Tanked against the Tiges

[Deano74 156]

I thought we tanked today and still nearly won. Warnock and Frawley in the forward line.

Newton down back. Sylvia not picked. and Davey on the bench at times when i thought he should have been on.

Johnston also used in the backline.

[deeflog 679]

it does not look good for tigers, but you know their supporters will be vocal all week and talking up season 2010

[Freak 100]

there's no such thing as half assed tanking. if you're going to tank, then bloody tank! Drop Davey, Bruce, Jones, Petterd, Bate, McDonald and Rivers and replace them with some rookies etc. Bloody melbourne are idiots. ffs!

[sylvinator 96]

I thought we tanked today and still nearly won. Warnock and Frawley in the forward line.

Newton down back. Sylvia not picked. and Davey on the bench at times when i thought he should have been on.

Johnston also used in the backline.

I agree that the coaching staff played players well out of position today. This is definitely a form of tanking.

Noone however could ever argue that the players didn't try their very hardest to win

[Jarka 767]

there's no such thing as half assed tanking. if you're going to tank, then bloody tank! Drop Davey, Bruce, Jones, Petterd, Bate, McDonald and Rivers and replace them with some rookies etc. Bloody melbourne are idiots. ffs!

Freak, we had Sylvia, McLean, Moloney, Morton, Green, Wona, Garland and Jamar not playing (and I'm sure I've missed a couple). There's not many left who can come in. Bailey did everything he possibly could to lose today.

[Toot182 7]

Noone however could ever argue that the players didn't try their very hardest to win

Agreed. They all looked devastated after the game. I don't think there is any doubt the it's not the players.

[Freak 100]

Freak, we had Sylvia, McLean, Moloney, Morton, Green, Wona, Garland and Jamar not playing (and I'm sure I've missed a couple). There's not many left who can come in. Bailey did everything he possibly could to lose today.

fair point. well tell your forwards to miss, pretty easy really.

[Deano74 156]

Freak, we had Sylvia, McLean, Moloney, Morton, Green, Wona, Garland and Jamar not playing (and I'm sure I've missed a couple). There's not many left who can come in. Bailey did everything he possibly could to lose today.

We looked good enough to win and to also beat Nth Melb and Freo in coming weeks. Injuries might be the only way to stop us winning. Cause I honestly believe we are better than all those teams.

[jacey 333]

Bailey did everything he possibly could to lose today.

I would like to congratulate Dean Bailey. Did everything possible but dumbarse Richmond can't read.

We need to make sure we are on the ball nxt week.

There is going to be mass pressure on the demons this week but hopefully we are strong enough to keep doing what we are doing and not get sucked into winning against North.

[Yze_Magic 3]

fair point. well tell your forwards to miss, pretty easy really.

Freak stays clueless.

[45HG 1,559]

joke of a system.

[Nunce 5]

Yeah definitely tanked, embarrassed to admit I was barracking for Richmond....feel sorry for the players though.

Interesting to note that Bailey walked out of the box with 20 seconds left when we were infront, maybe he didnt want ne1 to see him pull whats left of his hair out if we won.....

we were robbed though, McMahon definitely took that mark after the siren

other than tanking, does anyone know why Sylvia wasnt picked? Not good for moral if the players think the coach is tanking

[Choko 493]

We looked good enough to win and to also beat Nth Melb and Freo in coming weeks. Injuries might be the only way to stop us winning. Cause I honestly believe we are better than all those teams.

I thought Bailey coached beautifully, and demonstrated he had a Plan A, B, C and D.

Plan A: Drop half the team

Plan B: Hope to play blokes in position and be beaten

Plan C: Bring a ruckman into the side for a midfielder, then play Miller in the ruck.

Plan D: Play blokes out of position - Warnock and Frawley in the forward line, Newton in the team, ON A WING, Davey on the bench, Bartram forward (after playing on Riewoldt) , Johnson back, Valenti at full back

Plan E: Don't mark 2 players inside the back 50.

