Adam Treloar

[Redleg 41,432]

This isn't a rumor, just a hypothetical.

If Howe is traded for pick 15 (North's pick, and of course just speculation that this would happen), would pick 6, 15, 43 be enough to get Treloar and Bugg?

If not, what needs to be added/substituted to make it work?

Absolutely. That is more than the Dangerfield deal.

[Redleg 41,432]

You need to have atleast have 3 live picks in the draft.

I thought you just needed to make 3 list changes. They could be trades, draft picks,upgrades, or whatever

[Redleg 41,432]

On SEN they are saying that the Pies are meeting with Howe probably in Bali ad could make a big play for him.

I think that could be a disaster for us.

If we have made enquiries of GWS re Treloar and the Pies know, then they could stop us getting a pick to give GWS, by convincing Howe to nominate them and then just stuffing around until the last day, where we are forced into a firesale for him.

All hypothetical of course.

[RalphiusMaximus 6,088]

On SEN they are saying that the Pies are meeting with Howe probably in Bali ad could make a big play for him.

I think that could be a disaster for us.

If we have made enquiries of GWS re Treloar and the Pies know, then they could stop us getting a pick to give GWS, by convincing Howe to nominate them and then just stuffing around until the last day, where we are forced into a firesale for him.

All hypothetical of course.

Why would you want to go to the Pies, who missed out on finals, when you could go to a team that has made the prelims the last two years?

[H_T 3,049]

On SEN they are saying that the Pies are meeting with Howe probably in Bali ad could make a big play for him.

I think that could be a disaster for us.

If we have made enquiries of GWS re Treloar and the Pies know, then they could stop us getting a pick to give GWS, by convincing Howe to nominate them and then just stuffing around until the last day, where we are forced into a firesale for him.

All hypothetical of course.

I agree with this. And yes hypothetical, but it would snuff it out. Kind of hoping North get him, unless GC can help us out somehow.

[PaulRB 6,411]

How could the Pies get Treloar, Howe, etc... pickwise?

[Redleg 41,432]

How could the Pies get Treloar, Howe, etc... pickwise?

Kennedy.

[Mach5 4,768]

Kennedy.

Not enough.

Pies can jog on.

[Mondê 525]

Why would you want to go to the Pies, who missed out on finals, when you could go

to a team that has made the prelims the last two years?

Because Collingwood is closer to a flag than North.

The wheels are about to fall off at the Kangas.

[Cards13 9,117]

Because Collingwood is closer to a flag than North.

The wheels are about to fall off at the Kangas.

Not if they have guns like Howe playing for them..

[beelzebub 23,383]

Jungle drums suggest deal done.. Treloar to be a Pie

[MadAsHell 4,215]

Kennedy.

& 26?

[demoniac 1,336]

So Treloar had groin surgery in Tassie after his Pies medical but did not tell the club he is still contracted to about the surgery. Nothing to do with the Pies of course.

[RalphiusMaximus 6,088]

So Treloar had groin surgery in Tassie after his Pies medical but did not tell the club he is still contracted to about the surgery. Nothing to do with the Pies of course.

Who paid for it? That sort of thing would normally be covered by the club (GC). If you're saying they didn't know, did the Pies pay? Their insurance wouldn't cover him. Did he pay for it himself?

[H_T 3,049]

Who paid for it? That sort of thing would normally be covered by the club (GC). If you're saying they didn't know, did the Pies pay? Their insurance wouldn't cover him. Did he pay for it himself?

GWS.

[RalphiusMaximus 6,088]

GWS.

Good point. I have GC on the brain over the Howe situation.

[Lucifers Hero 40,362]

So Treloar had groin surgery in Tassie after his Pies medical but did not tell the club he is still contracted to about the surgery. Nothing to do with the Pies of course.

From AFL website on Treloar's operation: 'The Giants are now seeking clarification from Treloar and his manager Peter Blucher, who said: "I’m not saying anything about anything until everything is done. I’m not saying a word about anything." ...Collingwood assured the Giants it had no involvement in the operation.'

This is the same Blucher guy who was so 'honest' with mfc in his management of one TS several years ago.

It sounds like he has a story to tell but isn't telling...

...If he is quoted correctly it seems a case of 'he who protests too much'!.

Sorry to be cynical folks but I don't trust a word that guy says!

I would expect the AFL to be asking a few questions and check who paid the medical bills!!

Edit: Bulcher is also the guy who was suspended for a year over the Kurt Tippett fiasco.

Edited October 17, 2015 by Lucifer's Hero

[Cards13 9,117]

Wow, that really is an odd scenario, would that be break of contract? It certainly is not working in good faith.

[beelzebub 23,383]

Filth welcome to him...and may yhey pay through the nose.

[Redleg 41,432]

Filth welcome to him...and may yhey pay through the nose.

You think they didn't organize it so he would be ready for 2016?

[beelzebub 23,383]

You think they didn't organize it so he would be ready for 2016?

quite likely and i wish the karma fairies to unleash retribution for dodgy dealings

[dazzledavey36 55,347]

From AFL website on Treloar's operation: 'The Giants are now seeking clarification from Treloar and his manager Peter Blucher, who said: "Im not saying anything about anything until everything is done. Im not saying a word about anything." ...Collingwood assured the Giants it had no involvement in the operation.'

This is the same Blucher guy who was so 'honest' with mfc in his management of one TS several years ago.

It sounds like he has a story to tell but isn't telling...

...If he is quoted correctly it seems a case of 'he who protests too much'!.

Sorry to be cynical folks but I don't trust a word that guy says!

I would expect the AFL to be asking a few questions and check who paid the medical bills!!

Edit: Bulcher is also the guy who was suspended for a year over the Kurt Tippett fiasco.

Wow really? How the hell is he allowed back in AFL industrie?

Something definitely not right there.

Edited October 17, 2015 by dazzledavey36

[SaberFang 7,151]

Groin surgery in another state. Yeah, pure coincidence.

LOL.

Gotta love the way rich clubs get away with whatever they want. Obviously nothing came of the contract Maguire's company gave Treloar's girlfriend, either. Shocking.

[ignition. 1,466]

Treloar's been one of my favourite young players to watch over the last few years.

I think I'm goin to loathe him running around in the Collingwood colours.

Edited October 17, 2015 by ignition.

[beelzebub 23,383]

Isn't it a given...you just loathe Collingwood?