DeeZee

Giles absolutely gave him a bath on the weekend. Killed him in the air every single time. A worse kick of the footy I have never seen.

Can't take a contested mark to save himself.

I agree, they are the perfect back up players...can come in and do a job, adds depth to our list. They probably wouldn't get a game with a fully fit list though, but you never know.

For the money they paid for Folau and scully they could have picked 3 or 4 others who would have given them far greater value. Folau just looks like he doesn't want to be there, and Scully is one the most over rated , over paid, footballers in history.

Doesn't sound good..plays last week...then leaves the club with 3 games to go. I'd be surprised if he ever returns .....hope I'm wrong.

I will be dissapointed if we end up with none of them, Boak, Cloke or Caddy. Unless of course we get others who are good experienced players such as Sewell. Sewell Viney Toumpas would still be a big win.

Rivers has had a great year....I think he is third on our marks tally. We don't need to get get rid of good experienced senior players thank you.

Clark Jones Watts Grimes TMac Frawley Trengove Sylvia Blease Howe Apologies to Jamar and Jurrah who i rate 11 and 12

I'd keep him, I still think he has a lot to offer when fully fit...which he clearly wasn't this year.

Turning point in the history of our club....things are starting to turn around.

He just won this weeks rising star

I don't know.....is just that I'm very nervous about Cloke...nothing to like about him this year. Just sayin, I'd rathers throw the dollars at Boak, or Sewell.

Close has been an absolute spud this year, whatever he had a couple of years ago he has totally lost. Fingers crossed we don't get him as he will be a total liability. Throw the big dollars at midfielders please, not big gooses like Cloke

After Yesterday's Saints game, Sellar, Bate and Moloney have to go.....seen enough from them. Also I'm not sure about Mckenzie,I think these days you need more from players than one trick. al he does is tackle,doesn't get the ball enough or use it with any intent.

Congratulations Greeny.....250 games, club captain, leading goal kicker...true champ of the club.

One more year for mine....Smart player, good mark, great kick...we need experience.

If we are talking irrelevant, then no more irellevant team than Fitzroy when Roos was with them. At least Melbourne are still around! All those poor performances by Roos and his mates led to the downfall of the club. Roos has probably never recovered and wants to take another struggling club with him. Bad news Roos!

My guess is that Craig will join Leon Cameron at port,and Malthouse will take Craig's spot at Melbourne.

The ting about Tom is he rarely gets beat.

Look at someone like Keiran jack, who has been getting great accolades this year,but in my opinion has been on par with Jones. To be fair though, I have noticed the media noticing Jones more and more.

If you think Greens career is over, when he was our best player,god help the rest of them . I think Green has his mojo back,and should be given one more year.

I had a great day today...sat on level two,,right next to Robbie Flower and Todd Viney. Rod Grinter was directly behind me ,with Greg Healy next to him.. In the next bay was the melb current players ,Jurrah,,watts,Clark etc. Had a great win,then hada kick of the footy with my son on the g Got a terrific car spot too !

I was wondering who else has a sick feeling in their stomach,worried we will lose draft picks? It's just the latest in a long line of terrible things that have happened to us of recent times. I don't need to list them asi could write a novel on all the crap that has gone on over the last few years. Please...when will it all end? Mod Comment: There's about 5 other related threads on the front page - use one of them ...

Pee on the steps of the AFL

I think we just need to land a couple of experienced midfielders and we will be right. add Viney and Toumpas to that list and thats 4 players who could bolster our midfield . We can still get Cloke as well....why not? Clinton Young and Matt Rosa are two i would take in a heart beat. Id also be happy with Shannon Byrnes....but we could also snare another quick goal sneak in the draft.