6 - Viney

5 - TMac

4 - Watts

3 - Kennedy

2 - Oliver

1 - Gawn

6. Watts

5.Viney

4.McDonald.T

3.Kennedy

2.Gawn

1.Oliver

6 - Viney ( a complete game )

5 -  T,McDonald ( reliable, effective, convincing )

4 - Watts ( loved his new found endeavour and passion )

3 - N.Jones ( prolific and led from the front )

2 - Kennedy ( short in stature but big in endeavour and heart )

1 - Oliver ( focused and skilled )

6 Viney (I said way back he was our Joel Selwood)

5 T-Mac (Started just like last season)

4 Kennedy (Kept bobbing up when we need him)

3 Gawn (what was our biggest worry pre-game - Mummy)

2 Watts (brilliant first and last terms, the latter limited by a corkie).

1 Hogan (the other matchwinner with JW - just like Lethal, does nothing and then steps up and wins the game for you. Didn't even need to take out three players).

 

6 Viney

5 Mc Donald T

4. Watts

3 Oliver

2 Kennedy

1. Jones N

3 hours ago, Nasher said:

Is Jetta that underrated amongst Melbourne fans? I think the main sentiment is acknowledgement that he just quietly goes about his business; defends solidly and rarely wastes the ball when he has it. He doesn't do things that get a lot of attention (compared to TMac with the marking, for example) but I reckon most would agree that he's an important part of the team. I certainly haven't read much negative sentiment towards him at all since he was reinvented as a back pocket by Roos.

6. Watts

5. Viney

4. T. Mac

3. Oliver

2. Kennedy

1. Salem

3 hours ago, Nasher said:

Is Jetta that underrated amongst Melbourne fans? I think the main sentiment is acknowledgement that he just quietly goes about his business; defends solidly and rarely wastes the ball when he has it. He doesn't do things that get a lot of attention (compared to TMac with the marking, for example) but I reckon most would agree that he's an important part of the team. I certainly haven't read much negative sentiment towards him at all since he was reinvented as a back pocket by Roos.

I cannot understand how Salem's game has suddenly gone unnoticed? It is not as though he has put a step wrong.

6 Viney

5 Watts

4 Hogan

3 Gawn

2 Oliver

1 Vince

As is our practice, we have taken three sets of votes at random and, as a result, the round 1 leaderboard reads -

18 Jack Viney

11 Ben Kennedy

10 Jack Watts

9 Tom McDonald

7 Nathan Jones

6 Clayton Oliver

2 Max Gawn

21 hours ago, Return to Glory said:

GTG, I always like what you have to say but....Jones well ahead of Watts? Not for mine.

I've always been a Watts fan and I definitely understand why he's getting a lot of votes here. I had him lower in my ranking due to how quiet he was in Q2 and Q3, but that doesn't mean that I wasn't very impressed with his game.

6 - Viney

5 - Watts

4 - T Mcdonald

3 - N Jones

2 - Gawn

1 - Oliver

6. Viney - Son of a gun

5. Watts - keep it up

4. T McDonald - good confidence and solid in defence, may he be the rock that the forwards smash themselves on

3. C Oliver - well deserved

2. N Jones - Captain deserved

1. C. Salem -  great skills and composure

 

6. Viney - Son of a gun

5. Watts - keep it up

4. T McDonald - good confidence and solid in defence, may he be the rock that the forwards smash themselves on

3. C Oliver - well deserved

2. N Jones - Captain deserved

1. C. Salem -  great skills and composure

 

6. Viney - Son of a gun

5. Watts - keep it up

4. T McDonald - good confidence and solid in defence, may he be the rock that the forwards smash themselves on

3. C Oliver - well deserved

2. N Jones - Captain deserved

1. C. Salem -  great skills and composure

 

6. Viney - Son of a gun

5. Watts - keep it up

4. T McDonald - good confidence and solid in defence, may he be the rock that the forwards smash themselves on

3. C Oliver - well deserved

2. N Jones - Captain deserved

1. C. Salem -  great skills and composure

 

6 - Viney - consistent 4 qtrs, and stood up during the middle patch where things weren't going our way.

5 - McDonald - very solid in defence all game.

4 - Watts - He started the resurgence and had numerous important touches. He seemed really vocal all game, too.

3 - Kennedy - like Watts, had a huge last qtr and plenty of score involvements.

2 - N Jones - solid captain's game and his move into defence really steadied us.

1 - Gawn - Had an excellent game on Mummy.

 

6-Viney

5-Watts

4-Kennedy

3-Salem

2-TMac

1-Clarrie

Gawn !!!  Maxy was huge today Mumford is a match winner and Maxy cancelled him out and took the chocolates . Room for improvement but super important in relation to our win.

6. Viney

5. T McDonald

4. Watts

3. Kennedy

2. N Jones

2. M Jones

6. Viney

5. T Mcdonald

4. Watts

3. Kennedy

2. Oliver

1. N. Jones

6.  Viney

5. Watts

4  Kennedy

3.  T. Mac

2.  Gawn

1.  N Jones