Team Of The Century

[UK Demon 75]

Seeing that few of us are going to be around to see the 2021 MFC Team of the Century named and that this month is usually the silly season of the AFL, I am calling for nominations. The century is a fifth old so theoretically that means four or five players. Unless of course you think that we are going to be so good in the future that none of our current players will get in.

By the way, it's snowing here!

[whatwhat say what 23,631]

it would definitely be limited you'd think

the likes of jones, neitz, schwarz, yze, and white, would be likely candidates based upon their current body of work from 2000 to now

current players under consideration would be gawn, oliver, and possibly petracca depending on what sort of impact they have as players over the next half a decade or more

you'd also hope that young players such as jackson, pickett, rivers, and who knows who else would be seriously considered depending on their next decade of performance

for the most part, we haven't had many 'star' performers this century; we've been fairly woeful on field

[tiers 2,875]

Only those who have finished their careers and whose whole body of work can be assessed should be considered.

Current players will have their chance next time.

Neitz, Schwarz are definitely in. Toss up for any others who, unfortunately, would have to displace premiership players from our successful eras.

 

[dieter 3,325]

Jetta              May           Frawley

Whelan         J.Rivers        Bizzel

Davey         Oliver            Woewodin    

Yze            Schwartz             Petracca

Farmer       Neitz              Green  

Gawn     Bruce           Johnstone

White,  McDonald, Vince,Jones

Edited February 11, 2021 by dieter

[Demon Dude 425]

15 minutes ago, dieter said:

Jetta              May           Frawley

Whelan         J.Rivers        Bizzel

Davey         Oliver            Woewodin    

Yze            Schwartz             Petracca

Farmer       Neitz              Green  

Gawn     Bruce           Johnstone

White,  , McDonald, Vince,Jones

that would have to be one of the most talented half forward lines you would ever see, and it's also probably my 3 favourite all time Demon players as well.

[Turner 1,516]

4 hours ago, dieter said:

Jetta              May           Frawley

Whelan         J.Rivers        Bizzel

Davey         Oliver            Woewodin    

Yze            Schwartz             Petracca

Farmer       Neitz              Green  

Gawn     Bruce           Johnstone

White,  McDonald, Vince,Jones

vince over moloney? and hard to include may after 2 years? bruce or johnstone instead 

[Little Goffy 14,793]

5 hours ago, Demon Dude said:

that would have to be one of the most talented half forward lines you would ever see, and it's also probably my 3 favourite all time Demon players as well.

I was going to say, Robertson is a bit unlucky to miss out on a forward spot but you can also see why.

[dieter 3,325]

17 minutes ago, Little Goffy said:

I was going to say, Robertson is a bit unlucky to miss out on a forward spot but you can also see why.

I had him in the original 22...Then I remembered Woewodin...

 

Edited February 11, 2021 by dieter

[dieter 3,325]

50 minutes ago, Turner said:

vince over moloney? and hard to include may after 2 years? bruce or johnstone instead 

BIt short on key defenders, when you examine it closely. Vince was a better ball user than Moloney, far more 'finessed.'

[WERRIDEE 5,601]

B: WHELAN, FRAWLEY, JETTA

HB: N.BROWN, J.RIVERS, S.FEBEY

C: YZE, JONES, WOEWODIN

HF: BRUCE, SCHWARZ, ROBERTSON

F: FARMER, NEITZ, DAVEY

FOLL: GAWN, JOHNSTONE, J.MCDONALD

IC:  T.MCDONALD, WHITE, MOLONEY, GREEN

[Turner 1,516]

6 hours ago, dieter said:

BIt short on key defenders, when you examine it closely. Vince was a better ball user than Moloney, far more 'finessed.'

i mean is frawley not a key defender, and you've seen how AA teams are picked teams of the centuries are picked similarly, just get the good players in and stick to a traditional ish side, no need for second talls and 4th rucks they don't actually have to play anyone

[58er 6,849]

7 hours ago, Turner said:

vince over moloney? and hard to include may after 2 years? bruce or johnstone instead 

I know Who  most Teams would like to face At the opening bounce and it's Bruce and Johnstone rather than Clarry and Trac.

Ironically Trav is a Centreman  really and Bruce mainly a half forward So changing  them and 10% toughness would be the result.and players in their best possie also.

In addition Vince might provide versatility but our Bernie is not the Adelaide version do Robbie as our third highest goal kicker earns a bench spot on  decade of devotion and thrills he gave us! ( Still he hardly ever picked up a ball off the ground once he flew and missed the mark).

Did  Bizzell play long enough  ? I mean Ward Walsh Even Hibbo have played enough In comparison.

Ingerson surely over May who in 2 years will be a cert for  FB.
 

[dieter 3,325]

On 2/11/2021 at 11:56 PM, 58er said:

I know Who  most Teams would like to face At the opening bounce and it's Bruce and Johnstone rather than Clarry and Trac.

Ironically Trav is a Centreman  really and Bruce mainly a half forward So changing  them and 10% toughness would be the result.and players in their best possie also.

In addition Vince might provide versatility but our Bernie is not the Adelaide version do Robbie as our third highest goal kicker earns a bench spot on  decade of devotion and thrills he gave us! ( Still he hardly ever picked up a ball off the ground once he flew and missed the mark).

Did  Bizzell play long enough  ? I mean Ward Walsh Even Hibbo have played enough In comparison.

Ingerson surely over May who in 2 years will be a cert for  FB.
 

I would change Ingerson for Rivers, Steve Febey for Bizzel. The rest would be the same, maybe Johnstone in the centre, Oliver on the ball, 

[Queanbeyan Demon 6,958]

I note the Pedo has somehow been omitted from all lists. 

[In Harmes Way 7,842]

In determining whether any current players will make the 2000 team of the century, I'm of the view that the selectors will be our great grandchildren and probably not up to date with current talent. They'd probably take one look at the 2010-2020 results and look no further.

In evaluating the 1900 team of the century, only two players made the team from pre 1930's (Bert Chadwick and Ivor Warne-Smith, who won two Brownlows). 6 players from the three-peat team 1939-1941 and 11 from the most dominant team of all time in the 50's. More recently than 1965, the selectors picked Hardeman, Flower, Lyon, Stynes and Viney. 

I'd imagine the 2000 team of the century will have much the same profile, unless we start winning a bunch of flags soon (hoping).