6: Watts

5: Oliver

4: Hibberd

3: Hunt

2: Jetta

1: Stretch

6. Hibberd

5. Oliver

4. Hunt

3. Petracca

2. Watts

1. Melksham

I found it extremely difficult to separate my top three.  A lot was asked of them, and they did the red and blue proud in demanding circumstances.  The next tier was also difficult, and a few were unlucky not to feature.

 6.  Oliver  

5.  Watts 

4.  Hibberd

3.  Hunt

2.  Jetta

1.  Petracca

6. Clayton Oliver

5. Michael Hibberd

4. Jayden Hunt

3. Jack Watts

2. Neville Jetta

1. Billy Stretch.

6. Oliver

5. Hibberd

4. Hunt

3. Petracca

2. Watts

1. Frost

 

1. Oliver 4.80 / 1st - just over Hibberd....over use of handball when a quick kick i50 will do just as much damage a high percentage of time

2. Hibberd 4.08 / 2nd

3. Watts 2.93 / 11th - no hit out stats included but a 2.93 score around the ground was only bettered by Big Maxy in Rnd 2 vs the Blues where he scored 3.28!

4. Garlett 3.73 / 8th - our only effective forward who also played a fantastic 2nd half much of it up the field, admittedly most of the good work after half time.

5. Hunt 4.03 / 3rd - ran out of steam with about 10 to go in the 3rd but was brilliant up till then.

6. T-Mac 3.95 / 4th - undid some of his solid early work in the 2nd half with some costly one on one losses but he was taking their best forward.

Edited April 26, 20178 yr by Rusty Nails

Michael Hibberd's terrific debut was rewarded with plenty of points but Clayton Oliver was very good too and he increases his lead on the progressive points table.

57. Clayton Oliver
42. Jack Watts
41. Nathan Jones
28. Jayden Hunt
23. Jeff Garlett
16. Michael Hibberd Christian Salem
13. Christian Petracca
11. Max Gawn Dom Tyson
7. Alex Neal-Bullen
6. Jordan Lewis  Bernie Vince          
5. Dean Kent Tom McDonald Billy Stretch 
4. Jesse Hogan Neville Jetta 
2. Jake Melksham 
 

Oliver

watts

Hibberd

Hunt,

jetta

 Viney 

The first four were easy (although ordering them was hard). The last two were near impossible to identify.

6. Hibberd

5. Oliver

4. Hunt

3. Watts

2. Melksham (yes, truly)

1. Vince (yes, truly)

Viney was great in the first quarter, Petracca struggled manfully and creatively in patches, and Tom McDonald was good when he wasn't actually anywhere near Jack Reiwoldt. 

17 hours ago, Demonland said:

Michael Hibberd's terrific debut was rewarded with plenty of points but Clayton Oliver was very good too and he increases his lead on the progressive points table.

57. Clayton Oliver
42. Jack Watts
41. Nathan Jones
28. Jayden Hunt
23. Jeff Garlett
16. Michael Hibberd Christian Salem
13. Christian Petracca
11. Max Gawn Dom Tyson
7. Alex Neal-Bullen
6. Jordan Lewis  Bernie Vince          
5. Dean Kent Tom McDonald Billy Stretch 
4. Jesse Hogan Neville Jetta 
2. Jake Melksham 
 

Incredible to see that Viney does not have a single vote, what a strange year he is having so far.

Watts in second place.

Go Jack!

6- Hibberd

5- hunt

4- Watts

3- Oliver

2- Jetta

1- Frost

On Tuesday, April 25, 2017 at 0:52 PM, Rusty Nails said:

1. Oliver 4.80 / 1st - just over Hibberd....over use of handball when a quick kick i50 will do just as much damage a high percentage of time

2. Hibberd 4.08 / 2nd

3. Watts 2.93 / 11th - no hit out stats included but a 2.93 score around the ground was only bettered by Big Maxy in Rnd 2 vs the Blues where he scored 3.28!

4. Garlett 3.73 / 8th - our only effective forward who also played a fantastic 2nd half much of it up the field, admittedly most of the good work after half time.

5. Hunt 4.03 / 3rd - ran out of steam with about 10 to go in the 3rd but was brilliant up till then.

6. T-Mac 3.95 / 4th - undid some of his solid early work in the 2nd half with some costly one on one losses but he was taking their best forward.

Watched the game AGAIN on replay. Oliver was a bull but ineffective in disposals. 30 plus possessions but should use handballs more wisely

 10 turnovers... ouch.

He can be a Star but needs to run and deliver. The kid must be taught how to use his power. His extract to GARLETT  showed his ability.