16 minutes ago, Sir Why You Little said:

Last night the Season was on the line

The first 10 Centre Clearances were won by Footscray 

Where does that put the mindset of the Players and Coaches?

So from last quarter last week to this week we lost 18 centre clearances in a row. Ouch

12 minutes ago, Heart Beats True said:

They had checked out and didn’t show up but it’s alright because they’re all still mates 🙄 

Isn’t that so nice….

2 minutes ago, demon3165 said:

I just love reading posts from people who are in denial and think everything is ok. 

Who says that everything is ok? I’d like to see a quote saying that. 
But everything not being perfect doesn’t equate to “SACK THE COACH”. 
Nothing is ever as good or as bad as it seems. Especially in football. 

5 hours ago, dimmy said:

A bloke called Petracca

Another called Oliver

Another called May, who has played injured most of the year

Another called Lever who has trouble finding oponents

A Gawn who can play on one leg even if his heart/head should say stay home

Now Windsor

Pretty is still overcoming a chronic injury.

Apart from that ........................  allis good !!

A currently suspended player/son-of-a-gun, who in spite of everything was our best forward in the 23 finals (though forward line was decimated in any case, even Fritsch wasn't right after his injury).

Spargo - who has his detractors here, but would have at least given us some options and is still our best I50 kick.

Ben Brown - no reason why he couldn't have given us 40+ goals a year and been a foil for JVR if his body had held up. He's only 31, same age as (e.g.) Jeremy Cameron. And you look at players like Taylor Walker (34) or even Tom Hawkins (36), there should have been plenty more good footy there.

Salem: was a key to our 21 premiership, his experience, leadership and disposal smarts are sorely missed down back. And having hm playing (decently) would have freed up Judd for more midfield time.

Plus:

Viney not right/carrying a shoulder.

Bowey hasn't been right since his shoulder and missing so much footy.

The team/list is completely shot, regardless of what the injury list says.

Edited August 3, 2024Aug 3 by bing181

If Goodwin had a 1-3 GF record having had Buddy Franklin for those 3 losses, and was coaching a side with Heeney, Warner and Gulden in it which trailed 71-0 in the second quarter, this thread would still exist. 

The double standards on Demonland are profound. 

Watch any of the spineless drivel Sydney served up in that first 1.5 quarters and ask yourself whether that was any better than anything you’ve seen from us this year. 

And then remind yourself that their opponent is a side whose crowd booed their coach off the field a month ago. 

1 minute ago, layzie said:

So from last quarter last week to this week we lost 18 centre clearances in a row. Ouch

Even more damming 

Good Pick up Layz…

4 minutes ago, Superunknown said:

TBF the site and its post edit / cache function isn’t fabulous on mobile view ports/devices. 
 

I’ve had very old replies cached and pre populate responses to totally different threads 

 

some of the site’s behaviour on Firefox / iOS is weird 

 

so it might be that 

Or it could just be the poster’s an [censored]

2 minutes ago, Sir Why You Little said:

Even more damming 

Good Pick up Layz…

That’s made your night, hasn’t it. 

3 minutes ago, Jaded No More said:

Who says that everything is ok? I’d like to see a quote saying that. 
But everything not being perfect doesn’t equate to “SACK THE COACH”. 
Nothing is ever as good or as bad as it seems. Especially 

Never said SACK the coach, we are a one paced midfield with a lack of skills and a past by date of a game plan, Goodwin has to reinvent how we play, any person with football knowledge should be able to see that but then again it's  demonland.

4 minutes ago, WalkingCivilWar said:

That’s made your night, hasn’t it. 

No. It’s quite sad actually, and alarming for the Club

16 minutes ago, Ollie fan said:

The love that JJ gets from some posters on DLand makes me wonder about myself : was I watching a potential Brownlow medallist and not knowing it?

Actually, no I wasn't.

As for Tomlinson: he got a chance and took it. What's wrong with that? Then injury cruelled him. He always tries.

 

JJ’s just a role player but he’s exactly what we are missing now, and we took him out of the side for 1 year of Hunter being no better. Short term - no gain, for long term negative.

Tomlinson took it for a while but Petty was always coming to take that job. He was the same player after the injury, he just had a run of games that he was never going to live up to. He pretends to try. Runs hard, but protects himself in contests, rarely leaves his man to cover, doesn’t crash packs, doesn’t break tackles or even hold up under pressure with his ball use.

I've scratched Longmire off the list

And it's all Goody's fault, like, I mean, players have 'chequed out', um, the recruiters are all Orangutans, anti-deluvian, the coaches are all part-time bozos, not to mention so totally incompetents they weren't there at all in 2021, and Viney, Sparrow and Chandler and Oliver are milking the system to build great investment portfolios. Oi Weh, the MFC is mired in duck muck, is all I can say, they are all nincompoopers, and it's got nothing to do wid the luck of the AFL Charlatans, the Draw, or injuries, just plain incompetence. I mean, even noncompoopers win flags, don't they? Like Sheedy and Jeans and even Joyce, and what about Malcolm the Blight...

59 minutes ago, Superunknown said:

TBF the site and its post edit / cache function isn’t fabulous on mobile view ports/devices. 
 

I’ve had very old replies cached and pre populate responses to totally different threads 

 

some of the site’s behaviour on Firefox / iOS is weird 

 

so it might be that 

Does Firefox have an app for mobile? If so is it good?

1 minute ago, Monbon said:

And it's all Goody's fault, like, I mean, players have 'chequed out', um, the recruiters are all Orangutans, anti-deluvian, the coaches are all part-time bozos, not to mention so totally incompetents they weren't there at all in 2021, and Viney, Sparrow and Chandler and Oliver are milking the system to build great investment portfolios. Oi Weh, the MFC is mired in duck muck, is all I can say, they are all nincompoopers, and it's got nothing to do wid the luck of the AFL Charlatans, the Draw, or injuries, just plain incompetence. I mean, even noncompoopers win flags, don't they? Like Sheedy and Jeans and even Joyce, and what about Malcolm the Blight...

