Go the Biff

That's how I recall Balme's tenure as well. He was cruelled by injury, not just for a few games but for seasons. I still can't quite wipe out the memory of a loss at Port Adelaide where we were so short of manpower that our "tall forwards" were The Wiz & Sean Charles.

I understand your thirst for info but one of the best things about the club since Jackson came on board is that we no longer leak like a sieve

The problem with that scenario is that you assume that Jamar has some trade value. I don't & I doubt other clubs would either. If you assess him from the end of his AA year you'd have to put him in the "injury prone & out of form" category. Much like Jolly. If GWS start sniffing around for an experienced ruckman, surely it will be Mumford But your starting point of trading Pick 2 for a good player & a good pick is the way to go if that pick lands on the table.

Really ? He's had more clubs than Jack Nicklaus. Would he be any better than Jordie Mac in that role ?

Nice theory but I'm none the wiser Rockliff - I have no idea The Swallow story I've only seen on this website....so I assume it's baseless Selwood - Troy Selwood said on radio this morning from his discussions with them, that both brothers are staying in Perth. Adam taking up an off field role Sloane - it's been said that his family were so dirty on us not drafting him as promised that they'd never have anything to do with MFC again. But that was on this website as well so could be as baseless as the Swallow story

Do you have a wishlist ?

Why is he the most realistic ? I thought he was contracted for 2014. Just like Shuey, Selwood, Rockliff & Sloane

He would struggle to grow into the bloke trying to hang on

According to his brother Troy on SEN this morning, Selwood won't be moving. As well as being mid-contract & happy at WCE, his recently retired brother Adam will likely remain at the Eagles in an off-field role. That interview is probably up at the SEN website by now for those interested enough

Wasn't Pedersen targeted by us - or at least Neeld ? Also agree with FireInTheBelly that North was a poor option for Gysberts. Perhaps they were the only ones showing interest but they were already well stocked with young mids.

Best we start staging a few photos of him emerging from nightclubs & knockshops & get 'em out on social media

Don't post much but am Deemonator over there

I understand that you are pretty close to the mark. Source - a mate who works out of Tecoma. Spends a few days a week in the town On Rory Sloane I have no clue.

That was a good listen. I think Tyler will be hosing down those Adelaide blokes pretty quickly

I'd be happy if he became our Ted Fidge. We can reset his goals from there

A bloody good one. Rover.....back when such things existed Some pretty graceless comments on here. He's tries to run a midfield with only one midfielder up to scratch & predictably got poor results. I doubt he was trying to fail and I'm sure he gave his best efforts for the MFC ! For some hero on here to describe him as a disease is a [censored] disgrace.

No. Seriously no. We've been bitching about the Melbourne "boys club" and where it's got us Jackson identified our habit of going for the best "Melbourne" person rather than the best person Why go there ? Most of the blokes that have achieved success at our club are brown bread mate. Time to look outside Best available Footy first As for which players I'd like back, none from that list. I don't want a fair chunk of the ones we've still got !

So do I but it doesn't matter Footy First !

All of that is true. What tends to be overlooked though is that AD was also instrumental in the Schwab signing so perhaps he's just trying to square the ledger

Take it to court so he can play in the grand final ? Well done Dazzler. Like Nasher, I was 98% sure you were extracting the urine. The other 2% wanted to track you down & kill you. Slowly & painfully.

It's been a shite year on so many fronts. All enjoyment has been sucked out of footy. I don't GaF about finals, Essendon, Jack Trengove's choice of foot cream or Jack Watts playing future. But that third line was gold. Thanks Jaded.

I'd be surprised DemonWA, if Matt Jones wasn't top 5 in the B&F. He's been very consistent.Terlich not far behind. Jones has battled manfully in a deplorable midfield. Terlich has battled manfully in a competent, albeit besieged defence. Agree (stating the obvious) that Viney will leave both in the shade. I think Kent could as well

I'd be happy if we never got another one It's been a poisoned chalice for us

It'd be local footy for me And the TV wouldn't get much use

Locked then deleted