No one invited to train ? (preseason)

[beelzebub 23,200]

It seems that apparently there are no invitees to attend any preseason training with Melbourne. This strikes me as quite odd given the plethora of delistings and the fact we have PSD #1

For sure there are more than a few players delisted for good reasons. We ourselves have done so but there are also more than a handful of players who still have more upside than not. Some are superfluous to the requirements of particular teams either by the type ( position) or age and/or clubs perception of windows and such.

Im past years we've often had one or two train with us...and this year none or so it seems.

Is there a reason ...club mandated ? Always thought such preseason invitations offered up a chance to get close scrutiny on potential recruits.

Interested in views and or the genuine reasons.

Edited November 4, 2009 by belzebub59

[torpedo 33]

Perhaps waiting on final list lodgements on 13 November

Edited November 4, 2009 by torpedo

[Dee Fan 3,247]

It seems that apparently there are no invitees to attend any preseason training with Melbourne. This strikes me as quite odd given the plethora of delistings and the fact we have PSD #1

For sure there are more than a few players delisted for good reasons. We ourselves have done so but there are also more than a handful of players who still have more upside than not. Some are superfluous to the requirements of particular teams either by the type ( position) or age and/or clubs perception of windows and such.

Im past years we've often had one or two train with us...and this year none or so it seems.

Is there a reason ...club mandated ? Always thought such preseason invitations offered up a chance to get close scrutiny on potential recruits.

Interested in views and or the genuine reasons.

I think we are struggling to delist enough players to use our first 5 picks in the National Draft, so there doesn't seem to be any additional spots available. If we don't get Ball we may go for another uncontracted player and I would imagine they would know enough about him without him training with us.

If Ball decides to stay with the Saints we may invite a couple down but somehow I doubt it.

[beelzebub 23,200]

Perhaps waiting on final list lodgements on 13 November

also occurred to me...but I would have thought one or two ( out of already delisted ) might have been worth a close squiz.

13 Nov doesnt give a lot of time.. possibly enough granted, to make an evaluation. Maybe 2-3 weeks is sufficient.

given the nature of potentially rookying senior ( other club ) players I might have thought some players might have been worth the time.

Edited November 4, 2009 by belzebub59

[Nasher 33,607]

I don't think it's that much of a concern at this point in time. I reckon we'll have a few down after the ND has taken place so we can suss out a few we might be interested in as rookie/PSD candidates. Until then there's probably not a great deal of point.

[Prodigal_Son 4]

Does the AFL still publish a permission to train list? I can't find it.

[Disco Demons 92]

maybe no players want to do the travel to casey

[Pello 1]

I'd say we are waiting for the final decision from Ball. No point inviting someone down and then a week later saying "sorry - no more room on the list."

[Demonland 70,326]

THE AFL has advised that the following unlisted players have been given permission to train with the following AFL clubs.

 

ADELAIDE

Nil

BRISBANE LIONS

Kieran King (Brisbane Lions)

Niall McKeever (Ireland)

 

CARLTON

Aaron Kite (Adelaide)

 

COLLINGWOOD

Seamus Macnamara (USA)

ESSENDON

Nil

 

FREMANTLE

Trent Dennis-Lane (Subiaco)

Kyle Hardingham (East Fremantle)

Matt Riggio (North Melbourne)

Alex Silvagni (Casey)

Danny Stanley (Collingwood)

GEELONG

Nil

HAWTHORN

Dean Putt (Richmond)

Jesse Smith (North Melbourne)

MELBOURNE

Nil

NORTH MELBOURNE

Nil 

PORT ADELAIDE

Nil

RICHMOND

Ryan Allen (Coburg)

Ben Clifton (Coburg)

Justin Kadhlefelt (Southport)

Thomas McCann (Ireland)

Jason Morgan (Coburg)

James O’Rielly (Ireland)

Graham Polak (Richmond) 

ST KILDA

Nil

SYDNEY SWANS

Daniel Bradshaw (Brisbane Lions)

Sam Crichton (Sydney Uni)

 

WEST COAST

Nil

 

WESTERN BULLDOGS

Nil

[spurs-r-us 0]

Carlton-Matt Maguire

[Prodigal_Son 4]

THE AFL has advised that the following unlisted players have been given permission to train with the following AFL clubs.

 

ADELAIDE

Nil

BRISBANE LIONS

Kieran King (Brisbane Lions)

Niall McKeever (Ireland)

 

CARLTON

Aaron Kite (Adelaide)

 

COLLINGWOOD

Seamus Macnamara (USA)

ESSENDON

Nil

 

FREMANTLE

Trent Dennis-Lane (Subiaco)

Kyle Hardingham (East Fremantle)

Matt Riggio (North Melbourne)

Alex Silvagni (Casey)

Danny Stanley (Collingwood)

GEELONG

Nil

HAWTHORN

Dean Putt (Richmond)

Jesse Smith (North Melbourne)

MELBOURNE

Nil

NORTH MELBOURNE

Nil 

PORT ADELAIDE

Nil

RICHMOND

Ryan Allen (Coburg)

Ben Clifton (Coburg)

Justin Kadhlefelt (Southport)

Thomas McCann (Ireland)

Jason Morgan (Coburg)

James O’Rielly (Ireland)

Graham Polak (Richmond) 

ST KILDA

Nil

SYDNEY SWANS

Daniel Bradshaw (Brisbane Lions)

Sam Crichton (Sydney Uni)

 

WEST COAST

Nil

 

WESTERN BULLDOGS

Nil

Thanks for posting that

No Buckley or Valenti or Robbo

[Cards13 9,117]

I like to see the Dees snatch someone who is training at another club in the PSD. haha. Like Jurrah last season take a player who another club has paid to have a look at and we snatch them away, if they are good enough for our great club of course..

[Bruce Almighty 0]

there are a few mature age players in the wafl that deserve a shot

shaun hildebrandt (Subico)

Blake Broadhurst (Subiaco)

Kaylor-Thomas (Perth)

Trent Dennis Lane (Subiaco) currently training at freo

trevor oliver (east perth)

robinson (swan districts)

if they get picked up they will do well, watch this space

[jacey 333]

Mitch Thorpe will be training with Melbourne from Monday.

[Bates Mate 4,428]

Mitch Thorpe will be training with Melbourne from Monday.

Source?

[w00dy 146]

Source?

Pickers his manager mentioned it this morning on SEN.

[tess 19]

I heard this on SEN also.

[Carlos Danger 380]

Thanks for posting that

No Buckley or Valenti or Robbo

Buckley has been training with the Kangaroos.