PODCAST: Practice Match vs Carlton

[Demonland 67,235]

The Demonland Podcast will air LIVE on Thursday, 29th February @ 8:30pm. Join George, Binman & I as we dissect the Practice Match victory over the Blues at Ikon Park.

You questions and comments are a huge part of our podcast so please post anything you want to ask or say below and we'll give you a shout out on the show.

If you would like to leave us a voicemail please call 03 9016 3666 and don't worry no body answers so you don't have to talk to a human.

Listen & Chat LIVE: https://demonland.com/podcast

Call: 03 9016 3666

Skype: Demonland31

[Return to Glory 7,923]

Sure, which former Dees player could we most liken Caleb Windsor to, even though it's early days?

 

[binman 40,494]

15 minutes ago, Return to Glory said:

Sure, which former Dees player could we most liken Caleb Windsor to, even though it's early days?

 

Funny you should ask that. A player immediately came to mind  which I thought I'd note on the pod.

And, on reading your q, another player came to mind.

[Return to Glory 7,923]

Looking forward to hearing it Binman

[Deeminion 355]

Thought we had the game sewn up at half time and I was very happy with what  I saw up until then. I know the 3 boys on the bench played in the earlier match but I would have liked to have seen more of Verrell, Brown and Tholstrup. What are your thoughts on their limited minutes and did you think we should have rested Max and a few others earlier. 

[Lefty 363]

Thought our forward connection was excellent and only let down by set shot kicking for goal. How do you think our key forwards fared? Schache? Roo?

[smurf 128]

I was beginning to lose faith in Sparrow and I thought he stood up after 1/4 time and had an excellent game kicking 3 goals. We need a big year from him given Gus’ retirement and Clarry’s potential absence. 

[Redjacket 711]

Interesting Centre Bounce Attendance stats that Andy posted in the Post Game Thread. I was really impressed with Salem's poise and polish in the middle and was pleasantly surprised that he attended the most Centre Bounces for the Dees with 22. Viney 20, Tracc 17, Sparrow 10 and Kozzy 9.

MELBOURNE

Player	Time On Ground %	Ranking Points	Disposals	Kick Ins	CBA
M.Gawn	74	185	24	0	0
T.Rivers	84	80	24	0	0
A.Neal-Bullen	83	110	23	0	3
C.Petracca	71	79	23	0	17
C.Salem	74	102	23	0	22
J.Viney	77	114	23	0	20
T.Sparrow	83	112	20	0	10
J.Billings	77	91	17	0	0
E.Langdon	92	60	17	0	0
B.Laurie	73	58	17	0	0
J.Bowey	79	76	16	3	0
J.Lever	99	95	16	0	0
K.Pickett	80	102	15	0	9
B.Fritsch	91	42	13	0	0
J.van Rooyen	65	79	11	0	0
C.Windsor	66	77	11	0	0
S.May	92	73	10	0	0
A.Tomlinson	100	78	10	0	0
J.McVee	77	34	9	0	0
J.Schache	78	57	9	0	0
K.Chandler	79	49	7	0	0
B.Howes	69	44	6	0	0
K.Brown	12	6	3	0	0
K.Tholstrup	13	8	2	0	3
W.Verrall	12	7	2	0	0

[Doug Reemer 1,039]

Been very critical of Schache. I thought that was his best competitive performance for the club so far, competed, took his chances rucked ok.

Didn't see Olivers VFL appearance, did he only play in the midfield? What was his rotating position?, if he comes in, what amount of time do you think he would play in the middle if he does against Sydney.

[pingu 68]

Devastated about the news of Gus' retirement last week. Champion player whose career has been tragically cut short. I hope the club can find a role for him. He will forever be a Premiership Demon.

He simply can't replace his onfield leadership but how do you think we will cover the important role he played?

[Wodjathefirst 2,535]

I believe Billings only played a handful of games for the Saints in the last two seasons due to a combination of injuries and form loss prior to coming over to us.

