Clash Jumper - forum poll

[Tigers Dayz 2]

[Straight Sets Simon 23,113]

Of the Demon logo jumpers, I actually prefer the new one.

But neither really floats my boat.

[rusty_kingswood 0]

I think its important to incorporate the DEMON. The MFC remids me too much of The Team Melbourne/ MelbourneFC crap. (althought I do like the designs).

[beelzebub 23,390]

I think its important to incorporate the DEMON. The MFC remids me too much of The Team Melbourne/ MelbourneFC crap. (althought I do like the designs).

Keep in mind...first came MFC...then everything else !!!

We are the Demons.. but I can live without comical incarnations of it...I dont folk to laugh at us.. I want them to be worried !!

Either its done well.. or leave it off a jumper

[Demon4Life 603]

I voted for my own but I do like caddy's, which I think the AFL would be more likely to accept.

[tez 6]

i do like demon4lifes design however i have voted on what the club has put forward and gone for the demon logo

[Gouga 570]

I reckon the new demon looks like Cameron Bruce. Must be the widow's peak!

[H_T 3,049]

I reckon the new demon looks like Cameron Bruce. Must be the widow's peak!

Must be the widow's peak Gouga.

Good work Dees Dayz.

I prefer Clint's/Demon4Life's but if the AFL won't accept that, caddys would surely meet the criteria. Caddy's.

[Straight Sets Simon 23,113]

I'm surprised by the number of people who want in the jumper.

[Johnny Karate 559]

Demon4Life/Clint's is my choice.

Option A & B are just dull and only marginally better than the silver monstrousity.

C & D are better reworkings IMO although the new demon logo is looking less ridiculous by the day in my eyes.

But D4L/CB's actually looks like a football jumper that is representative of Melbourne Football Club - I'd actually buy that one it's red & blue not a bastardized version of our history with a neutral colour thrown in. For those who have voted the other options would you actually buy any of them? Could you really be bothered trying to explain who the jumper represented? It doesn't look anything like Melbourne.

I'm tired of our boards giving us the choice between a turd sandwich and a giant [censored] when it comes to these issues. It's no choice at all.

Stuff the AFL, it's our club, our game, our jumper it's either red and blue or it's for the EDFL.

[Sir Why You Little 37,307]

Any Melbourne jumper that has white in it is just BLOODY WRONG! i will nnot stand forit,we are not the bulldogs!!

[H_T 3,049]

Any Melbourne jumper that has white in it is just BLOODY WRONG! i will nnot stand forit,we are not the bulldogs!!

Get a cold flanel and lie down WYL. Settle. We get your point.

[beelzebub 23,390]

But D4L/CB's actually looks like a football jumper that is representative of Melbourne Football Club - I'd actually buy that one it's red & blue not a bastardized version of our history with a neutral colour thrown in.

I think tis is a salient comment.. Id buy it too. Id be proud to wear that guernsey to a match etc.. to wear the colours. it looks the part...not a 'this weeks' attempt abiding the AFL.. Its looks like a real footy jumper...well it is !! lol

Amongst a sea of spectators ...hundreds..indeed thousands of those would stand out !!

[Trisul 674]

I transferred D4L/CBs design into the guernsey used for the others.

Slight aspect/pebkac problems but does the job:

[beelzebub 23,390]

I transferred D4L/CBs design into the guernsey used for the others.

Slight aspect/pebkac problems but does the job:

Thats better actually ( all plaudits to those along the way too.. lol ) the somewhat larger emblem sits well lifted onto chest.

even the blue piping looks good

looks good

[True Believer 1]

Thats better actually ( all plaudits to those along the way too.. lol ) the somewhat larger emblem sits well lifted onto chest.

even the blue piping looks good

looks good

Demon4life gets my vote....please someone send these onto the club.!!!!!! Hate the options they gave us to pick from.

[beelzebub 23,390]

Demon4life gets my vote....please someone send these onto the club.!!!!!! Hate the options they gave us to pick from.

True Believer...we are..and have.. maybe you can too more peopel that comment and suggest ( even if the same thing) the more momentum it might gather !!!

we ALL need to convey this to the club

[True Believer 1]

True Believer...we are..and have.. maybe you can too more peopel that comment and suggest ( even if the same thing) the more momentum it might gather !!!

we ALL need to convey this to the club

believe me... I have spoken my feelings via several emails to the club.!!!!! :angry: :angry:

[beelzebub 23,390]

believe me... I have spoken my feelings via several emails to the club.!!!!! :angry: :angry:

Good !!

lets get a few more doing same

[True Believer 1]

Good !!

lets get a few more doing same

just sent another email to the club ...NO WHITE for me.... we are RED and BLUE, through and through !!!! :angry:

[beelzebub 23,390]

just sent another email to the club ...NO WHITE for me.... we are RED and BLUE, through and through !!!! :angry:

I do beleive they are hearing us and getting the message !!!

[Straight Sets Simon 23,113]

Good !!

lets get a few more doing same

I sent my email through yesterday.

[Trisul 674]

Love the new avatar BB59

Would really, really, really like the club to prepare actual jumpers and stick people in them in future design polling. Several people (tall, short, beefy, stick figure). Preferably with long sleeve versions as well. Seeing Brock in that long sleeved silver almost discombobulated me to death.

[beelzebub 23,390]

Love the new avatar BB59

thought the 'new' jumper needed fleshing out a little

I tend to agree it would make a lot of sense to actually see some designs on bodies

[True Believer 1]

just sent another email to the club ...NO WHITE for me.... we are RED and BLUE, through and through !!!! :angry:

this is my reply to the email I sent today....

We appreciate your feedback regarding MELBOURNEfc's uniform. MELBOURNEfc experimented with some colours to create a uniform appearance in the early years of its existence. A distinctive white outfit was used, which led to one of the Club's earliest nicknames - 'Invincible Whites'. This made way for red and blue in the 1870s, but still has an important place in the Melbourne Football Club's earliest history and cultural background.

Clash jumpers are in place to ensure that there is clear differentiation between the teams to benefit the players, the spectators, the officials, and the broadcast and media partners amongst others. A ‘main’ playing uniform and an ‘alternate’ playing uniform are mandatory for all Clubs as stipulated by the AFL.

The other criteria enforced by the AFL surround the length of time a jumper must be used and it's colouring. Dark playing strips need a light coloured alternative, as in the case of our silver jumpers and an "alternate" jumper must also be used for a minimum of two years. Unfortunately, the AFL will not allow Red to be the predominant colour. The AFL have determined that the MELBOURNEfc home strip clashes with Brisbane, St Kilda, Essendon, Fremantle and Carlton. This clash occurs mainly due to the dark back of our jumper and those of the clubs listed.