2010 MFC List Assessment

[Red Sox 2]

http://www.melbournefc.com.au/news/newsarticle/tabid/7415/newsid/101503/default.aspx

[H_T 3,043]

Straight to the point by Luke. Seems to be a reasonable assessment.

[Rogue 585]

IIRC the first player mentioned is Bail, and the author says he deserves to be a best 22 player, which I found a bit off.

Pretty good effort, though.

[DeeSpencer 25,383]

Biggest errors - Cheney doesn't have good skills, Davey doesn't play half back, Frawley didn't play on Barry Hall, Jones didn't improve as a tagger.

But was pretty good overall, was spot on for most players.

[Red Sox 2]

Biggest errors - Cheney doesn't have good skills, Davey doesn't play half back, Frawley didn't play on Barry Hall, Jones didn't improve as a tagger.

But was pretty good overall, was spot on for most players.

Where does Davey play if not half back? I thought Chip did play on Hall? Agree with Cheney & Jones.

[Felix 92]

seems like few players will be shown the door and come the end of 2011, even more will be shown the door (if no improvement).

[e25 5]

I think Jones improved in his tagging role.

[titan_uranus 24,963]

IIRC the first player mentioned is Bail, and the author says he deserves to be a best 22 player, which I found a bit off.

Pretty good effort, though.

Well I agree with him...

I think Jones improved in his tagging role.

Pretty harsh to knock a guy who's in hospital with fractured vertebrae, but I thought he was spiflicated by Harvey when he was tagging him, and I'm not convinced that he will end up being a good tagger.

[beelzebub 23,312]

Jones had indeed improved but still not there... Close. . Decisions are better... Another step up again next year would be great .

I agree what exactly IS Daveys actual posi ? Will depend on role for the day. Bail .. Definitely a find

is a little kind to some players but a fair assessment me thinks

[H_T 3,043]

Pretty harsh to knock a guy who's in hospital with fractured vertebrae, but I thought he was spiflicated by Harvey when he was tagging him, and I'm not convinced that he will end up being a good tagger.

Spiflicated ? good description.

I would have liked to have seen Scully go with Harvey from the start.

[Deeoldfart 8,005]

Straight to the point by Luke. Seems to be a reasonable assessment.

Agree. So close to the mark that most of us could have written it.

[Ron Burgundy 8,584]

Bruce - likely next Captain? I would've thought (perhaps hope) Green, Moloney and Davey are ahead of him.

[titan_uranus 24,963]

I would have liked to have seen Scully go with Harvey from the start.

Me too. We put Morton on Goodes for a day which was a learning exercise above all else. I reckon Scully could have learned a thing or two if he'd been on Harvey for the full game, not just half of it.

[satyricon 267]

.do we know who the author is, can't find him on any of the MFC staff lists?

[Dr. Mubutu 824]

.do we know who the author is, can't find him on any of the MFC staff lists?

Probably a writer from afl.com.au. That's where this first bobbed up (to my knowledge). They're doing it for all the bottom 8 sides at the moment.

[beelzebub 23,312]

Probably a writer from afl.com.au. That's where this first bobbed up (to my knowledge). They're doing it for all the bottom 8 sides at the moment.

Yes, Luke Holmes is a writer for the AFL. Google is a wonderful friend

[Red&BlueBlood 61]

Me too. We put Morton on Goodes for a day which was a learning exercise above all else. I reckon Scully could have learned a thing or two if he'd been on Harvey for the full game, not just half of it.

Good point however I think they played Scully in the role they want him in - line breaking midfielder.

I think Jones is a good tagger (could use extra pace) who was battling well with Harvey before injury.

Interesting both Gerard Healy & James Hird called for Watts to be played as a tall ruck rover... IMO I think we should keep him deep in the forward line.

[RalphiusMaximus 6,013]

Where does Davey play if not half back? I thought Chip did play on Hall? Agree with Cheney & Jones.

I would have said Davey was playing in the midfield for most of the year.

As for Hall, Warnock absolutely spanked him. I think Hall got 11 disposals, 1 mark and 1 point for the game.

[Grandson of a gun 276]

I thought it was well written and like most fairly accurate overall.

Not bad for an outsiders perspective.

[DeezMan 4]

As for Hall, Warnock absolutely spanked him. I think Hall got 11 disposals, 1 mark and 1 point for the game.

Frawley was on Hall.