drdrake

Roos can't comment as the players we drafted fitted his game style, big body footballers that will win around the contest. That was the case you win the contested ball you win the match. The issue we face is we win the ball at the contest but don't have the skill to keep it. The other afl teams know this they just sit back in our defensive 50m arc and wait for the easy turnover and rebound from there. Our players aren't unfit, they work so hard to win the ball get it forward then bang the ball comes straight back out, we don't get a breather. The bottom line is our players are so far behind AFL standard in the fundamental skills of the game, kicking, handballing and Marking, I have never seen an AFL side even in our worse years that miss the target by hand and foot as much as we do. We have 3 players flying for the ball with no one down both forward and backs. Last year we scored this year we just don't have that scoreboard pressure

Be nice to see another kid, Jordon, Chandler or Bedford. Time to see more fresh faces

We really have 2 players that the opposition would be worried about ball in hand Salem and May, Lever is a good kick but just needs more games. The rest you know will miss targets on a semi regular basis, that is bad 3 players out of 22 that line up each week

Kicking, we just can't hit targets, absolutely disgrace that full time professional well paid players can't hit a target 20m away. We tried to put the ball into dangerous spots but the downside is once we missed the turnover was a goal, that was the difference yesterday, we worked hard for our goals, the Eagle got cheap goals due to our turnover and it wasn't Eagle pressure it was just pure skill errors.

Or we get to the bottom of the run and think wow that was an awesome run, dwell on that awesome run for a while add a handful of bad runs because we are thinking about the awesome run we had. It is a glaring issue for our team once the ball leaves that 5-10m of the contest our defensive pressure is terrible we allow teams to run away from the contest, our mids and forwards don't work hard enough outside the contest.

I reckon he is almost there, just needs to hang onto a couple more marks and kick those easy goals. He bashes the contest when he can't mark it and has shown he can take a good high contested mark. One more pre-season and he will be a 30 goal a year forward

Weiderman- Nearly there game Fine line between a good game and bad game, kicks those 2 goals that he one in the first and one in the second he has a good game, missed both badly and it goes the other way.

Disagree with this as we don't have any decent small medium size forwards. You have a giant of a man that is strong and aggressive leave him inside the forward 25m, if you are kicking long like we are you need someone to kick to. Weiderman and McDonald work from 25m out up to the back half and run up and back. The main issue is our small forwards, we play an extra mid around the ball so we always play 1 forward short, that forward pushing up doesn't work to get front and square up forward so it is always an out number once it hits the ground, then you have 3 forwards jumping at the same ball against 1-2 defenders leaves us 2-3 short one ground.

Lever if Fit comes in for Petty Chandler or Bedford for ANB, lets face it ANB offers nothing add some kids that add a bit of speed to our forward line JKH for Hannan Lewis for Brayshaw move Jones back midfield and Lewis down back, Brayshaw has been woeful Pruess for Smith at least Pruess will ruck and offer something

Key forwards, our entire forward line needs addressing. Our small/medium size forwards offer nothing no defensive pressure limited skills. I would hate to be a key forward in our team, we bomb to the same spot and three of your team mates compete for the same make with no crumbing forwards at your feat. Then when you offer a good lead the incoming kick misses you.

We just run forward of the ball and dont run the other way

Smith, hannon, anb woeful

Would rather do a Carlton and trade our 2020 first round pick to get another top 10-12 pick in 2019.

