Demonland 74,637 Posted June 21, 2012 Posted June 21, 2012 DIGGING DEEP by Whispering Jack That wily old campaigner Kevin Sheedy had to dig deep into his bag of tricks to come up with a message for this week's game between the fledgling GWS Giants and Melbourne. Instead of informing all and sundry that his team, composed of mainly pimply faced teenagers mixed in with a handful of broken down old hacks and two or three players poached for nothing from other clubs considered it an honour to grace the wonderful ground which really gave birth to our native game, Sheedy couldn't help but go feral by baiting Melbourne fans with stereotypes about visiting the snow and with tales about how his club lured Tom Scully away from the club and into the fleshpots of Rooty Hill. As with much of what Sheedy says and does these days, it's all smoke and mirrors stuff - deception to mask the inadequacy of his team which was put together with the money and influence of a higher power being the AFL. There was no recruiting acumen and no finesse involved. The Giants' recruiters picked heir marks, offered more than their current clubs could possibly pay and had them hook, line and sinker. Clubs whose investments in the game were garnered through a century and a half of the hard slog had players pirated by people using their money. Talk about insult and injury! The truth of the matter is that Sheedy's new franchise is bleeding the AFL of millions of dollars to gain the sport a foothold in a new heartland in the western suburbs of a city that isn't interested the game at all. You only had to look at the rows and rows of empty seats at Skoda Stadium where the visiting Tiger fans almost outnumbered the bewildered looking locals at last week's affair to tell you that it's just not working. The truth is that Sheedy's ploy is a total distraction. An attempt to move the focus away from the fact that there's a game to be played and won and onto personalities like Scully, who jumped ship at the first opportunity to make a bigger buck (and good luck to him if he can get paid for routinely producing less on the field than half a dozen of his pubescent teammates) or James McDonald who, quite frankly, must have been embarrassed by the coach's suggestion that he be made captain for the day just so he could stick it up the fans who supported Junior so well for more than a decade. The first game between Melbourne and Greater Western Sydney Giants deserves much more than the piffling build up and humbuggery of Kevin Sheedy. It deserves to be taken seriously as a game of football for four points and not as a circus. Unfortunately, that’s exactly what Sheedy has made it. Hopefully, Mark Neeld won’t take the bait. THE GAME Melbourne v. GWS Giants at the MCG – Sunday 26 June 2012 at 3.15pm HEAD TO HEAD Overall Melbourne 0 wins GWS Giants 0 wins At the MCG Melbourne 0 wins GWS Giants 0 wins Since 2000 Melbourne 0 wins GWS Giants 0 wins The Coaches Neeld 0 wins Sheedy 0 wins MEDIA TV - Channel 7 & Fox Footy Channel live at 3.00pm. RADIO - ABC774 3AW Triple M THE BETTING Melbourne to win $1.31 GWS to win $3.55 LAST TIME THEY MET Never. THE TEAMS MELBOURNE Backs James Sellar James Frawley Jared Rivers Half backs Daniel Nicholson Tom McDonald Jack Watts Centreline Rohan Bail Jack Trengove Jack Grimes Half forwards Jeremy Howe Lynden Dunn Nathan Jones Forwards Mitch Clark Colin Garland Colin Sylvia Followers Mark Jamar Brent Moloney Jordie McKenzie Interchange Matthew Bate Aaron Davey Joel Macdonald James Magner Emergencies Sam Blease Troy Davis Cale Morton In Rohan Bail Matthew Bate Aaron Davey Joel Macdonald Out Sam Blease Brad Green (hip) Cale Morton Luke Tapscott (suspension) GWS GIANTS Backs Jack Hombsch Tim Mohr Sam Darley Half backs Shaun Edwards Phil Davis Toby Greene Centreline Tom Scully Callan Ward Adam Treloar Half forwards Taylor Adams Jeremy Cameron Rhys Palmer Forwards Nathan Wilson Jonathan Patton Mark Whiley Followers Dean Brogan James McDonald Dylan Shiel Interchange Tomas Bugg Jonathan Giles Devon Smith Luke Power Emergencies Chad Cornes WIlliam Hoskin-Elliot Andrew Phillips In Jonathan Giles Jack Hombsch Nathan Wilson Out Chad Cornes (rested) Andrew Phillips Sam Schulz (calf) THE PERILS OF LONG RANGE FORECASTING Let's face it. The minute the AFL issued its programme of matches way back twhen the full roster of Greater Western Sydney players was far from finalised, we were all smacking our chops in anticipation of what shaped not only as an eminently winnable game for Melbourne but also as a probable crushing of the club we had quickly grown to loathe because of the tactics used to lure Tom Scully away from the club. After all, Melbourne's first encounter in 2011 with that year's debutants from the Gold Coast had resulted in a 15 goal victory even though most judges felt the team didn't even raise a gallop until the final quarter. Surely, this would be another massacre of similar proportions? Well, we've seen some changes since then. Things have not gone well for Melbourne with injuries, loss of form, a slow adaptation to a new style of play and some extraordinary and well documented on and off field events derailing the first half of the club's season. Not even in our wildest nightmares did we expect Melbourne to be on only one win at this juncture. A similar thing could be said of Greater Western Sydney who most expected to go through 2012 winless. Not only did they beat the Suns earlier in the season, but they have been impressive with some real