22 Under 22 2019

[Demonland 72,186]

Here is the squad.

Only 2 Demons and Bayley in as a Defender.

VOTE for the final team here: VOTE FOR 22UNDER22

[Kent 2,909]

This doesn't look good for our future

Lots of development of Dees' players required quickly.

[praha 11,240]

1 hour ago, Kent said:

This doesn't look good for our future

Lots of development of Dees' players required quickly.

Why? We had the most number of players in this team last year if I remember correctly. Most would be +22 now. 

Ideally most premiership teams have a core of 26-28 year olds in their prime. We are knocking on the door. This is why Goodwin and co absolutely need to fill the gaps because we need to get as much finals experience into this core group as possible. Otherwise we'll just end up with a team of Nathan Jones'.

Quick rise back up. 2019 was a failure. Fail quickly. Mini rebuild this offseason built around our core group of Oliver, Brayshaw, Tmac, Fritsch, Trac, Gawn, Lever, Salem, May. Move on Jones. Keep Lewis for another year. Move Jetta into a player-coaching role. Trade Hibberd and get some more class in our defensive 6. 

Make a decision on AVB. Either get him playing senior footy or get rid of him. Trade ANB and get in players that can impact the contest. Some outside run to help Harmes and compliment Oliver. Do what you can to get Hill over the line.

Touch decisions need to be made. 

Edited August 7, 2019 by praha

[poita 3,902]

3 minutes ago, praha said:

Why?

Because over the next couple of years we will lose Lewis, Jones, Jetta, Hibberd and Garlett, most of whom are regulars, from an already  poor team and the replacements are not obvious. We should have quality young players with a couple of years on the list ready to take over when the time comes.

[praha 11,240]

3 minutes ago, poita said:

Because over the next couple of years we will lose Lewis, Jones, Jetta, Hibberd and Garlett, most of whom are regulars, from an already  poor team and the replacements are not obvious. We should have quality young players with a couple of years on the list ready to take over when the time comes.

Yes I did add to my comment to address this (mostly). Jones and Garlett are not huge losses imo. Lewis and Jetta moreso than anyone. I would keep Lewis for another year and start getting Jetta into a coaching role. 

[Lord Travis 10,730]

This is the direct result of not drafting any elite young talent in the first round of the draft for four years. 

[ManDee 7,147]

37 minutes ago, Lord Travis said:

This is the direct result of not drafting any elite young talent in the first round of the draft for four years. 

Clayton Oliver says hi!

[old55 23,573]

23-25 year olds on MFC list:

Best 22: Salem, Harmes, Petracca, Lever, Brayshaw

Solid performers: Hore, Hunt

Depth/Developing: Preuss, JKH, OMac, ANB

Currently injured: J.Smith, KK

[sue 9,106]

6 hours ago, Kent said:

This doesn't look good for our future

Lots of development of Dees' players required quickly.

There are 42 in that list if I counted right.  With 18 clubs, on average there would only be 2.3 from each team.  So we seem to be average with 2 and it's hard to find 0.3 of a player though some might say some on our list are worth about that. (Lots of development would be nice too).

Edited August 7, 2019 by sue

[Lord Travis 10,730]

18 minutes ago, ManDee said:

Clayton Oliver says hi!

Exactly the point. If we didn’t trade away 3 first round draft picks for players who can’t stay on the park, we could have 3 more Clayton Oliver’s out there now.

[Demonstone 22,518]

13 minutes ago, Lord Travis said:

we could have 3 more Clayton Oliver’s out there now.

There's only one Clayton Oliver.

[old55 23,573]

12 minutes ago, Lord Travis said:

Exactly the point. If we didn’t trade away 3 first round draft picks for players who can’t stay on the park, we could have 3 more Clayton Oliver’s out there now.

So you're saying Lever and May are permanent busts?  I look forward to having this conversation same time in 2020.

[Lord Travis 10,730]

1 minute ago, Fifty-5 said:

So you're saying Lever and May are permanent busts?  I look forward to having this conversation same time in 2020.

Lever looks like a bust for what we paid. Two first rounders is superstar territory, and he isn’t a superstar. I rate him as a good player, but it appears his body isn’t up to the rigors of afl. For roughly the picks we gave up we could've had Aaron Naughton and Xavier Duursma.

May has been a disappointment thus far. He’ll be 29 next year so it’s not like we have him playing for long either. We could’ve got him for free this year via free agency instead.

I find it confusing that most on here are defensive of the clubs list management choices. We’re 17th. They got it wrong. Proof is in the pudding. We need to focus on bringing in elite youth now to rectify the mistakes made and rebalance the list.

[dimmy 1,307]

6 from Carlton .

How come Henry from Gellong missed out  and Blakey from Swans

[brendan 3,437]

I wonder if they will make Oliver captain seeing he is the best player on that list 

[praha 11,240]

16 hours ago, Lord Travis said:

I find it confusing that most on here are defensive of the clubs list management choices. We’re 17th. They got it wrong. Proof is in the pudding. We need to focus on bringing in elite youth now to rectify the mistakes made and rebalance the list.

It is bizarre, isn't it? If we have a similarly disappointing year in 2020, we're looking at another 3-4 years down the bottom as we rebuild our list again. 

Next year is either we sharply improve and content, or we stay where we are. IMO there is no in between that will occur.

[old55 23,573]

16 hours ago, Lord Travis said:

Lever looks like a bust for what we paid. Two first rounders is superstar territory, and he isn’t a superstar. I rate him as a good player, but it appears his body isn’t up to the rigors of afl. For roughly the picks we gave up we could've had Aaron Naughton and Xavier Duursma.

Interesting that you selected the two players that were chosen directly BEFORE our selections in both those 2017 and 2018 drafts - players that would not have been available to us - so no we couldn't have had Naughton or Duursma.  But then your argument looks a bit weaker if you nominate Lochie O'Brien and Liam Stocker who were actually taken at the traded picks doesn't it?

[Red and Blue realist 2,051]

17 hours ago, Lord Travis said:

Lever looks like a bust for what we paid. Two first rounders is superstar territory, and he isn’t a superstar. I rate him as a good player, but it appears his body isn’t up to the rigors of afl. For roughly the picks we gave up we could've had Aaron Naughton and Xavier Duursma.

May has been a disappointment thus far. He’ll be 29 next year so it’s not like we have him playing for long either. We could’ve got him for free this year via free agency instead.

I find it confusing that most on here are defensive of the clubs list management choices. We’re 17th. They got it wrong. Proof is in the pudding. We need to focus on bringing in elite youth now to rectify the mistakes made and rebalance the list.

Fair bit of leverage taken with nearly everything in this post. May will turn 28 early next year. We got Lever and Petty for essentially  Lachie O'Brien and Liam Stocker. 

Are you also saying that had we brought in more youth last draft that we wouldn't be in the same position? Surely we spent so many years going back to the draft that the time is to focus on winning, we made the prelim last year and you suggest that youth is the way to go?? We've had an ordinary season but in no way would a few extra young kids have made it any better.