drdrake

Colin Sylvia would give him a good run for that title, maybe he was the decade before Bennell

Peter Bell is a [censored] and clubs will hate dealing with him

You will find they took the graft from his hamstring. There has been some amazing advancements with Knee reco's you have a number of options for the Graft one being Transplant which I think Goldsack had, a Transplant means you only need to rehab from the knee and not the area they take the graft as well

I hope he goes to USA like Petracca, that training was intense

Wait till he confirms he is going or staying and the trade is done, 500 pages here we come

If he wants to go I reckon it will be picks and a player. First round pick this year, future second Round pick plus Matt Taberner for Hogan and Pick 51. If Hogan goes our tall forward stocks are light on so getting Taberner in is back up and I reckon he can play. First Round and Future first round goes to Gold Coast for May, KK and Pick 18 this year

I think the issue is St Kilda don't have a lot to trade Pick 3, 57, 61 and 63. Good chance we get 57 or 61 for him which really is not far off his value. No idea how St Kilda is going to execute all the trades they want, Dan Hannebery is going to cost them a first round pick with a bit of change coming back, doubt it will be Pick 3 might be future first round and Sydneys pick 30 this year. If that deal happens like that I would take pick 30, 57 and give them pick 43 and Kent

Bit like Jack Watts last year, bit different though Watts wanted to stay but the club wanted to trade him, seems we are happy for Hogan to stay but we are unsure what he wants. The club is a bit torn at the moment they see the benefits of trading Hogan but also the downside is losing a very good player

So the flip side for us we have no chance getting Yarra Park as the to major parties will be sacred to lose the Green vote

Yep, with out a great knowledge of those seats, I'm assuming Punt Rd would be a green seat at the moment and Geelong a Labor Seat under threat from Liberal

Only if the AFL allow us to trade next years first round pick which might not be enough considering it will be Pick 18

You are using one pick for the Preuss, another for KK leaving you with 4 picks between 33-55 and hopefully get the Bedford for pick 90ish as NGA pick

We aren't getting a second round pick for him 40-55 is his value this would be similar for Kent and AVB

Hopefully he slots on Salem's HBF, to allow Salem to push up onto the wing.

A bloke who can't run, Kick or Tackle, I'm sure 17 clubs can't wait to get him on their list

He must be gone then based on Tim's great journalistic efforts to uncover this. Journo's are paid to make statements to keep them employed. If they don't make big statements and just deal with facts no one reads or listens to them. If they are wrong no one holds them to account, they can say what they want, make stuff up would it right and get away with it, bit like our politicians. We have 117 pages based on Journo's hunches not facts. Until we get some concrete comment for Hogan, his manager, Melbourne or Fremantle, he is a Melbourne player no point everyone saying we don't need him because we do what team doesn't need a 50 goal per year forward.

Saints have pick 3 and next is 57, offer 51 and Kent for Billings

Because Freo will be worried about big brother West Coast swooping in as a replacement for Josh Kennedy

As long as we keep a first round pick for next years draft we are ok. So if we get freos future pick we can keep or trade 1 future first round pick

It's 6 spots and 1 rookie spot

Add Kent into the Hogan deal to ensure we get 2 first rounders and change

That gives us 6 spots on senior list with AVB, JKH and Kent uncontracted.

I reckon if we were trading Hogan, Cam Pederson would have been offered another year on his contract

It's a shame that North's salary cap will be busting at the seems after they pay massive overs for Gaff/Polac/Hall this season

Trading is simple, if your club will benefit from the trade you need to have a serious look at it. I'm not for trading Hogan, key forwards are pretty rare but if Fremantle are silly enough to offer two picks inside the top 10 for him and he is willing to go it needs to be considered if you have a May lined up with the deal and a spare first round pick that could be offered to GWS for a Whitfield/Kelly. Adding May and one of those two GWS players this deal would be done in a heartbeat