spirit of norm smith

-6 Goodwin -5 Chaplin -4 McCartney you get the idea

Lyon is being honest. The turnovers and dropped marks are ridiculous. Oscar McDonald Salem Jones Petracca Melksham Kennedy Harris Viney Hibberd all multiple offenders of lazy lazy play

Yes it’s almost child abuse it is gutting

Skilled disposers of the footy ONLY.

May gone. Hamstring. Season over.

Yes he is very average. Very average kick and not looking like getting any improvements.

It’s horrible. What is Goody teaching them. Nothing !!!!!!!!

Fumbles. It’s rud poor ridiculous

He played two more games of AFL than most people and probably all of us. What might have been? His debut was good but his body let him down.

Tim Smith has struggled over the past 3 years even before he was put on as a rookie with consistently getting into the field. He has had constant back and calf injury issues. Doesn’t seem capable of playing 3-4 games in a row. Disappointing as he could be a handy player. Not sure he gets another year!!

Pick 4. Toumpas WE BLEW IT !!!!!!!!! Wines wanted to be at MFC and we blew it. Neeld and The recruiters will NEVER BE FORGIVEN

Agree 6 off the list with Lewis Keilty Jwags Jkh Garlett Maynard. Think Spargo and Omcd should also go but that’s not the nice way that the mfc goes.

Lewis is better than quite a few right now but has slowing legs and given our year, the chances of another premiership is looking slim. Probably will retire and take up an assistants role. But I wouldn’t be disappointed if he went on in 2020.

So if Hawks get Brad Hill back (80% likely) and Langdon stays at Freo (50/50) .... what then ??? I am happy to go the draft with picks 2 & 20 and let JT weave his magic.

Demons would be least likely suitor. Many others like Bulldogs, Hawks, saints or Kangas are probably the club.

Out. Omcd wagner in. May Hore

No no no

Hawks will likely offer pick 7 for Hill and Dockers would jump at it. Hawks would pickup a pacy midfielder to compliment Mitchell, Scully, Worpel, Omeara. That’s not a bad midfield group.

Agree. Look forward. Dees to rock in 2020

Trade Viney. Ffs. The world has gone mad.

I’m onboard with Richo

Ridiculous thread. Keep Brayshaw

Foot skills. We need 8-10 more players with foot skills.

Brayshaw in top 5!. I think he has dropped off this year. Great to see him overcome his concussion issues but he needs to bring the 2018 form back.

Agree the coaches must take a lot of the heat right now as well.