10 steps to a broken club...

[Tatu 416]

Nice avatar Daaaaaaaaave...

The reality is after we lose to GWS and GC he will be under severe risk to lose his job. It's you that's missing the point. "Should" doesn't come into it in the context that you used it. Someone's head has to roll, even if it's not the right one, and you can't fire 50% of a list in one off season.

Why can't clubs delist 50% of the list?

[Range Rover 1,935]

...and he was the one who organised that absolutely stupid Scully press conference.

Why was it stupid? Tom Scully had told him and Jim Stynes that he hadn't signed anything with GW$ amidst a storm of rumours that he had.

Don't absolve the little mercenary of anything but full responsibility for the lies he told at that presser.

[old dee 23,872]

Why can't clubs delist 50% of the list?

where are you going to find 20 players any better than the ones you just flung.

One of the big problems with having 18 teams is the talent pool is streched too thin.

[RudeBoy 164]

I thought it was ridiculous that Bailey was sacked. His first 2 years, the club was obviously tanking, and last year he had the team on the verge of a top 8 finish when he was axed, after internal politics affected the team's morale leading into the Cats disaster. However, that was last year.

This year everyone should support Neeld who is doing his best under the most trying of circumstances.

[Guest Jackie]

I thought it was ridiculous that Bailey was sacked. His first 2 years, the club was obviously tanking, and last year he had the team on the verge of a top 8 finish when he was axed, after internal politics affected the team's morale leading into the Cats disaster. However, that was last year.

This year everyone should support Neeld who is doing his best under the most trying of circumstances.

Neeld won't get very far if only fans and CS are supporting him. Somehow he has to win the players back and he should make it clear on who's side he's on. There is only one choice for him if he wants to salvage his career and reputation.

Edited May 22, 2012 by Jackie

[Tatu 416]

where are you going to find 20 players any better than the ones you just flung.

One of the big problems with having 18 teams is the talent pool is streched too thin.

I'm pretty sure, the club would be able to find 20 people that would love to play for the red and blue....

I'm not suggesting that the club should delist 50% of the list. Merely asking why not....

[rjay 25,087]

Why was it stupid? Tom Scully had told him and Jim Stynes that he hadn't signed anything with GW$ amidst a storm of rumours that he had.

Don't absolve the little mercenary of anything but full responsibility for the lies he told at that presser.

Not absolving him mate, that whole thing was a scam in my eyes.

[rjay 25,087]

I thought it was ridiculous that Bailey was sacked. His first 2 years, the club was obviously tanking, and last year he had the team on the verge of a top 8 finish when he was axed, after internal politics affected the team's morale leading into the Cats disaster. However, that was last year.

This year everyone should support Neeld who is doing his best under the most trying of circumstances.

...and we haven't recovered from that. Neeld won't get a fair go until those involved in the politics are gone. Lets hope we don't have too long to wait.

[Deecathalon 3]

Since the debacle of the MacNamee appointment and sacking and reinforced by many other poor decisions, it is clear the administration of the club lead by the Board is simply not up to the job.

I have thought that Schwab and Connelly are at the heart of our problems. How it was possible to backflip from sacking Schwab to Bailey is beyond understanding. There is no doubt that the series of decisions covering Junior and Bruce, Bailey have undermined trust in the management of the club.

You can say what you like about the team being professional athletes but if you don't trust the leaders of the club then you can't give your best effort. Every successful company in the world knows you can't force the best performance from people, they have the want to give it. You do this by building a culture that provides the conditions for excellence.

Now I certainly don't condone players not giving everything and I can't bear to watch it anymore. But if what is believed to have happened with the Leading Teams report actually did occur then I now understand why. Culture lives or dies through leadership. If I was a player who committed to the process, took the risk to be honest and then had the trust I had placed in the leadership completely undermined, perhaps I wouldn't care anymore. Maybe I would just go through the motions and take my money.

Like others I would love know the facts, but it's clear something is very wrong at melbournefc.

[Hardnut 327]

Congratulations on your first post deecathalon, and very well said.

[rjay 25,087]

Since the debacle of the MacNamee appointment and sacking and reinforced by many other poor decisions, it is clear the administration of the club lead by the Board is simply not up to the job.

I have thought that Schwab and Connelly are at the heart of our problems. How it was possible to backflip from sacking Schwab to Bailey is beyond understanding. There is no doubt that the series of decisions covering Junior and Bruce, Bailey have undermined trust in the management of the club.

You can say what you like about the team being professional athletes but if you don't trust the leaders of the club then you can't give your best effort. Every successful company in the world knows you can't force the best performance from people, they have the want to give it. You do this by building a culture that provides the conditions for excellence.

Now I certainly don't condone players not giving everything and I can't bear to watch it anymore. But if what is believed to have happened with the Leading Teams report actually did occur then I now understand why. Culture lives or dies through leadership. If I was a player who committed to the process, took the risk to be honest and then had the trust I had placed in the leadership completely undermined, perhaps I wouldn't care anymore. Maybe I would just go through the motions and take my money.

