What does our best team look like?

[Jaded No More 68,913]

CB that might be the worst team MFC has ever put out on the park.

Come on...

Look at the wholesome goodness and complete awesomeness of that half forward line!

An injured flanker who doesn't give a rats about this season, a midget who can't kick, and Godfrey.

And what about that backline... a man with the turning circle of the Titanic and the speed of a turtle on dope, a 26 year old stick figure, and a kid who just had the training wheels taken off his bike.

All this side is really missing is Nicho at FB, and the return of Brent Grgic.

[Jarka 767]

our spine is a comedy. Like others have said, unless we can get an elite power player in their prime holding down either of FF, CHF, or CHB and dominating games we'll never challenge seriously.

Miller after promising much has let the club down oh so badly.

I agree, although I got harrassed by certain posters for having this opinion, interesting that your post goes unnoticed.

[w00dy 146]

B: Whelan Carroll Bell

HB: Petterd Rivers Wheatley

C: Green Jones Sylvia

HF: Bruce Bate Davey

F: Robertson Neitz Newton

R: White McLean McDonald

I: Moloney, Johnstone, P. Johnson, Dunn

E: Frawley, Bartram, Brown

i'm sure you all think i'm an idiot putting brown ahead alot of others for the emergency list, but his pace and recent good form gets him there... however if blokes like buckley continue to improve then he might fall back further...

tall line a little forward, dunn to play as a half forward/wing when he gets on...

[Rhino Richards 1,467]

I am not worried about now but what our team will evolve to in 12 months time and into 2009

B: Bell, Frawley, Carroll

HB:Wheatley ,Rivers, Sylvia

C: Johnstone McLean Bartram

HF: Bruce, Bate, Pettard

F: Davey, Newton, Dunn

R: PJ, Green, Jones,

I/C: Moloney, Garland, Buckley,????

Hopefuls: Weetra and Hayes

Players retiring or finishing their careers by end of season 2008 or start to be fringe : Neitz, Yze, Robbo,Junior, White and others like Ward, Bizzell, Godders, Miller.

I would expect to pick up 5 to 6 players in the draft and hoping that the prime target is a line breaking midfielder and possibly another midfielder with good defensive skills. It would be nice to pick up a combative second ruckman.

I actually think with Newton, Bate, Frawley, Rivers and McLean that the spine is coming together quite well with a fair bit of promise.

[sylvinator 96]

I actually think with Newton, Bate, Frawley, Rivers and McLean that the spine is coming together quite well with a fair bit of promise.

[Rogue 585]

in an ideal world, Rivers, Frawley and Bate would be played more as flankers. Rivers floating across half back, Bate across half forward, and Frawley playing against lead up forward like okeefe.

Not sure about Frawley, but agree re: Rivers and Bate.

[mick2007 0]

B Whelan Bizzel Wheatley

HB Frawley Rivers Bell

C Johnstone MacDonald Jones

HF Bartram Sylvia Green

F Robertson Neitz Yze

R White Bruce McClean

I Davey Moloney Bate Miller

Robertson Neitz Yze (old) Keep them close to goals and are freaks in front of goal

Push Younger players with more Legs to Half Forward

Have quick legs on bench for rotation of midfield and wings. Use Miller up forward or back, Ruck? where needed

[CarnTheDees 52]

Back 6:

Whelan Carroll Bizzell

Bell Rivers Bartram

Midfield:

White McLean McDonald

Jones Johnstone Bruce

Forwards:

Sylvia Bate Petterd

Davey Neitz Robertson

I/C:

PJ Green Wheatley Moloney

[H.B.K 0]

B: M Whelan, N Carroll, D Bell

HB: C Bartram, J Rivers, P Wheatley

C: J McDonald, C Sylvia, T Johnstone

HF: C Bruce, M Bate, B Green

F: A Davey, D Neitz, R Robertson

R: J White, B McLean, N Jones

I: R Petterd, P Johnson, J Frawley, B Moloney

Emerg: M Newton, A Yze, L Dunn

In 2 years (not counting draftees or trades)

B: D Bell, N Carroll, J Frawley

HB: R Petterd, J Rivers, C Bartram

C: T Johnstone, C Sylvia, P Wheatley

HF: C Bruce, M Bate, L Dunn

F: A Davey, M Newton, B Green

R: P Johnson, B McLean, N Jones

I: C Garland, B Moloney, S Neaves, C Johnson

[Straight Sets Simon 23,113]

FB: Whelan Carroll Bell

HB: Bizzell Rivers Petterd

C: Johnstone Jones Bruce

HF: Sylvia Bate Green

FF: Davey Neitz Robertson

Foll: White McDonald McLean

Int: P Johnson Moloney Bartram Newton

Depending on fitness / form: Frawley Dunn Wheatley Ward Godfrey Brown Yze Pickett Buckley Holland

[Demons 32 235]

My Team.

B: Whelan, Carrol, Bizzel.

HB: Bartram, Rivers, Green.

C: Davey, Jones, Johnstone.

