Jump to content

Roger Mellie

Life Member
  • Posts

    3,190
  • Joined

  • Last visited

  • Days Won

    3

Everything posted by Roger Mellie

  1. FMD - was expecting 2 or 3 years tops. Clark's terms are conspicuously absent. I have no desire to wish ill-health or injury on any player but I geez I hope Geelong get bitten on the bum with this.
  2. Two of Petracca, Brayshaw, McCartin, Lever makes me a happy camper.
  3. The only thing we need to clear in our cap space is the cobwebs.
  4. Now Adelaide to consider trumping Richmond for Trengove: Adelaide Crows look to trump Richmond deal for Melbourne midfielder Jack Trengove Yikes
  5. Try this on for size: Melbourne trades Pick 23 to Adelaide and receive Jarrod Lyons and 31 (or 50?). Melbourne trades 31 to GWS for Frost and 40 (or just 50 to GWS for Frost).
  6. I wouldn't rate Frost a 2nd rounder. Other than that, all good so far.
  7. I see where you're coming from and I agree - we definitely should've got Jack Viney for a 4th round pick.
  8. Can someone help me out here? It seems the AFL want to throw a free first round draft pick at Essendon to help them out. Let's compare notes: Mitch Clark right royally shafts the MFC after we do everything possible to accommodate him during his bout of depression. The key here is, the MFC do everything right by him in the hope that he regains is mental health and fingers crossed might resume being an out and out gun. Essendon DON'T do the right thing by Ryder (or 33 other suckers for that matter) and he wants out - the AFL are looking to toss them a free first round pick. Have I got this right? Grrrr
  9. The 'Draft Guru' Callum Twomey pronounced it as Petrarkah. Callum would know because he's a draft guru. Hope this helps
  10. There seems to be an issue with Ben re-signing with Carlton and Freo circling (sauce AFL website). We could trump them without raising a sweat. Should we.......mmm contested possessions... ?
  11. His name sounds familiar - I think he nominated last year but was overlooked?
  12. Or - Sorry Mitch, it didn't work as planned - you're off to GWS. Thanks anyway.
  13. I agree, we shoulda coulda got him then for nothing but we didn't, nor did any other club. I'm just asking the question is Greenwood and 15 (and say maybe a swap of Norths 2nd for or our 3rd for instance) worth Pick 3? I don't believe I said we should trade Greenwood for Pick 3.
  14. Is Greenwood and North's Pick 15 a possibility for Pick 3? Gives us Pick 2 - Brayshaw ? Petracca Greenwood Pick 15 (say Weller/De Goey) (Maybe a swap of picks later in the piece)
  15. Neade had a blinder (for at least a half) against Freo the week before if my failing memory stands up. Played a big part in Port's comeback.
  16. Just trade the [censored] to the highest bidder. None of this tip-toing around 'poor' Mitch and letting him choose. Whatever the best deal is for the MFC. I'd quite like to see him at GWS for Shiel (or part thereof). If it turns out he never plays another game, then Collingwood is fine.
  17. Ineligible - not possible to put the Filth and POTY in the same sentence.
  18. Touching! Who came up with that serenade? It's very fitting
×
×
  • Create New...