Like others I would love know the facts, but it's clear something is very wrong at melbournefc.

Well put Deecathalon..

As written by Patrick Smith...our record with CEO's has not been great.

"At the time, Melbourne chief executive officer Cameron Schwab said it cut loose Energy Watch and its money because the club stood for integrity. This is the same club and same chief executive fined $600,000 and denied draft picks for two years for salary cap breaches 'fessed up to in 1999."

[Guest José Mourinho]

I thought it was ridiculous that Bailey was sacked. His first 2 years, the club was obviously tanking, and last year he had the team on the verge of a top 8 finish when he was axed, after internal politics affected the team's morale leading into the Cats disaster. However, that was last year.

This year everyone should support Neeld who is doing his best under the most trying of circumstances.

You'd know all about internal politics though, wouldn't you...

[felixdacat 459]

Neeld won't get very far if only fans and CS are supporting him. Somehow he has to win the players back and he should make it clear on who's side he's on. There is only one choice for him if he wants to salvage his career and reputation.

What is his choice? Jackie

Listening to David King on Insider tonight he basically outlined all that is wrong with the club and started with the coach but when Dunstall asked what is his suggestion to fix it he had nothing. Apparently King was going to dissect MFC on Insider and it turned into a hatchett job.

,

[H_T 3,049]

Neeld won't get very far if only fans and CS are supporting him. Somehow he has to win the players back and he should make it clear on who's side he's on. There is only one choice for him if he wants to salvage his career and reputation.

Load of crud. The Board had thrown its support behind Neeld and the players led by Grimes and Trengove support him - as Jack stated yesterday (Tuesday). His choice is to coach them through it. And anyone who deviates from the line and will not adhere to game plan will go elsewhere.

[Range Rover 1,935]

Load of crud. The Board had thrown its support behind Neeld and the players led by Grimes and Trengove support him - as Jack stated yesterday (Tuesday). His choice is to coach them through it. And anyone who deviates from the line and will not adhere to game plan will go elsewhere.

Correct. Neeld is here to stay Jackie and is supported by our board, our captains and by most of our players.

Quit your stirring and unite behind the coach ... or pizz off.

[fuchsia 37]

Scwabby has done a fantastic job & continues to do so.People should get off his case.

End of story.

the most prized sponsorship market ( no1 sport )in this country is the "AFL JUMPER' & BACK DROP & STAFF SHIRTS Not to mention web sites & ground..etc.

to be that incompetent & allow a low level co; to be a major sponsor without due diligence & the usual research after WB ,RICH, ETC being wary. & knocking back.

AND to be without a completed endorsement & sponsor for the back of said jumper for a number of rounds into season...

& as such putting the club through a week of a PATRONISING TELETHON TYPE BEGGING for help

( not the least eddie putting boot in with conceited help fest who tried successfully to humiliate THE MFC..)

THEN a worker from webjet who happened to be a melb. fan suggest to his boss about sponsoring who then RANG THE CLUB HIMSELF.... !!!!!

WHOEVER IS RESPONSIBLE !!!! NEEDS TO BE SACKED IMMEDIATELY !!!!

AND REGISTERED AS A COMPLETE INCOMPETENT ....NO EXCUSES.

cam schwab doing a great job ????? give me a break !!!

i don't think so..( all that WHITEBOARD WEDNESDAY STUFF DID NOT ACHIEVE MUCH DID IT )

all arrogant blah blah yadda yadda.....

" INCOMPETENT"

seen major sackings for 10% of what he failed at !!!

whats next a $32 million golden parachute !!!

[Guest Jackie]

Load of crud. The Board had thrown its support behind Neeld and the players led by Grimes and Trengove support him - as Jack stated yesterday (Tuesday). His choice is to coach them through it. And anyone who deviates from the line and will not adhere to game plan will go elsewhere.

I ceased believing the spin and tripe that comes from this club a long time ago. Never quite equates to whats happening on the field and usually the polar opposite.. What do you expect the players to say? They speak under orders. If spinning bull was a measurable stat we would be ranked first. And Neelds day are numbered as long as spin master Schawb remains.

Edited May 22, 2012 by Jackie

[Dr. Gonzo 24,292]

What is his choice? Jackie

Listening to David King on Insider tonight he basically outlined all that is wrong with the club and started with the coach but when Dunstall asked what is his suggestion to fix it he had nothing. Apparently King was going to dissect MFC on Insider and it turned into a hatchett job.

,

King had no idea what he was talking about. It was embarrassing for him.

[rjay 25,087]

the most prized sponsorship market ( no1 sport )in this country is the "AFL JUMPER' & BACK DROP & STAFF SHIRTS Not to mention web sites & ground..etc.

to be that incompetent & allow a low level co; to be a major sponsor without due diligence & the usual research after WB ,RICH, ETC being wary. & knocking back.

