DeeZee

we need some run badly...need Bennell Clarke needs support...also need Petterd and Jurrah

Sellar...worst mark in the AFL Sylvia hasnt touched it at all. Just playing dumb footy today...Cats cruisnig

sellar not a player...how he gets a game ahead of petterd or watts is beyond me

Grimes and Trengove very ordinary....we are pretty bad....not manning up at all. i just cant understand our lack of intensity

I like it....You dont perform ..youre out!

Give them our two priority picks, give him a million dollars a year and make him captain

Always thought Blease and Petterd have to be part of our best 22 , as they have the tools needed to succeed

Totally agree here, i think one more big preseason and we will see a big improvement next year....this year about showing intensity, gradual improvement learning the gameplan, and finding out about the players.

Could have used Petterd up forward tonight Happy to see some inprovement in the team. Watts was a tad dissapointing. Throw in Mitch Clarke , Frawley, Petterd and Jurrah and we start to look like a decent side.

Sylvia is very good in space, he converts on the run and is the give to player who can also hit atarget in the forward line. He is just the player we are missing at the moment.

The price of fish in china

He has had more Kicks Marks and goals than Natanui and Hurley. He is a better player than Tom Hawkins and Goddard were at his age. He can play midfield and key position in a similar vein to James Hird. Im still banking on him to be our no.1 player in a couple of years...just in time for us to flourish. and you wait till a fella named Jordie Gysberts comes on...still very young, great pair of hands, along with Viney will be in our top 2 midfielders.

We need a quick skillfull midfielder in the mould of Marc Murphy...Jones, magner, Maloney,Mckenzie..all too similar. Boy do they how to jump on the ball, but zero finesse or pace. This is the type of player we are desperate for.

Out. Dunn Bartram McDonald Macdonald Tapscott In . Petterd Couch Davis Grimes Fitzpatrick

We had our best passage of play in the 3rd quarter that lasted 15 minutes or so where our intensity was the highest its been all year. Its like they werent thinking game plan too much just willing themselves to win every contest. But that dropped off in the last and although we were still competitive , we lacked the edge we had in the 3rd. Coach still finding out about his players. We really need Grimes,Pettard, Sylvia, Jurrah, Gysberts, coz we lack that class,and these 5 are in our best 22. Also we need either of Blease or Bennel to come on, because we lack speed. Even Troy Davis i would play ahead of Macdonald. Tapscott and Tom Mc Donald need to find form in the twos. Bartram is a big worry for me, got killed by Dahlhaus,and to me has been our weakest link, as its always his man that is the most damaging . But overall i wasnt as gutted as previous weeks.

For me it all depends if Moloney and Couch are selected. If so we are a chance.

Would rather Valenti than Brock anyday of the week. Except tuesday.

We haven't stooped that low yet have we?

Hit the nail on the head there. Of course we all love the Dees ...they are family to us, and yes we are grieving....we are all just venting our frustration and sharing it with each other....all the while hoping it will start to improve......so this whole sad depressing thing can convert to a bit of Joy for once.

With all the good work the club has done over the past couple of years rebuilding. and saving the club, thanks to Jim. My biggest fear is we are now going backwards again. This is mainly due to how the team is performing. At some stage you do have to have on field success,or the club will never be a success, or respected. Now had we had some encouraging performances, 40,000 members could have still been a reality. Now it is a dream so far off its not funny. Not one genuine superstar footballer at the club, getting our pants pulled down every week. When will it end? My son and i walking away depressed game after game after game....come on! This is truly hell for footy lovers. Been waiting an awful long time. What makes this coaching regime different to the last, or the one before that?

My 11 year old son is scared to wear his melboune jumper to school on footy day because the other kids laugh at him

Bartrams game on Nahas was terrible...he plays way too loose

We have the worst midfield inthe comp bar none. Its in the centre square thats the problem. Our forward line and back line arent too bad. If we can drop Green for form...then we should drop Grimes, Trengove and Tapscott too this week.

How's Eddies succession plan going? If it ain't broke, don't try and fix it.

Cant remember if he played or not but thats when it happened