9 hours ago, dazzledavey36 said:

 http://www.foxsports.com.au/afl/afl-premiership/melbourne-players-no-longer-protecting-their-own-backyard-in-new-selfless-culture/story-e6frf3e3-1227696844398

Blah, Blah .... Blah, blah, blah.

3 minutes ago, Fork 'em said:

Blah, Blah .... Blah, blah, blah.

So that's your contribution?

If you don't like what you read don't bother to comment if its such a sensitive issue for you.

simple really.

1 hour ago, McQueen said:

This is it though.

If Jack Viney was interviewed and made the same comments we'd all be banging on about how awesome it was.

No we wouldn't. I wouldn't. And I'd marry JV if Mrs P would let me.

They are just fluffy words. Whose saying them is irrelevant. Clearly a lot the fans are done with fluffy words.

By all means talk about the fantastic change of culture and mindset. But don't expect everyone to actually give a damn. Not until we are buying tickets to the football in September. Seeing is believing.

2 minutes ago, P-man said:

No we wouldn't. I wouldn't. And I'd marry JV if Mrs P would let me.

They are just fluffy words. Whose saying them is irrelevant. Clearly a lot the fans are done with fluffy words.

By all means talk about the fantastic change of culture and mindset. But don't expect everyone to actually give a damn. Not until we are buying tickets to the football in September. Seeing is believing.

So let's just have zero media coverage and interviews with players until we play finals?

Should we just take Roosy and Goodies word at face value?

I know, let's beg Saty back to the forum so we can get all the juicy goss.

sadly same stuff we have all heard before 

results will win me over ...

show me the wins on the board and i am a believer 

9 hours ago, The Song Formerly Known As said:

same stuff said, just said differently every year for 8 years now. big, MEH, from me.

You actually think things are same now under the new regime as they have been previously?

Certainly looks and feels very different to me. Very different.

 

15 minutes ago, McQueen said:

So let's just have zero media coverage and interviews with players until we play finals?

Should we just take Roosy and Goodies word at face value?

I know, let's beg Saty back to the forum so we can get all the juicy goss.

yeah nah

10 minutes ago, Ron Burgundy said:

You actually think things are same now under the new regime as they have been previously?

Certainly looks and feels very different to me. Very different.

 

i didn't say that. I said same stuff "SAID". Behind the scenes it's different, as we know. But the players need to now be a result of that action through winning performances, for it not to be the same jargon said by the players to the media every pre-season.

45 minutes ago, dazzledavey36 said:

So that's your contribution?

If you don't like what you read don't bother to comment if its such a sensitive issue for you.

simple really.

 If my contribution is such a sensitive issue then scroll on past Fork head.
 Simple really.

 

 

 

Edited January 4, 20169 yr by Fork 'em

44 minutes ago, McQueen said:

So let's just have zero media coverage and interviews with players until we play finals?

Should we just take Roosy and Goodies word at face value?

I know, let's beg Saty back to the forum so we can get all the juicy goss.

Player interviews and media coverage are important. It's just difficult not to zone out when they start talking about how much better/more professional things are than they once were. It's a tune sung every single year.

The boy keeps crying wolf and maybe it really is a wolf this time. But I wanna see it for myself 

16 hours ago, Mad_Melbourne said:

One thread gets locked, another opened. Admittedly this is based on an article, but the hilarity of people suggesting that people no longer care about the fella. 

I like the statements about culture but it's all stuff that every football club says and is almost certainly dictated to him via media management. 

I wonder if the club used jacky for this reason though. He'll either be a hero or a scapegoat as a result. Maybe it's puts some more pressure on him to perform. 

13 hours ago, bing181 said:

If there's an interview with a player, they're criticised because it's "only words" and meaningless. If there's no interview with players, the club is criticised because of a lack of communication.

Damned if you do, damned if you don't.

(Not sure what exactly people expect them to say ...)

Really? I couldn't give a crap about this sort of media release. Much prefer reading Roosy's brief pre season updates. I think most on here feel words like this are very cheap without actions to match and the irony of who made this release is not lost on anyone here. 

18 hours ago, Robot Devil said:

In 2014 I think I saw about 1 or 2 shepherds from a Melbourne player. 

In 2015 I think I saw about 6 or 7 shepherds from a Melbourne player. 

There has been improvement but hopefully we can start shepherding and protecting team mates regularly in every match instead of playing Hot Potato with the football whilst we handball to players backs or stationary targets. 

 

 

 

Shepherding is a fast disappearing play in football.

The choice has become shepherd and hope that it is successful to allow your teammate free passage as opposed to not shepherding but create your own space to take the ball as your teammate takes the tackle.

Where we have been poor is we haven't shepherded or made space to take the receive. You have got to do one or the other.

I see Hodge shepard a lot & quite often use it as a weapon to hurt opponents. There's a reason why Hawks are so good & part of it is team's like us play scared against them. Thankfully we have blokes like Viney & Hogan coming through..... 

14 hours ago, Munga said:

Seeing that Watts thread was locked yesterday guys, do you think we can turn this in to our new Jack Watts thread? 

maybe a watts = jack thread?

44 minutes ago, thevil1 said:

Really? I couldn't give a crap about this sort of media release. Much prefer reading Roosy's brief pre season updates. I think most on here feel words like this are very cheap without actions to match and the irony of who made this release is not lost on anyone here. 

It is Jan the 5th ..... very hard to put words into actions when we are 2 months from playing a game in anger.   All clubs, at this time of the year have puff pieces to keep their club members in touch and there will be many more before the games start.   Get used to it 

15 minutes ago, Bossdog said:

It is Jan the 5th ..... very hard to put words into actions when we are 2 months from playing a game in anger.   All clubs, at this time of the year have puff pieces to keep their club members in touch and there will be many more before the games start.   Get used to it 

Who said I wasn't used to it? My club put it out there & I can comment on it all I like. 

no more selfies!

Last Season the MFC lost shocking games to Essendrug and bottom feeder Carlton  

until results like this are completely eradicated the above media puff piece is merley chip wrapper...

15 minutes ago, Sir Why You Little said:

Last Season the MFC lost shocking games to Essendrug and bottom feeder Carlton  

until results like this are completely eradicated the above media puff piece is merley chip wrapper...

Yes your right SWYL........But until we start to play games, nothing can be done about it.     I like seeing articles about our club rather than not.   I know it all means jack but it's better than nothing.

4 minutes ago, Bossdog said:

Yes your right SWYL........But until we start to play games, nothing can be done about it.     I like seeing articles about our club rather than not.   I know it all means jack but it's better than nothing.

I know what you mean Boss but i am just so over positive interviews  that are then followed up with Game Day results that just do not back it up. 

That said i do have a good feeling about 2016. I believe Roosy will want to back away from the senior job as a winner. 

For me that is a September appearance. 

The players should be wanting that as well

2 hours ago, thevil1 said:

I see Hodge shepard a lot & quite often use it as a weapon to hurt opponents. There's a reason why Hawks are so good & part of it is team's like us play scared against them. Thankfully we have blokes like Viney & Hogan coming through..... 

Spot on.

Theyre called 1%'s for a reason and can be real team-lifter when applied timely and with intent to hurt an opponent.

we havent laid a shepherd for years.

and then we wonder why our kicking accuracy is so poor...

Didn't he say the samething under Neeld?! 

3 hours ago, biggestred said:

no more selfies!

and no more monkeys jumping on the bed