AND to be without a completed endorsement & sponsor for the back of said jumper for a number of rounds into season...

& as such putting the club through a week of a PATRONISING TELETHON TYPE BEGGING for help

( not the least eddie putting boot in with conceited help fest who tried successfully to humiliate THE MFC..)

THEN a worker from webjet who happened to be a melb. fan suggest to his boss about sponsoring who then RANG THE CLUB HIMSELF.... !!!!!

WHOEVER IS RESPONSIBLE !!!! NEEDS TO BE SACKED IMMEDIATELY !!!!

AND REGISTERED AS A COMPLETE INCOMPETENT ....NO EXCUSES.

cam schwab doing a great job ????? give me a break !!!

i don't think so..( all that WHITEBOARD WEDNESDAY STUFF DID NOT ACHIEVE MUCH DID IT )

all arrogant blah blah yadda yadda.....

" INCOMPETENT"

seen major sackings for 10% of what he failed at !!!

whats next a $32 million golden parachute !!!

Yep

I ceased believing the spin and tripe that comes from this club a long time ago. Never quite equates to whats happening on the field and usually the polar opposite.. What do you expect the players to say? They speak under orders. If spinning bull was a measurable stat we would be ranked first. And Neelds day are numbered as long as spin master Schawb remains.

and yep again

I still don't know how he was taken back as CEO after what he cost us last time and if you don't know that do some homework. We just don't learn from our mistakes, do you seriously think that Melbourne Storm would consider appointing Brian Waldron as CEO again.

[rjay 25,087]

From the Demon history...

Daniher repeated his 1998 pre-season plan of sending the players to four weeks of 'school', split between theory and training.

Off-field the club was hit with $600,000 in fines after voluntarily admitting salary cap violations over the preceding years. $250,000 was suspended on the condition that the club not be involved in any serious breaches fof five years. Joseph Gutnick had called for an enquiry on March 1 and admitted that the Demons excess payments would be more than $800,000.

Melbourne were forced to hand their first pick in the 1999 National Draft to Fremantle as compensation for taking Jeff White with the tainted money, and they lost the first three picks of the 2000 Draft as well. They later got back their first pick in 2000.

In August CEO Cameron Schwab retired after disagreements with Gutnick. Garry Lyon, who retired during the season, joined in a public disagreement with the President over the issue. With five vacancies on the board at the end of the year Gutnick endorsed Mark Rothfield, Peter Hayes, Gabriel Szondy, Beverley O'Connor and Stephen Bickford. This ticket was opposed by Ian Thorogood, Gary Hardeman, Ralph Glezer, Aris Imbardelli, Garry Pearce and existing director Angus Graham.

The club made a remarkable $1,494,645 loss. Salary cap fines, tax debts and an undisclosed severence payment to Schwab accounted for $1.2m on top of a trading loss of $298k.

The club end of season trip to Cancun, Mexico was notable for the players deciding to train while on the trip in an attempt to build fitness for the 2000 season, and to atone for their poor performance in '99

[Guest Jackie]

From the Demon history...

Daniher repeated his 1998 pre-season plan of sending the players to four weeks of 'school', split between theory and training.

Off-field the club was hit with $600,000 in fines after voluntarily admitting salary cap violations over the preceding years. $250,000 was suspended on the condition that the club not be involved in any serious breaches fof five years. Joseph Gutnick had called for an enquiry on March 1 and admitted that the Demons excess payments would be more than $800,000.

Melbourne were forced to hand their first pick in the 1999 National Draft to Fremantle as compensation for taking Jeff White with the tainted money, and they lost the first three picks of the 2000 Draft as well. They later got back their first pick in 2000.

In August CEO Cameron Schwab retired after disagreements with Gutnick. Garry Lyon, who retired during the season, joined in a public disagreement with the President over the issue. With five vacancies on the board at the end of the year Gutnick endorsed Mark Rothfield, Peter Hayes, Gabriel Szondy, Beverley O'Connor and Stephen Bickford. This ticket was opposed by Ian Thorogood, Gary Hardeman, Ralph Glezer, Aris Imbardelli, Garry Pearce and existing director Angus Graham.

The club made a remarkable $1,494,645 loss. Salary cap fines, tax debts and an undisclosed severence payment to Schwab accounted for $1.2m on top of a trading loss of $298k.

The club end of season trip to Cancun, Mexico was notable for the players deciding to train while on the trip in an attempt to build fitness for the 2000 season, and to atone for their poor performance in '99

Wasn't Gary a beneficiary of some of the salary cap breaches and also investigated by the tax department?

Edited May 23, 2012 by Jackie

[Dr. Gonzo 24,292]

Schwab's just one of the boys.

[H_T 3,049]

And Neelds day are numbered as long as spin master Schawb remains.

You're entitled to your beliefs.

Schwab and Neeld are not necessarily tied. Schwab may or may not finish at years end, and Neeld would still be coach with 2 yrs remaining on his current contract.