monoccular

And how is the spencil going overall? 4th game is it? Any closer to AFL?o

Who else? Dawes won't ruck The momentum change free to debutant in front, even though he missed, was appalling. He drove head down into the tackler, and we keep getting told this will not be paid. A disgrace. He didn't stage, he just caused the high contact. "Play on"!!

It was our only Friday night game that year, and one of few we get. I seem to remember DumbItriou saying something like "we give them a Friday night and nobody goes. Don't deserve any more". It was the opening of the Bejing Olympics FFS. 8/8/08

Has JKH done much? - has had a long layoff.

Yes and yes, they sure should, but won't I read that Pedersen was sick with pneumonia which if true would see him out for quite a few weeks. Pity, because he offers so much more - can mark, can ruck, will ruck.

It was a very soft report, but knowing the corruption of the MRP he could well be offered 2 down to 1 - totally unjustified I know, but it is the MRP :-( One of those 'pivotal moments' IMO.

Hunt!!! You must be kidding, surely. VDB first game back after a long lay off was OK Harmes is out of form - remind me, does Casey play this week or is there another bloody bye?

And maybe we didn't learn and do it more ourselves. Probably were concerned that there may still have been a kicking in danger rule, when it clearly has been thrown out secretly by Gil.

Certainly some real positives from this game Exactly - I have been a critic but he honestly competed well - it was his first senior game for ages. Hopefully will do better against his old club next week. Yet with not many marks up forward this should have been his sort of day

You bitter individual, picket. He has a long way to go, but was far from our worst today. Under seige v Hawks did reasonably well. Yes he still has a lot to learn but will learn faster playing AFL than VFL. That said he may be due for a spell at Casey. PS: not (well actually yes) wanting to be a total pedant, but a light year is a measure of distance not of time, FYI.

6 Vince 5 Tyson 4 Jetta 3 Jones 2 Watts 1 Wagner PS from TV, not there

His marking (not) was predictable but almost excusable in these conditions. Overall he had a good game. And a positive - what a great idea to play Frost in defence. I wonder why nobody thought of that before. Brilliant one out of the hat by Roos

Much as I loathe the expression, it was a 'noble loss' if ever there was one. Not quite enough polish, but never without endeavour. Missed Viney badly in these conditions.

Head down int the tackler . Crap

Surely you are not seriously suggesting that the AFL would indulge in knee jerk reactions? How scurrilous of you. :-)

Was that the reason you started following Melbourne, or the result of it?

Freo, in fact any team coached by Ross Lyon, by a country mile Norf Brisbane = Gold Coast* *GC are so boring that they have to contrive "music" whenever they score a goal, which is, thankfully uncommon. Talk about an artificial club, an artificial team in an artificial location.

What ore do you expect him to say? No, sir?

I have only seen a little of this game, but OMG without being the pot calling the kettle black, we are surely far better than the Toiges. Totally inept. And they appointed Softwick for how many decades??

Hopefully less controversial than the Pentagon Papers.......only folk old enough to remember regular MFC flags may have even heard of these.

Fair points there Ros said his first priority was teaching the team to defend - they seemed to be doing that at times last year, despite some bad losses, but this year they seem to have slipped backwards probably because of a totally changed plan.

Such balanced reporting ? A far more interesting conspiracy theory than many others to date Maybe seed that. Where was it reported?

And of course the MRP had a good look at that too ?

Exactly Almost everything about our beloved club has become so much more professional......except the selection committee.

IN - at training, David Schwarz to give Jesse a bloody kicking lesson, please. Or even get JW4 to take him aside and spend time with him. As John Kennedy (Hawks coach not US President) said - "just do something"!