My 3 word player analysis V Brisbane

[joeboy 3,160]

Trengove - hesitant and slow

Grimes - performed as expected

N.Jones - an unexpected passenger

Watts - only second gear

Frawley - good without ball

Byrnes - played his part

Sylvia - was always trying

McKenzie - presence not justified

Rodan - gave little drive

Blease - 5 minute performance

Garland - easily our best

Terlich - ugly but effective

Pederson - wasted a position

McDonald - mistake-riddled performance

Evans - unsighted after first

Tapscott - tough and effective

Davey - couldn't get involved

Gawn - showed encouraging signs

Howe - playing after first ?

Jamar - enjoyed Moloney's presence

Bail - regularly fluffed possessions

Jones - tried but flawed

Edited April 28, 2013 by joeboy

[Straight Sets Simon 23,113]

I've missed your analysis, joeboy.

For what it's worth I think you are pretty much spot on with your assessment.

[Little Richard 6,216]

Terlich?

[Lordweaver 235]

trengrove slow,

grimes good but too light for midfield imo,

both jones had a go,

watts good 2 nice goals,

frawley good,

byrnes ok,

Sylvia good,

mc kenzie not great, will be better for run

rodan - tried but couldn't get into space

, blease good in patches took them on,

garland good,

Pederson didn't do much,

mc Donald too slow,

evans good contributor like him,

tapscott tough and that's about all,

Davey ok didn't have much chance to make an impact,

Gawn impressive,

Howe went quiet but was promising early,

Jamar good,

Bail good

[Lordweaver 235]

moloney - very good

[Arrow 1,257]

Trengove - hesitant and slow

Grimes - performed as expected

N.Jones - an unexpected passenger

Watts - only second gear

Frawley - good without ball

Byrnes - played his part

Sylvia - was always trying

McKenzie - presence not justified

Rodan - gave little drive

Blease - 5 minute performance

Garland - easily our best

Terlich - ugly but effective

Pederson - wasted a position

McDonald - mistake-riddled performance

Evans - unsighted after first

Tapscott - tough and effective

Davey - couldn't get involved

Gawn - showed encouraging signs

Howe - playing after first ?

Jamar - enjoyed Moloney's presence

Bail - regularly fluffed possessions

Jones - tried but flawed

You've got to be ****ing me. He played as a small defender on Zorko, who was left unattended all day and all his goals were unopposed, and offensively, his last name would be more suited as turnover. Mostly good but Terlich is way out of his depth.

Whilst on the topic of out of depth and the 3 word analysis;

Sam Blease sucks.

[Nascent 8,652]

Bail burnt his team mates on three seperate occasions to have a shot on goal. I like him as a player but he needs to improve his decision making. Not that he's alone in that area.

[Gorgoroth 12,712]

I thought father Garland, Byrnes was possibly our best. Other than when he kicked into the man on the mark.....

[QueensBirthday 186]

Trengove - Obviously lacking pace
Grimes - Turnovers ruined it (C'mon, AFL captains don't do that (censored))
N.Jones - Toweled up today (By Raines, of all people...)
Watts - Talent, lacking fitness
Frawley - Second efforts PLEASE!
Byrnes - Good in patches
Sylvia - Really impressed today
McKenzie - Lacking touch, imagination
Rodan - Tried heart out
Blease - 5 minute performance (exactly)
Garland - Very impessed, thankyou
Terlich - Good defensive run
Pederson - Dumb positioning, what the (censored) are you on?
McDonald - Don't give ball!! (Otherwise good.)
Evans - Excellent run all day. (Unsighted after first - He wasn't unsighted, Mark Neeld through him in defense to do the running others didn't want to do. Looking at you Jack Watts)
Tapscott - Becoming a player (He's playing like an AFL player and will get better. Tough as nails!)
Davey - Tried hard, unfortunate
Gawn - Brilliant contested footy
Howe - Tried all day
Jamar - Game plan please. (Despite perceptions, the ruckman have to be very smart to hit to advantage and be creative with centre breaks. Just didn't have it.)
Bail - Glory hound, selfish
M. Jones - Ran for us!!

[Forest Demon 4,681]

Bail burnt his team mates on three seperate occasions to have a shot on goal. I like him as a player but he needs to improve his decision making. Not that he's alone in that area.

Rohan Bail has one or two chances a game where he should convert, but he rarely converts on the run. If he could take those chances, that turns an average 16 disposal game where he burns a couple of chances, to a 16 disposal, 2 goal performance which is decent.

[ThreeOneSix 954]

You've got to be ****ing me. He played as a small defender on Zorko, who was left unattended all day and all his goals were unopposed, and offensively, his last name would be more suited as turnover. Mostly good but Terlich is way out of his depth.

Whilst on the topic of out of depth and the 3 word analysis;

Sam Blease sucks.

So Zorko did have an opponent after all.

[Nascent 8,652]

Rohan Bail has one or two chances a game where he should convert, but he rarely converts on the run. If he could take those chances, that turns an average 16 disposal game where he burns a couple of chances, to a 16 disposal, 2 goal performance which is decent.

That’s the problem. He misses shots he isn't likely to convert while ignoring team mates in a better position. I'd much rather a 16 disposal 2 goal assist game than a 16 disposal and 2 behinds game.

[Forest Demon 4,681]

That’s the problem. He misses shots he isn't likely to convert while ignoring team mates in a better position. I'd much rather a 16 disposal 2 goal assist game than a 16 disposal and 2 behinds game.

I agree, but I think any decent league footballer should be slotting 80-90% of those chances as opposed to the the 20-30% that Bail does. Either way, whether he takes them on or lays it off, it isn't good enough. In saying that, I do like Bail and think he can get there, but he either needs to take those chances or turn them into assists.