100 points of I remember.

but other than 87 and 88 plus our side in 2000 the other year and season I loved as when we beat the saints in 2006 qualifying final after they got ahead at quarter time - grant Thomas's last game as coach. They said we won't the Victorian grand final that night finishing higher than any other Victorian side.

cam Bruce had some great seasons as well.

when you watch the daniher or northey years you realize just how shameful we are now.

bring back Nathan Carroll - sorry I jest - but Scott Thompson leaving was the first step in our decline. They changed the rules on white and turncoat jolly left.

bailey and neeld are way behind.

[Norm Smith's Curse 2,078]

Sorry won not won't - auto correct!

[Norm Smith's Curse 2,078]

Kick it to neitz!!!

[Norm Smith's Curse 2,078]

And as a reminder - only three clubs have won more premierships than us....

[thaipantsman 180]

1976 final round v magpies at Victoria Park. Won easily. Sadly missed the finals JUST. Hinged on result at Western oval Bulldogs v Blues. Dees were great in

76with guys like Wells and Flower leading the way.

[thaipantsman 180]

Need another Neitz!

[thaipantsman 180]

1976 final round v magpies at Victoria Park. Won easily. Sadly missed the finals JUST. Hinged on result at Western oval Bulldogs v Blues. Dees were great in

76with guys like Wells and Flower leading the way.