HF: Bruce, Miller, Sylvia.

FP: Robertson, Neitz, Yze.

R: White, Mclean, Mcdonald.

INT: Newton, Moloney, Pickett, Bate.

EMG: Buckley, Petterd, Jamar.

Get rid of Injuries this year. Good side!!!

[Coxy 0]

My Team.

B: Whelan, Carrol, Bizzel.

HB: Bartram, Rivers, Green.

C: Davey, Jones, Johnstone.

HF: Bruce, Miller, Sylvia.

FP: Robertson, Neitz, Yze.

R: White, Mclean, Mcdonald.

INT: Newton, Moloney, Pickett, Bate.

EMG: Buckley, Petterd, Jamar.

Get rid of Injuries this year. Good side!!!

It's brave naming him in that spot around here!

I like the side though, shows what we have to look forward to next year

[Demons 32 235]

It's brave naming him in that spot around here!

I like the side though, shows what we have to look forward to next year

I still hold a candle to the Miller of old.

Im hoping a new coach will bring back his bite.

[titan_uranus 25,016]

I still hold a candle to the Miller of old.

Im hoping a new coach will bring back his bite.

I've lost hope. He couldn't kick a goal up forward, now he can't hold a second or third tall down back. All he can do is mark, which is nice, but he needs to work on kicking. Can't see him becoming a quality CHB or CHF (which is what we need).

[deanox 9,914]

I've lost hope. He couldn't kick a goal up forward, now he can't hold a second or third tall down back. All he can do is mark, which is nice, but he needs to work on kicking. Can't see him becoming a quality CHB or CHF (which is what we need).

and he only marks on his chest, not out in front. i hope he proves me wrong, but i wouldnt bet on it.

[Demons 32 235]

and he only marks on his chest, not out in front. i hope he proves me wrong, but i wouldnt bet on it.

WHAT!?!?

He always marks out front. I think you mean robbo marks on chest.

Because thats how Miller made a name for himself. Running upfield and taking strong marks out front. Not really many chest marks at all.

[Stromberg45 0]

B: Whelan Carroll Bell

HB: Wheatley Rivers Petterd

C: Johnstone Moloney McDonald

HF: Davey Bate Bruce

FF: Robertson Neitz Newton

Foll.: White Sylvia McLean

Int: P. Johnson Jones Green Bartram

how can you put sylvia on the ball before Jones? Jones is much better on the ball than Sylvia. Sylvia would ONLY just slot into a forward pocket at the moment

[Stromberg45 0]

What our best team needs to look like in 2008 for us to improve IMO is

Whelan Carroll Frawley

Bell Rivers Bartram

Sylvia Mclean Johnstone

Bruce Bate Robertson

Davey Neitz Newton

White McDonald Jones

PJ Buckley Green Wheatley

Moloney Dunn Petterd

The only reason Buckley makes my team ahead of Petterd and Moloney is pace we need someone else besides Davey with speed and he looks to have good acceleration and pace just needs to get better each week over the next 6 and preseason. Frawley has to cement that spot because our other options won't help us go forward. Robbo has to get his knee right and play HFF so we can have two talls on our FF line. This will enable Newton and Neitz to work in tandem great learning for Newton.

this is the best team posted so far

[Demons 32 235]

how can you put sylvia on the ball before Jones? Jones is much better on the ball than Sylvia. Sylvia would ONLY just slot into a forward pocket at the moment

I didn't make this team and don't completely agree with it but it is well known Sylvia is a true on baller.

He is going to be a SUPERSTAR.

He is slowly but surely getting over his injuries. Melbourne are looking to put him on ice for the rest of the season. He is going to be a total force, one of the most aggresive, talented players in the comp. I love Jones. Our hardest toughest midfield will consist of Moloney, Jones and Sylvia.

Sylvia will indeed become a prominant fixture in the demon midfield next year, I guarantee it.

[Rogue 585]

WHAT!?!?

He always marks out front. I think you mean robbo marks on chest.

Because thats how Miller made a name for himself. Running upfield and taking strong marks out front. Not really many chest marks at all.

He takes plenty on his chest.

[deanox 9,914]

WHAT!?!?

He always marks out front. I think you mean robbo marks on chest.

Because thats how Miller made a name for himself. Running upfield and taking strong marks out front. Not really many chest marks at all.

rewatch the tapes the last two years he has mostly been taking them on his chest. this is why his marking is good when on a long lead away from the goals (he has a break on his opponent) but not when it is man on man or when the kick is poor and he has to prop. bate marks in his hands, miller on his chest. have a look.

[Demons 32 235]

rewatch the tapes the last two years he has mostly been taking them on his chest. this is why his marking is good when on a long lead away from the goals (he has a break on his opponent) but not when it is man on man or when the kick is poor and he has to prop. bate marks in his hands, miller on his chest. have a look.

Why would I watch tapes of past games, when I watch it there everyweek. He cannot be pointed at when you have robbo who could take 10-15 marks per game if he just used his hands.