The Mitch Clark Thread

[Freddy Fuschia 750]

Spoke to a Saints supporter today who is a huge wrap for Walsh.

Look at your avatar Redleg.

It shows a horse bolting and that's what's happened with Tommy Walsh while we were having our tilt for Clark.

The horse bolted.

Sydney have come in with a big offer for Tommy with a strong endorsement from Tadgh.

The Saints are still fighting to convince him to stay.

We're a long, long, long way behind ...

[Sir Why You Little 37,240]

Look at your avatar Redleg.

It shows a horse bolting and that's what's happened with Tommy Walsh while we were having our tilt for Clark.

The horse bolted.

Sydney have come in with a big offer for Tommy with a strong endorsement from Tadgh.

The Saints are still fighting to convince him to stay.

We're a long, long, long way behind ...

$$$ can still talk if he is worth it....

[Redleg 41,731]

How can we have offered Clark more than we offered.....Clark ??

What are you talking about. I used him as an example of someone we offered more to but he chose another club over us.

[old dee 23,916]

$$$ can still talk if he is worth it....

I am fairly confident that is incorrect with this guy WYL

[Redleg 41,731]

$$$ can still talk if he is worth it....

Not to mention our Irish connection as the first club to try it and the fact of not having to leave his "Melbourne" home and mates here.

[beelzebub 23,387]

What are you talking about. I used him as an example of someone we offered more to but he chose another club over us.

more to than whom ? It looked like you were comparing what we attempted with Clark ..to the same attempt. Maybe it read ambigously .

[timD 994]

I'm horrified that we couldn't use cash to persuade someone to uproot his family and leave his desire of living and playing at home. I mean, how could anyone resist cash...oh wait...maybe he is an adult with his own soul and brain...

[Sir Why You Little 37,240]

I am fairly confident that is incorrect with this guy WYL

You look to be right, but Footy can be a very fickle game....Mitch Clark may regret our solid offer.....

[Jesse Christ 2,884]

Joel Tippet Thread.

[Nasher 33,617]

The first thing I thought when reading that Pick 12 got the deal done but Clark didn't want to come here (let's be honest - we knew this from the outset) was: what would Pick 12 buy from Fremantle?

[Jesse Christ 2,884]

Steven Hill.

[Redleg 41,731]

more to than whom ?

Than Freo.

[Redleg 41,731]

I'm horrified that we couldn't use cash to persuade someone to uproot his family and leave his desire of living and playing at home. I mean, how could anyone resist cash...oh wait...maybe he is an adult with his own soul and brain...

No need for the sarcasm Tim D. I think everyone on here accepts his desire to go home and that it won out over money. Can't see anyone complaining.

[beelzebub 23,387]

Than Freo.

ahh

[Jesse Christ 2,884]

I meant Kurt Tippett..

What of him.

Will somebody take this pick 12 and a compo for someone good for gods sake!

[tess 19]

This years draft is thin and there seems to be 8 to 10 that are ok and after that it is ordinary, it depends on club needs who falls outside the top players and who will be there at 12 but I have a feeling that we will be saying meh when our selection is read out. I hope not but it may be the case.

You sound like an expert but you dont know what you are talking about. Docherty, Ellis, Crisp and Clay Smith will all be still there past pick 10.

[Dee Fan 3,247]

I meant Kurt Tippett..

What of him.

Will somebody take this pick 12 and a compo for someone good for gods sake!

Greene will take 12 this year and a top line mid will take the compo pick next year, never fear it's all under control.

[Dee Fan 3,247]

You sound like an expert but you dont know what you are talking about. Docherty, Ellis, Crisp and Clay Smith will all be still there past pick 10.

So which of those do you think will turn out to be top line players?

[jayceebee31 761]

It was never more than an outside chance from the start and good on them for trying. As we've seen with Judd, Scully and now Clark, you need months if not years to set up the major coups.

So true - that is why we should have worked with Fevola earlier.

[DemonOX 8,809]

We all knew he wanted to go to Perth for family reasons so its no great shock.

Get FEV he will be cheap and we can stick him in the goal square and will take the best defender.

Also to protect ourselves put clauses in his contract to the point where that if he farts innappropriately he is gone.

[BAMF 4,413]

So which of those do you think will turn out to be top line players?

Personally I think pick 12 could get us a good player. Not a superstar, but a best 22 player. I'm thinking a Jones or Zaharakis type.

Docherty should be there at our pick and I would be happy with him. Greene might still be there. And if he is not then another quality player will slide.

I have no qualms trading pick 12 away. doubt it will happen now though.

[Dee Fan 3,247]

Personally I think pick 12 could get us a good player. Not a superstar, but a best 22 player. I'm thinking a Jones or Zaharakis type.

Docherty should be there at our pick and I would be happy with him. Greene might still be there. And if he is not then another quality player will slide.

I have no qualms trading pick 12 away. doubt it will happen now though.

If tess had taken the time to read what I said, I said I have a "feeling" that we won't get a top player and that's a distinct possibility. There are some reasonable players outside the top 8 to 10 but I don't think that there will be any superstars there. If we get Greene I'll be rapt if we get a good quality player then that would be great, but we need, as someone said earlier, stars not foot soldiers.

Just as a matter of interest we have picked up the following with pick 12

Jones, Frawley and Cook so this is the fourth time we've had it since 2005.

Edited October 14, 2011 by RobbieF

[Redleg 41,731]

Look at your avatar Redleg.

It shows a horse bolting and that's what's happened with Tommy Walsh while we were having our tilt for Clark.

The horse bolted.

Sydney have come in with a big offer for Tommy with a strong endorsement from Tadgh.

The Saints are still fighting to convince him to stay.

We're a long, long, long way behind ...

Where did you read this. I have been unable to find anything on this.

[BAMF 4,413]

Where did you read this. I have been unable to find anything on this.

Age Article

http://www.theage.com.au/afl/afl-news/st-kilda-no-to-walsh-bid-20111014-1lpc0.html

[beelzebub 23,387]

Lions might get compensation

now its just getting plain weird..lol

Apparently the fat lady hasnt sung yet and no one knows what song it will be..

Gotta love trade week and the contrived nature of the AFL's ins and outs