Pick #18 for Andrew Raines

[paddo 0]

In the Hun this morning, Raines wants out of Tigerland due to limited opportunities in second half of the year.

Still only 23, and is a very good player when right.

Would provide us with more run off half back allowing Grimes to be released into the midfield.

In a draft which appears to lack depth beyond the first round this could be worth a punt.

Thoughts?

[WonnaJurah 5]

NO,he wants to go to QLD anyway,doesnt want to play in VFL anymore

[Left Field 313]

Doesn't hit enough targets. Half backs require skill, speed and poise. He only has 2 of these.

No trade.

[Ash35 425]

Could be a handy pick up if he is over his injuries, but not for pick #18.

More likely the Tigers would be happy with a 3rd round pick. With Melbourne having the first pick in the 4th round, that might even be enough.

Pick #18 would be way over the odds. Richmond would do that in a heart beat if offered.

[The O 39]

In the Hun this morning, Raines wants out of Tigerland due to limited opportunities in second half of the year.

Still only 23, and is a very good player when right.

Would provide us with more run off half back allowing Grimes to be released into the midfield.

In a draft which appears to lack depth beyond the first round this could be worth a punt.

Thoughts?

No chance of us drafting him. His manager has already expressed that his desire is to go home to Qld. So I'd expect a trade with Bris, or at worst will stay with a club for 2 years before heading to the GC. I would have thought we've got plenty of good young players coming through who can provide run off half back and expect Strauss, Bennell, Cheney, Morton, Tom Macnamara (if we resign him as there are rumours he wants to head home to SA), Bruce and maybe Buckley to be used in such roles and see Grimes still spending a lot of time there in a similar role to Hodge at Hawthorn.

[H_T 3,043]

Pick #18 would be way over the odds. Richmond would do that in a heart beat if offered.

Bingo Ash34. Way over the odds.

[Rhino Richards 1,467]

In the Hun this morning, Raines wants out of Tigerland due to limited opportunities in second half of the year.

Still only 23, and is a very good player when right.

Would provide us with more run off half back allowing Grimes to be released into the midfield.

In a draft which appears to lack depth beyond the first round this could be worth a punt.

Thoughts?

You're kidding

Send him to GC

[jacey 333]

Pick #18 would be way over the odds.

Raines specialty is to provide run. The problem is, he deliberately runs into traffic , gets pressured and gives a hospital handpass to a team mate or kicks it very poorly to them.

Just no.

[Weekends at Bernie's 64]

no thanks, dont need 2 waste a pick on a player that isnt gettin a game at tigers

same type of player as cj was

i wouldn give up any of our picks for him

[Kit Walker 225]

Looked a good player a couple of years ago but has gone backward since then (injuries/curse of TW?)

Needs an outstanding season at second tier level to even be considered for re-drafting if he doesn't stay at the tigers or be traded this year. Wouldn't think that anything under pick 50 would be offered.

In terms of Melbourne, I can't see why we would trade for yet another half back flanker.

[bjgc 0]

CRAZY TALK.

[Redleg 40,822]

CRAZY TALK.

Beautiful summary.

[joeboy 3,163]

Raines specialty is to provide run. The problem is, he deliberately runs into traffic , gets pressured and gives a hospital handpass to a team mate or kicks it very poorly to them.

Just no.

Sounds like a little bald guy who plays for us !

[Guest Rojik of the Arctic]

Jeez I hope none of the blokes who post here are recruiters for the club. Let's give away a top 20 pick for a spud like Raines or Staker and while we are at it trade Rivers for a "may be a player one day" kid.

FFS Half of the people here want to see us fail.

[Lil_red_fire_engine 11,112]

In the Hun this morning, Raines wants out of Tigerland due to limited opportunities in second half of the year.

Still only 23, and is a very good player when right.

Would provide us with more run off half back allowing Grimes to be released into the midfield.

In a draft which appears to lack depth beyond the first round this could be worth a punt.

Thoughts?

NO

[Tatu 416]

bell for raines

[Swampfox 190]

IMO Raines isnt AFL standard

[RalphiusMaximus 6,021]

He's a smaller version of Buckley with less kicking ability. No need for him on our list.

[Jurrah Coffee 0]

If he struggles to get games at the tigers, he's a definite no.

Plus we got guys like Grimes and Strauss who use the footy way better than Raines.

[hillie 41]

Could be a handy pick up if he is over his injuries, but not for pick #18.

More likely the Tigers would be happy with a 3rd round pick. With Melbourne having the first pick in the 4th round, that might even be enough.

Pick #18 would be way over the odds. Richmond would do that in a heart beat if offered.

pick 18 for a player that got dropped to the coberg seconds... tell em their dreaming.

[Deeoldfart 8,005]

bell for raines

One 'list clogger' for another. Why?

[paddo 0]

Pick 34 then?

[Bruce Almighty 0]

HOW MANY TIMES DO YOU PEOPLE NEED TO BE TOLD, YOU DO NOT TRADE AWAY EARLY DRAFT PICKS!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

[Guest hangon007]

CRAZY TALK.

Best post in the thread.

[ickey_11 145]

Raines has resigned with the Tigers (2 years)