Just checking, have Bevo, Mitchell, Longmuir and Hinkley been sacked yet? All were hopeless at stages this year.

Longmire will obviously be sacked tonight and Voss must be on shaky ground, as is McCrae.

54 minutes ago, demon3165 said:

Never said SACK the coach, we are a one paced midfield with a lack of skills and a past by date of a game plan, Goodwin has to reinvent how we play, any person with football knowledge should be able to see that but then again it's  demonland.

Have you watched us this year? We’ve re-invented the game plan, so much more run and risk taking from the backline, especially the young players who aren’t set in their ways. We’ve added speed and skill to the midfield from very limited choices (Rivers, ANB, Kossie). 

 

4 hours ago, bing181 said:

Hunter was a good pickup, filled a hole in giving us a genuine wing opposite Langdon. Cruelled by injury this year, but for 2023 average 22+ disposals, a couple of clearances and a handful of I50's per game was more than decent. Same for Tomlinson, was very good until the knee injury.

Other trades were cheap/depth - but once again, most trades are for not-required players and players who can't get a game. This idea that there's a pool of first-22 players just waiting to be traded is just a myth.

As for midfield depth, perhaps, but we weren't to know that we'd lose Brayshaw, then Petracca, and that Oliver and Viney would be down due to injury and whatnot. Suspect also that there was an expectation that Sparrow would come on more than he has, even Laurie.

But you can only plan for so much, and no decent or even half-decent mid was going to come to Melbourne to be backup to a stacked midfield - which is what we had back in the 23 trade period. The reason even players like Jordan and Harmes left was because they couldn't get games.

Lots of Hindsight Harries on this and other threads.

I don't agree.

It's obviously uncontroversial that we didn't know we were going to lose Brayshaw. But the rest is precisely what good list management is supposed to cover for. During our "up" period over the last four years, we have IMO relied too heavily (both in our list management and on game day) on Gawn, Oliver, Petracca and Viney being fit and able to carry us through seasons. The list needed more attention to the midfield over the last few years, not just last year, to ensure that with the inevitable injuries (long term or short) and fluctuations in form/fitness, we wouldn't be caught out like we have been this year.

Of course, list management isn't the only reason for our current predicament. Injuries have played their role. But I feel the problem with the position you take on here is that you put injuries as the far and away biggest determinant/factor, almost to the point of disregarding other factors. Obviously no Trac/Gus and Oliver/Viney/Gawn injured/unfit makes us worse, but Collingwood are closer to finals than we are and have had a much worse spate of injuries this year than we have.

18 minutes ago, Monbon said:

And it's all Goody's fault, like, I mean, players have 'chequed out', um, the recruiters are all Orangutans, anti-deluvian, the coaches are all part-time bozos, not to mention so totally incompetents they weren't there at all in 2021, and Viney, Sparrow and Chandler and Oliver are milking the system to build great investment portfolios. Oi Weh, the MFC is mired in duck muck, is all I can say, they are all nincompoopers, and it's got nothing to do wid the luck of the AFL Charlatans, the Draw, or injuries, just plain incompetence. I mean, even noncompoopers win flags, don't they? Like Sheedy and Jeans and even Joyce, and what about Malcolm the Blight...

And who's game plan is it? Just a simple question. 

5 minutes ago, titan_uranus said:

I don't agree.

It's obviously uncontroversial that we didn't know we were going to lose Brayshaw. But the rest is precisely what good list management is supposed to cover for. During our "up" period over the last four years, we have IMO relied too heavily (both in our list management and on game day) on Gawn, Oliver, Petracca and Viney being fit and able to carry us through seasons. The list needed more attention to the midfield over the last few years, not just last year, to ensure that with the inevitable injuries (long term or short) and fluctuations in form/fitness, we wouldn't be caught out like we have been this year.

Of course, list management isn't the only reason for our current predicament. Injuries have played their role. But I feel the problem with the position you take on here is that you put injuries as the far and away biggest determinant/factor, almost to the point of disregarding other factors. Obviously no Trac/Gus and Oliver/Viney/Gawn injured/unfit makes us worse, but Collingwood are closer to finals than we are and have had a much worse spate of injuries this year than we have.

We have plenty of time to get over Gus, other sides have lost important players over this year.

1 minute ago, demon3165 said:

We have plenty of time to get over Gus, other sides have lost important players over this year.

Look at what else has happened this year. I also don’t think some of you realise how important he was to our structure.

Edited August 3, 2024Aug 3 by Roost it far

1 minute ago, demon3165 said:

We have plenty of time to get over Gus, other sides have lost important players over this year.

Did you read anything else I wrote?

19 minutes ago, DeeSpencer said:

Have you watched us this year? We’ve re-invented the game plan, so much more run and risk taking from the backline, especially the young players who aren’t set in their ways. We’ve added speed and skill to the midfield from very limited choices (Rivers, ANB, Kossie). 

 

We tried to re invent but through a lack of skill and a slow midfield we were not able to implement it, we went back to 21 football done this since 21.

2 hours ago, WalkingCivilWar said:

I confirmed that the players adore Goody and that’s all I said. I didn’t address anything other than this. 

What else can they say ? They ain’t going to pot him publically.

 

Im sure they do - but they can still be against his coaching and game plan

Edited August 3, 2024Aug 3 by Gawndy the Great

7 minutes ago, titan_uranus said:

Did you read anything else I wrote?

I will admit I must have have not seen it, so apologies but people saying Gus was a main reason is wrong.