competitive performances, particularly in recent times. It's no mean feat to be on even terms with Geelong on its home turf even if the Cats are seemingly on their way down and the Giants did well last week to be within sniffing distance late in their game against the Tigers. On Sunday, the Giants will experience the MCG for the first time and the big ground should suit them because they run and spread well, a feature which has for the most part been lacking at Melbourne this year. The Demons have loaded up with big bodies in order to exploit the youthful Giants and it will be interesting to see how the game plays itself out. What puzzles me is the GWS decision to omit Chad Cornes who routinely stars against Melbourne and whose form this year had been widely acknowledged as one of the reasons why his team has been so competitive. Last week he had 23 touches against Richmond and whilst not as prolific against Geelong in the game before that, his contribution was significant. In his team's only win this year, Cornes had 28 possessions, took 12 marks and was easily best on the ground. It's hard to believe that he's been rested for this game on this ground and in the heavy conditions anticipated for Sunday. I wouldn't be surprised if this was yet another Sheedy ploy and a late change will see Cornes running out for the game. What Melbourne needs to win on Sunday is a good start. After a couple of weeks of competitive starts against Carlton and Essendon, the Demons were woeful for almost a quarter and a half as they conceded more than eight goals as a result of some sloppy play, loose checking and poor kicking for goal against the Pies on Queens Birthday. A similar start will lead to a day of embarrassment. On the other hand, the Giants will need everything to go their way much as it did last week against the Tigers when virtually every foray into the forward line resulted in a goal while Richmond was extremely wasteful up forward. The result was that the home side needed only fourteen shots to achieve twelve goals while the visitors scored one less goal with 31 attempts in their two goal win. In other words, it was only a matter of accuracy in front of goal that was the difference between a close result and an absolute thumping. These things rarely happen two weeks in a row and, on that basis I believe the time has come for Melbourne to kick off a better half of the season and I'm tipping Melbourne and Black Caviar to make it a double for the weekend. Both will end up saluting the judges. Demon fans - prepare to wave your jackets in the direction of the GWS coaches box at the end of the game! Melbourne by 36 points.
dpositive 1,838 Posted June 21, 2012 Posted June 21, 2012 An unfortunate reference in this game is that the AFL has supported this project above other matters. It was the same with Sydney Adelaide West Coast Port and Fremantle when they were introduced. of those teams only FReo have not produced the flag as justification of the success of the team. It is surely that success that builds or perhaps in truth maintained the supporter base. GWS is an opportunity to really grow the supporter base and so will be pursued at any cost by AFL when can we expext a GWS flag? and will it be before the Demons next> I can see only negatives for the MFC with the lead up to the match . Nothing less than a huge crowd of Melbourne supporters cheering their team to a ten goal win will be reported as a success for the MFC. Even if we do win by the 10 goals it will be reported that this is what is expected by aMelbourne team more advanced than the above mentioned pimply faced kids. and No doubt there will be more reporting of T$ reception and ststs than any other player action. Watts will need to kick 10 goals or have 40 possessions to even be considered against any T$ action and heaven help us if T$ is injured by anything less than a self imposed injury I hope that this weekend will quickly be over and we can concentrate on the fortunes of our own players I think we have more than enough good and bad issues to confront. In fact the snow is looking most welcome just wish I could get there.
Grapeviney 9,931 Posted June 21, 2012 Posted June 21, 2012 Hopefully, Mark Neeld won’t take the bait. and hopefully supporters do WJ, or it's going to be a cold and lonely afternoon at the 'g on sunday
beelzebub 23,395 Posted June 21, 2012 Posted June 21, 2012 dont forget wet... Showers forecast.. possible hail even.
PaulRB 6,436 Posted June 21, 2012 Posted June 21, 2012 The weather is going to help us Vs GWS as it will slow their spread and increase the advantage of our focus on winning contested ball and the defensive clearance structure. The kick long along the boundary, re-set, ball in etc... repeat. Magner, Jones, Beamer, etc... should thrive.
DemonWorshipper 304 Posted June 21, 2012 Posted June 21, 2012 Team for Sunday: B: James Sellar, James Frawley, Jared Rivers HB: Daniel Nicholson, Tom McDonald, Jack Watts C: Rohan Bail, Jack Trengove, Jack Grimes HF: Jeremy Howe, Lynden Dunn, Nathan Jones F: Mitch Clark, Colin Garland, Colin Sylvia Foll: Mark Jamar, Brent Moloney, Jordie McKenzie I/C (from): Matthew Bate, Aaron Davey, James Magner, Cale Morton, Sam Blease, Troy Davis, Joel Macdonald IN: Matthew Bate, Aaron Davey, Joel Macdonald, Troy Davis, Rohan Bail OUT: Brad Green (hip), Luke Tapscott (suspension)
PaulRB 6,436 Posted June 21, 2012 Posted June 21, 2012 Garland at Full Forward!!! Love it. I know they rarely line up in those positions...
