Roger Mellie

I'd like someone to explain why Casey has only been televised once this year.

Gunston's out which helps sorta Jetta should nullify Puopolo if not required elsewhere - should be a good contest between 2 tough nuts. I know Jetta's slower but he doesn't seem to get caught out too often. Still utterly dacked by the class factor - hope it rains

I don't know what everybody's worried about, it would be a first if we lost tomorrow on Saturday.

I like the sound of the INS if it pans out that way

The thought of Strauss on someone like Breust makes me feel ill

He's one of the few players that has some decent run. He'll stay on the list until someone with better ball use and decision making (as well as run) pushes him out

They shyte themselves when in a position to win.

Disagree - Kennedy was a young developing KPF. Carlton didn't want to lose him but had to, to secure Judd and Kennedy didn't want to leave Carlton at the time. He was not a massive disappointment by any stretch of the imagination.

I watched Bail today and clearly you're a fan, Fan and I'm not. IMO he had 3 effective disposals (that I saw) and for the most part, made poor decisions, had ordinary disposal and took the second and inevitably wrong option. If he took the first option, we might see a different player. They were the negatives, the positives were the tackling, pressure and he kicked a nice goal (from a free). Not in my votes.

I watched Toiges v GWS and watched Plowman closely. Admittedly, only the third time I've seen him play but I don't see what the fuss is about. Reminds me a little of Chris Lamb Rather Shiel and/or a host of others

How was Michie's defensive game?

While the combo sounds good (with Roos til 2016) can we afford that? Yes, yes got to spend money to make money, but we're on pretty shakey ground ATM and Bomba wouldn't be far away from Roos' coin

love it

I saw it and didn't think there was much in it. Might get a reprimand

Not only that, he called Jamar forward as the target and kicked it to where he had run from, straight into the arms of a port [censored]. Grrr

Not sure if you've picked up on this, but we have had 100% staff turnover on development coaches (2014) and fitness staff (2012). Why are you tarring them with the same brush? Why are you so certain that these new staff cant handle skinny kids? JKH is a skinny kid and Salem is hardly packing guns, but I'm happy to hold on to them.

Talking about frequency over severity and yes Bail has had both. Back to the context, IMO (and one more time IMO) Tapscott has had a lot of knocks

Not much of a tank, a bit slow and very good at running straight into an elbow. Not sure if I've seen a player get concussed (or at least seeing a few stars) as much as Tapscott. Often doesn't come off either so runs around half dazed. He seems to have the rest of the tools (tough! and a good kick) so I'd like to see him get a good crack at it. The 2 x 30 plus possessions at Casey is a great start.

Not much of a tank, a bit slow and very good at running straight into an elbow. Not sure if I've seen a player get concussed (or at least seeing a few stars) as much as Tapscott. Often doesn't come off either so runs around half dazed. He seems to have the rest of the tools (tough! and a good kick) so I'd like to see him get a good crack at it. The 2 x 30 plus possessions at Casey is a great start.

You shouldn't put up with it any longer! No really Switch teams Please

I dont advocate that it was all about poor recruitment at all. It was not the point of the post. Rather, was purely an objection of sorts to posters continually lumping recruiters together as if they were all the same and that further, that we have some perverse predisposition to drafting runts. I think Taylor's done a great job so far but it will take a while to see results - so far so good. He should be judged on his successes and failures, not Cameron's or BP's. I also expect him (Taylor) to have the odd miss as well as all recruiters do. It's a great start and hopefully he'll have way more hits than misses.

Our current recruiting manager is Jason Taylor. His fingerprints are all over Salem, Tyson, JKH, Riley, Georgiou and the other rookies. I find it surprising (even astounding) that posters find it difficult to separate one recruiter from the next. Taylor didn't recruit Morton, nor for that matter Hogan. Why are you (Fence and others) so quick to lump him in the same basket as our former questionable recruiters - as though he's on some mission to assemble soft runts! I don't get it. I'm pretty happy with the return so far and it's only year one. Let him make his mark!

Takk (jeg tenker)

Cant see any tangible benefits to this move. Melb Uni are a bureaucratic nightmare. The facilities would require significant investment and they are not easily accessible by anything other than tram from the CBD or Brunswick/Coburg/Carlton. IMHO most students would be unaware of an oval within Melbourne Uni. Just my 2 cents worth

FIIK