To the players, great effort and they clearly wanted to win. I thought that given that almost every player was playing out of position, they did pretty well.

Do you know what is a hell of a lot scarier than Melbourne tanking? Richmond wasn't

Jacky Grimes is a legend.

[Tony Tea 2,814]

Richmond are so bloody dreadful they almost lost despite us trying just about everything to lose short of playing Davey in the ruck.

The Tiges should have won comfortably.

Melbourne nearly won by accident.

In fact, I now hate Richmond even more than I did before. Instead of winning by several goals and consigning the game into the mists of history, they were so pathetic they won in "dramatic fashion" to put even more heat into the tanking issue.

We will now cop a heap of ugly attention because today's result will be viewed as every bit as notorious as Round 22, 2007 and West Coast last weekend - maybe even more notorious.

Will the AFL get involved? They only had to listen to the radio talk-back after the game to realise the current situation stinks.

Bloody Richmond.

[Yencks 8]

my favorite was bate and miller at the centre bounces

[Tony Tea 2,814]

my favorite was bate and miller at the centre bounces

Also, Frawley & Warnock in the forward line; and PJ at full-back

[Steamin Demon 401]

Freak, we had Sylvia, McLean, Moloney, Morton, Green, Wona, Garland and Jamar not playing (and I'm sure I've missed a couple). There's not many left who can come in. Bailey did everything he possibly could to lose today.

Jarka I agree, We couldn't have tried

[Steamin Demon 401]

Jarka I agree, We couldn't have tried

Any harder to lose. You should heard the filthy rigers supporters on 774. (Sorry for the typo).

[rpfc 28,906]

Freak stays clueless.

Unequivocably correct, YM.

If anyone from our FD told a forward to miss deliberately I would demand they be removed from the club.

You're an idiot, Freak.

[Gorgoroth 13,184]

I want to hear KB's response to thsi tomorrow on SEN

Warnock to full forward after we are in front

GOLD!

[titan_uranus 25,174]

We tanked. If anyone thinks otherwise, pull your head out of the sand. Bailey and the rest of the coaches did not want to win.

Warnock, Frawley and Whelan all playing forward. Newton playing defence. Miller rucking, when we're playing Spencer, Johnson and Martin. Cheney, Dunn, Bate and Whelan contesting centre bounces. Johnson being left to run around and do what he wants. Cheney playing on Hislop (looked to me like he was giving up quite a few centimetres).

I was sitting right in front of the coaches box, and when we hit the front, I looked at Bailey and he sure didn't look happy. I heard someone say that's what SEN said (something like 'Rawlings looks sick, Bailey looks worse').

This display has turned Kevin Bartlett, who until now has been a staunch sceptic of tanking.

It just goes to show how incredibly inept Richmond are.

[Straight Sets Simon 23,113]

I didn't see the game so I can't comment directly, however if Bailey was moving players around and the result was almost a win, I would like to see more changes and more creativity like this in the future.

[Cards13 9,117]

We finished with 19 fit players so I assume that they will say we had to play players out of position in the circumstances... Newts on the wing was amazing to see and not in a good way.

The players did not tank at all!

[45HG 1,559]

Our forward line for the last quarter:

Frawley Jetta Davey

Bartram Warnock Jones

That's better than any "tank team" we came up with during the week.

PJ fb, Warnock full forward the whole third quarter.

Our middle in the last quarter

Spencer, Grimes, Miller and Bate.

I feel so dirty.

[Sir Why You Little 37,307]

I want to hear KB's response to thsi tomorrow on SEN

Warnock to full forward after we are in front

GOLD!

KB's response tomorrow should be put out as a CD!! I think we all know now that Bailey wants those Draft picks.

Well played Bails at looking to the future. We also know the players do not try to lose, as it always should be.

Demons 2010 and beyond.