I know its early days but it appears that he has found a new lease on life. Boy does he have some silky skills. I am very bullish about how good this could turn out for him and us. I hope he plays in the ones against Sydney. No question from me, just a comment. 

[Skrull 102]

kozzy isn’t available for our match against the Swans in opening round . how will we cover his loss in the forward line and who takes his place ? I haven’t been overly impressed with any of our small forwards in the 2 praccy matches with the exception of kynan brown but he wasn't given much of a chance to put his hand against the blues . 

[leave it to deever 17,055]

11 hours ago, binman said:

Funny you should ask that. A player immediately came to mind  which I thought I'd note on the pod.

And, on reading your q, another player came to mind.

Travis Johnstone equals a young Caleb Windsor.

I'm guessing that's where you are going. I think a few noticed.

Is Salo in the middle a lock for the season?

Looking forward to the podcasts again.

 

Edited February 28 by leave it to deever

[Deeoldfart 7,922]

9 hours ago, Skrull said:

kozzy isn’t available for our match against the Swans in opening round . how will we cover his loss in the forward line and who takes his place ? I haven’t been overly impressed with any of our small forwards in the 2 praccy matches . 

Based on the Richmond match sim, I thought that Pup Brown might be a good chance.  What does the panel think?

ps.  I was disappointed that he wasn’t given more ground time against Carlton.  Could this be an indication that our Match Committee think he’s not quite ready?

[binman 40,494]

1 hour ago, leave it to deever said:

Travis Johnstone equals a young Caleb Windsor.

I'm guessing that's where you are going. I think a few noticed.

Is Salo in the middle a lock for the season?

Looking forward to the podcasts again.

 

Nup, not TJ.

TJ is an all time fav of mine, and funnily enough would probably suit footy cira 2024 better than when he played with the importance of wingers. And i can see the comparison. 

But whilst a smooth mover, Windsor strikes me as less, how should i put this - urgent? (was going to stay stoner like) and perhaps more hard it than TJ. And not as fast as Windsor.

Also, admittedly from a very limited sample size i'm not sure if Windsor is as good a kick as TJ, perhaps with Wattsy, the best kick i have seen at the dees.    

Edited February 28 by binman

[dino rover 680]

Isn’t Windsor faster?

[binman 40,494]

1 minute ago, dino rover said:

Isn’t Windsor faster?

Snap.

Agree, just though the same thing and edited my post accordingly 

[Deeoldfart 7,922]

I’ll enter the quiz and suggest Steven Stretch (but he’s probably before your time).

[Go the Biff 3,271]

14 hours ago, Return to Glory said:

Sure, which former Dees player could we most liken Caleb Windsor to, even though it's early days?

 

Strangely enough he reminded me of a former Carlton player.  David Glascott. Who was an absolute gun.

[The Chief 695]

Windsor reminds me of Alan Johnson, the loping stride with a bit of a back hunch. 

[kev martin 9,415]

Windsor reminds me of Stan Alves

[Bigfoot 249]

Very happy with the way we zoned in defence an were able to play tempo footy when needed. It was the mirror image of the way we played the Match Simulation against the Tigers. Playing Devil's Advocate here but were there any concerns that we still gave up their 3 goals apiece to their two key forwards in Curnow and McKay, the latter could have kicked 5 if he knew how to kick. Granted they're both Coleman Medalists and granted our defence shut down any other scoring opportunities and kept them to under 70 points.

[mandeelorian 161]

Let's not bury the lede here. Is Clarry getting selected to play in the Opening Round match against the Swans? It's time to fully welcome him back into the fold.

[Singa 192]

Surprised that there hasn't been more hype surrounding the Rematch of the Century in Gawn vs Grundy. Who wins the battle?

[Demonland 67,235]

Thank you to all who have asked questions or posted comments. I'm going to cut it off here as I need to put together the run sheet for the boys. See you tonight at 8:30pm or catch the pod on your preferred app tomorrow.