The Coaching merry Go Round

[beelzebub 23,348]

One of the more curious, entertaining and fascinating spectacles is the occasional circus called the Coaching Merry Go Round.

In past years not a lot has happened but this year , especially with the fresh announcement that N D will leave the Dees at the end of this year, the scene is primed for an un abashed frenzy of speculation regarding 2008 appointments.

Its probably been a while since we have the occasion of so many coaching position up for grabs and more than sufficent people to fill them , both old, known and totally fresh to the list.

I fully expect Neales announcement today to start a domino effect.. much of it behind closed doors.

well

lets the games commence

[re draft molan 1]

One of the more curious, entertaining and fascinating spectacles is the occasional circus called the Coaching Merry Go Round.

In past years not a lot has happened but this year , especially with the fresh announcement that N D will leave the Dees at the end of this year, the scene is primed for an un abashed frenzy of speculation regarding 2008 appointments.

Its probably been a while since we have the occasion of so many coaching position up for grabs and more than sufficent people to fill them , both old, known and totally fresh to the list.

I fully expect Neales announcement today to start a domino effect.. much of it behind closed doors.

well

lets the games commence

I dont really care about the circus about to take place over the next few weeks or months. Personally I think the powers that be at MFC have already picked their man, and the rest is just a procession. What will interest me is who will ND play in the forthcoming weeks and who will be busting their guts on the field.

[beelzebub 23,348]

Im talking the bigger picture...not just us !!

[Kit Walker 225]

It will be very interesting to see if what happened today acts as a catalyst.

Connolly is almost certainly gone and there are pretty big doubts over Sheedy (as there are almost every year), Pagan (if he doesn't get to 8 wins) and Laidley (probably if they don't make finals).

I'm not suggesting this (very much against it), but it's curious that while the Sheedy-Daniher swap was debated earlier in the year a Connolly-Daniher one wasn't. I know Connolly has been talked about as a possible MFC coach but Daniher did spend time there as an assistant...

[Rhino Richards 1,467]

Besides MFC, Freo would have to be as close in the underperforming stakes and who's been coach...Connolly.

He does not build culture and does not get the best out of his list.

I dont see the fixation with getting a failed coach just because he is ex-MFC. Whether he has played for MFC or not is neither here nor there and I dont see what tangible benefit it would bring to MFC that a coach from a non MFC background would not.

Who is it Molan?

[Straight Sets Simon 23,113]

Besides MFC, Freo would have to be as close in the underperforming stakes and who's been coach...Connolly.

He does not build culture and does not get the best out of his list.

I dont see the fixation with getting a failed coach just because he is ex-MFC. Whether he has played for MFC or not is neither here nor there and I dont see what tangible benefit it would bring to MFC that a coach from a non MFC background would not.

Agreed.

[Wiseblood 24,637]

I'm actually excited to see the direction that we take from here. While I'm sad to see Daniher go, I think this could eventually turn out to be a real positive for our club. A new coach with new ideas and new philosophies for our younger guys to build on is something that I think we can all get excited about.

Plus, now the Daniher has resigned, he might play the kids as there is no need for him to save his job anymore.

[QueenC 74]

Besides MFC, Freo would have to be as close in the underperforming stakes and who's been coach...Connolly.

He does not build culture and does not get the best out of his list.

I dont see the fixation with getting a failed coach just because he is ex-MFC. Whether he has played for MFC or not is neither here nor there and I dont see what tangible benefit it would bring to MFC that a coach from a non MFC background would not.

Agreed.

Yep me too !!!

[Rhino Richards 1,467]

Plus, now the Daniher has resigned, he might play the kids as there is no need for him to save his job anymore.

Like Pettard, Garland, Frawley, Dunn, Bate, Jones etc......

[Kit Walker 225]

Besides MFC, Freo would have to be as close in the underperforming stakes and who's been coach...Connolly.

He does not build culture and does not get the best out of his list.