PaulRB 6,436 Posted June 21, 2012 Posted June 21, 2012 Two half forward flanks out in Green and Tapscott would give Aaron a likely start, with Bail (if fit) over Bate and Joel or Troy possible if Frawley is a late withdrawal with his foot.
beelzebub 23,395 Posted June 21, 2012 Posted June 21, 2012 could someone be so kind as to remind me how well Davey went in his last outing ? ( scorps ) cheers
Deestroy All 14,266 Posted June 21, 2012 Posted June 21, 2012 could someone be so kind as to remind me how well Davey went in his last outing ? ( scorps ) cheers Pretty sure it was 18 nice touches then subbed off at half time.
beelzebub 23,395 Posted June 21, 2012 Posted June 21, 2012 Pretty sure it was 18 nice touches then subbed off at half time. cheersi reckon he might be an interesting call up for this game...He does have the skills to bring a few undone.. If hes hungry enough
Bitter but optimistic 22,333 Posted June 21, 2012 Posted June 21, 2012 cheers i reckon he might be an interesting call up for this game...He does have the skills to bring a few undone.. If hes hungry enough THe problem is that he may well put in a good one against weak/inexperienced opposition and then fail us again when the pressure is really one. I reckon he is done at MFC.
DEELIRIOUS 156 Posted June 21, 2012 Posted June 21, 2012 He will be there next year I reckon. Still the best fwd pocket on the list, Aaron Davey that is
Bitter but optimistic 22,333 Posted June 21, 2012 Posted June 21, 2012 He will be there next year I reckon. Still the best fwd pocket on the list, Aaron Davey that is Then we are in trouble. ( worse trouble)
RalphiusMaximus 6,112 Posted June 21, 2012 Posted June 21, 2012 Just don't get ahead of yourselves here. This is a real danger game for us. GWS have been holding their own by playing a close-checking, bodies at the ball style and refusing to take a backward step. If they had slightly better match fitness they'd have pinched a few this season already. I am very concerned that they just might throw us off our game by getting in the faces of some of our more fragile players and snatch the win.
beelzebub 23,395 Posted June 21, 2012 Posted June 21, 2012 I cant see Aaron playing allgames...but used when suits....just my h-o
Forest Demon 4,681 Posted June 21, 2012 Posted June 21, 2012 GWS are not to be under rated. They are a far better team than Gold Coast were in their first year (in fact they are a far better side than the Gold Coast are this year). The facts that the game is at the MCG and possibly the weather make us slight favourites, but we have no right to be cocky, that's for sure.
deeflog 679 Posted June 21, 2012 Posted June 21, 2012 cant see davis getting a game this week, based only on the already top heavy back line named, and i wouldn't be surprised if there was a late change and sellar was dropped due to the forecast bail and bate will be considered or their strong bodies but i also think the forecast will work against bate
Nascent 9,346 Posted June 21, 2012 Posted June 21, 2012 Jack Watts plays his 50th game this week. Would love to see him, more so than anyone else, lay a bone crunching tackle on scully, from one #1 draft pick to another.
Rob Mac...... 643 Posted June 21, 2012 Posted June 21, 2012 GWS are not to be under rated. They are a far better team than Gold Coast were in their first year (in fact they are a far better side than the Gold Coast are this year). The facts that the game is at the MCG and possibly the weather make us slight favourites, but we have no right to be cocky, that's for sure. Agreed. GWS will see this as winnable & play it like a grand final. That it's their 1st ever MCG match & $cullygate will inspire them to make even more of a statement. My 2 cents is they'll go hell for leather & the betting odds should be about even instead of us at $1.30 GWS $3.55
Pates 9,697 Posted June 21, 2012 Posted June 21, 2012 I reckon one of the best things that could've happened for us is GWS pushing the tigers last week. They should not be underestimated and I hope we come in with an attitude to what we had for 3 quarters last week. Hit every contest hard, play with instinct and passion. Give them a hard welcome to the MCG.
McQueen 17,867 Posted June 21, 2012 Posted June 21, 2012 Once again, our midfield is the greatest concern. Jamar will have to feed it straight down the throat of our boys. I can't see GWS matching our forwards and backs at all. Also, I'm tipping our physicality will be absolutely brutal on Sunday.
Hells Gates 505 Posted June 21, 2012 Posted June 21, 2012 Once again, our midfield is the greatest concern. Jamar will have to feed it straight down the throat of our boys. I can't see GWS matching our forwards and backs at all. Also, I'm tipping our physicality will be absolutely brutal on Sunday. Patton & Cameron look bloody good. Get in their ears, hope they get homesick!
Hiram Cowfreak 79 Posted June 21, 2012 Posted June 21, 2012 One thing I don't want to see is Junior trying to stick up for $cully and trading blows with his old team mates
Recommended Posts
Archived
This topic is now archived and is closed to further replies.