spirit of norm smith

agree with all these comments. Captain Jack was poor. Needs a class in decision making. 100% guts. 100% heart. 100% grunt. 25% footy smarts. 5% right foot disposal.

outs Lewis and Hogan. Both undisciplined and stupid. Didn't they learn from Vince's suspension. ins Vince and Spencer jetta t.mcd melksham salem o.mcd vince stretch viney hunt petracca watts brayshaw garlett weideman hannan gawn tyson Jones oliver anb harmes spencer emerg kent pedersen frost

6 Jones 5 Salem 4 T Mcdonald 3 Jetta 2 Watts 1 Stretch -1 Viney... troubling performance

omcd handball turnover hogan brainsnap melksham turnover

hogan miss viney fend off weideman play on OMG we are sh'$^%=×%it

yes agree 100% Goodwins address should be simple Clean up disposals move the ball quickly look for options 20-40 metres forward run run run handball away from a contest (these 5 things = watch the bulldogs play)

hannan looks lost players looking at 10 -15 metre kicks. blues now setup to stop this. handballs to players 40cms away !!! kicking backwards

chip chip muck around muck around in a circle handballs handball to a player under pressure turnovers viney has 4 turnovers rubbish 1st half yet so much talent under performing good - salem weideman watts gawn Jones poor - viney

Hawks 0-2 ... no tears from me Suns are a disgrace

Munro ? Hutchins ? Ferreira ? Moncrieff? Casey squad looks thin and will rely on Demons list again in 2017

45 on list excl lalalamumba 9 unavailable 36 available 22 for Mfc v the carl-filth 13 for Vfl casey praccy vs box hill hawks 1 ben ken on standby

Why is Mckenna not considered for inclusion? Fits into bag 6 as mid size tall as required. Good pre season. Physically ready. I think Tyson and Mckenna would be the best fit as ins.

10 players unavailable this week... and its only round 2 !!! thank goodness for 45 on the full list including rookies. Vince 1 wk susp Garland season Smith 12 weeks JKH 4-5 weeks King 5 weeks Vandenburg 5 weeks Wagner 2 weeks White 2 weeks Hulett 2 weeks Hibberd 2 weeks

Ins... Tyson Mckenna Outs... Vince susp Smith inj Jetta t.mcd Mckenna Salem o.mcd Melksham Hunt viney Stretch Petracca weideman Brayshaw Garlett hogan Watts Gawn Lewis Jones tyson oliver anb hannan emerg. bugg harmes spencer med/tall half backs cursed - Lamumba (ret); injured - m.white wagner j.smith garland hibberd. I thought we had the cover?

yes 18 matches and 16 have been poor. Constant mistakes causing goals either from turnovers, missed marks, fumbles ... all simple errors. He shows signs but has been fully backed by the coaching hierarchy. He gets the nod by Goodwin unless he cops an injury.

Great win today. Must back it up next week. Thought of competitive edge around the footy was the difference.

6 Oliver 5 Lewis 4 Jones 3 Vince 2 Gawn 1 Stretch

Saints team looks virtually full strength. We will need Hogan to kick a bag. Need to stop Steven in the midfield and Membrey has destroyed us previously.

jetta t.mcd j.smith Melksham o.mcd salem hunt viney stretch petracca hogan brayshaw garlett weideman watts gawn lewis n.jones oliver vince anb hannan tyson, hibberd, frost out of best 22. (smith anb hannan)

unavailable garland jkh vandenburg king wagner frost hibberd back 6 Jetta tmcd j.smith salem omcd Melksham midfield 8 Jones viney lewis hunt stretch oliver brayshaw tyson fwds 6 petracca hogan garlett watts Pedersen vince ruck 2 Gawn Spencer bench starters oliver brayshaw tyson spencer emerg harmes kent weideman omcd and smith are the worries.

Waiting until post VFL practice game. certainly out: Frost Hibberd JKH Vandenberg recovering/underdone: Garlett Kent Wagner J.Smith ok: Tyson Watts Saints have pace so need Hunt Melksham and Stretch. Garland to backup if o.mcd continued to struggle. Spencer supports maxy and go fwd. Pedersen or the Weid. jetta t.mcd garland salem o.mcd Melksham stretch Viney hunt petracca hogan brayshaw harmes weideman/Pedersen watts gawn lewis jones oliver tyson vince spencer

jetta t.mcd j.smith hibberd o.mcd salem hunt viney melksham harmes weideman petracca garlett hogan watts gawn lewis n.Jones oliver brayshaw tyson stretch emerg. anb vince spencer injured/unavailable: kent wagner jkh vandenberg

Clayton Oliver was super impressive. Could be A grade Star IMO.

hmmm bad habits still there t.mcd and o.mcd struggle under pressure. skill errors.

hard to argue o.mcd is still struggling after 15 development games