I dont see the fixation with getting a failed coach just because he is ex-MFC. Whether he has played for MFC or not is neither here nor there and I dont see what tangible benefit it would bring to MFC that a coach from a non MFC background would not.

Who is it Molan?

I'm not sure whether you are having a go at me or not, as I'm the only one who has mentioned Connolly in this thread although in the context of ND possibly being considered for the Freo job (unlikely but I don't know how he's rated by the Fremantle board).

I agree it is foolish to get a coach just because he was a player at the club and I have never proposed that and would never. Chris Connolly along with Grant Thomas, have failed to achieve acceptable results from two playing lists which I rate amongst the top 3 or 4 in the competition.

[Dappa Dan 2,188]

Like Pettard, Garland, Frawley, Dunn, Bate, Jones etc......

Newton, Buckley....

Sorry. Couldn't help myself. Point taken.

Back on topic, there is one ENORMOUS positive to come out of this. Knowing, as we do now, that Daniher is gone, we have first crack at any coach that's up for grabs. If any other club does a St. Kilda and ditches their guy after a final.... by then we already have had a few months to get our foot in the door first.

The biggest evidence of this would be the Voss/Melbourne talk that's SURE to dominate the papers over the next few months.

[Gorgoroth 12,947]

The list we should look at is

Ratten.

Mckenna.

Voss.

Viney.

I would take Sheedy.

[Rhino Richards 1,467]

I'm not sure whether you are having a go at me or not, as I'm the only one who has mentioned Connolly in this thread although in the context of ND possibly being considered for the Freo job (unlikely but I don't know how he's rated by the Fremantle board).

I agree it is foolish to get a coach just because he was a player at the club and I have never proposed that and would never. Chris Connolly along with Grant Thomas, have failed to achieve acceptable results from two playing lists which I rate amongst the top 3 or 4 in the competition.

Not at all Kit. Caro Wilson mentioned it in the paper yesterday and it has been said on this site prior to you joining

[re draft molan 1]

Besides MFC, Freo would have to be as close in the underperforming stakes and who's been coach...Connolly.

He does not build culture and does not get the best out of his list.

I dont see the fixation with getting a failed coach just because he is ex-MFC. Whether he has played for MFC or not is neither here nor there and I dont see what tangible benefit it would bring to MFC that a coach from a non MFC background would not.

Who is it Molan?

I don't want to give much away, but his initials are Guy McKenna. No, thats just my feel. I think he ticks all the boxes.

[Jaded No More 68,903]

When one door closes, another one opens.

This is our chance to make a real change at the MFC, wipe the slate clean and start again.

I'm sad to see Daniher go, because he has always been a good servant of this club, but I'm so excited by the prospect of starting fresh.

This is our chance to do something big. I just hope the club really makes the most of this opportunity.

[Rhino Richards 1,467]

I don't want to give much away, but his initials are Guy McKenna. No, thats just my feel. I think he ticks all the boxes.

Great player.

Why has he been overlooked for every major coaching job he has gone for? And he has gone for a few! <_<

[re draft molan 1]

Great player.

Why has he been overlooked for every major coaching job he has gone for? And he has gone for a few! <_<

There's only been a couple in the last few years, and there are quite a lot of assistant coaches out there. Todd Viney is my smokey.

[Deano74 156]

A few names mentioned on 3AW

expected - Voss, Ratten, Connelly, Todd Viney

unexpected - Buckley, Gavin Brown, (SOS) Silvani, Chris Bond, Alan Richardson

Not much mention of John Longmire and they had doubts about Harvey

[WonnaJurah 5]

Harvey will take over from connolly

[Deano74 156]

Heres a rumor I'll start for fun, Grant Thomas to Coach and bring his Mate Nick Riewoldt.

[WonnaJurah 5]

or lets bring back old coach neil blame?

[Gorgoroth 12,947]

Heres a rumor I'll start for fun, Grant Thomas to Coach and bring his Mate Nick Riewoldt.

No chance.

or lets bring back old coach neil blame?

I'd rather him than Connolly