We need a top end midfielder that has speed and can hit a target, or a Half Back, or forward that have the same attributes. All we want to hear is elite speed and skills. We need to inject this from the draft our core group is 22-25 years old adding most likely a top 5 pick plus a mid 20's pick is what our club needs When is 2m Peter a free agent

We are coming up against a small quick side, Lewis will come in fro Wagner I reckon that will be the only change although Mitch Hannan would want to start getting a kick, if we had a small forward that was capable of coming in he would be dropped

Skills are just terrible We dont have 1 forward that can mark or apply pressure

So you can abuse your own team, just no one else. Lucky we support Melbourne we don't need to yell at anyone else our side is protecting us from from this by playing so poorly that we only yell at them

Doesn't matter who is at the helm we have a losing culture in our club, I reckon PJ and Roos started to change this, then PJ and Goodwin kept it going but we have certainly gone back to what is easy losing games of Football. That is the problem for our club it is to easy to lose games and as a club have taken the easy path to many times and now it is in the fabric of our club. We just continually get it wrong at the draft table, we draft for now not where the game is heading. Dean Bailey was all about the running athlete type of player and the game turned into a contested structured game, then we went the contested bulls limited skills but great around the contest, we saw 1 year of relative success at the end, then game evolved to uncontested keep the ball off style we just don't have skilful enough players to execute this style. A football oval is massive when you defend teams try to make it small, attack teams try to make it large, the issue we have we make it small on the attack and play into oppositions hands. They know we will turn the ball over in our forward 50m arc and they just get ready to run to expose us. Melksham makes a defender accountable as they know he is dangerous with ball in had, they also know that our other forwards aren't so they can get attack off them and we don't work hard enough back into our forward line to be dangerous.

This is the recruiting, we have recruited for a contested Paul Roos style of game, control the footy at the contest and keep it. The issue is we do get first hands on the footy at the contest but don't have the skills to keep it. The game has also evolved to get the balance between contested and uncontested ball, we don't have the players on our list to compete on the uncontested side. We are a boring side no exciting players with run and dare. The biggest issue we have is keeping the ball inside our forward half, the ball just gets transitioned way to fast from our forward 50m arc to our defensive 50m our back 6 have no chance. Yesterday Hunt and Petracca really get a c- for their games Weiderman a D the other forwards Tmac, Garlett, Spargo, Hannan just offer nothing, Hannan has an excuse the other 3 are just plan woeful. Time to inject more youth Chandler, Lockhart to play small forwards, Pruess deep. Tmac, Spargo and Garlett get back to Casey and earn your way back into the side.

We are absolutely broken, players are done. Lucky we had May Lever and Hore this should be 100 points

Isn't Dingley where Hawthorn are going. The Hawks are based at Arctic Park it hasn't stop them being able to lure players. Agree Casey isn't the answer, shame as Casey Fields has every thing you want with space to expand

Ok on that basis lets move to Casey to keep the admin staff happy, players will crack it but we will have a happy admin team.

Yep guess what, Tullamarine isn't Windy Hill, Where Hawthorn is going isn't Glenferrie, The Glass house isn't Victoria Park, Lathlain isn't Subiaco, Coogee isn't Fremantle, it is a training head office base, we need to move on from the past and find somewhere to build a future

All State and federal governments are concerned about is increasing female participation numbers or look like they are trying to do this. Even the Victory announcement was for their Womens team and academy. We need to expand our club, the facility needs to include Male and female Football, you need to get the Vixens on board and another group, North was the Hub, Pies I think was VIS and the community running/walking hub for the yarra, Richmond has received funds for the Bashar Hawli Academy, Hawthorn is looking at their facility to have high performance Basketball and Netball. It is almost turning the clock back 30 years to the old Sports Club model, we started this with Team Melbourne, great concept just didn't gain any real momentum. Join forces with the Vixens look at the land near the State Netball and Hockey centre, there is already Football Ovals there between the centre and the Childrens Hospital, think outside the box with something that can tie into the Children and Women Hospital maybe a secondary rehab center that caters for out patients. Look at a Ronald Mcdonald house as an extension of the facility. You need something that will not only benefit the MFC but the broader community

And that doesn't include the dropped chest marks with from players on their own deep inside our forward 50m arc. O Mac played like a player resigned to the fact that he is now our 5th tall defender behind May, Lever, Frost, Hore and instead of doing what Frost has done and fight for his spot he has just dropped his bundle. His brother has gone from a bloke that marks everything to a spud.