Post Match Discussion - Round 19

[Demonsone 2,043]

Tomorrow at work the smug Roos supporters will come up to me and say "Dees showed a bit".

Like they have done since time started.[/quote

The complete rebuild of tour club from top to bottom is a work in progress, Roos is building a foundation & has turned over the list with 18 players & more to come . The reality is we are a better performing team & should have been on 8 wins which is a far cry if a train wreck in 2013 & getting smashed each week... bomber Thompson took 8 years to win a flag & build a power house club .. Reality guys????

[Dr. Gonzo 24,237]

N Jones hasn't played a big game in a while. Needs to work on breaking a tag

Umm he was pretty good against the Pies last week.

[Gorgoroth 12,976]

How reliable has Nate become at kicking goals when the team needs one!

[dazzledavey36 55,105]

Can somebody point me in the direction of anything official at all that talks about this supposed virus that swept the club, apparently affecting multiple players at both the MFC and Casey? Is this just a Demonland rumour or something more? If it is in fact true, I would suggest the club acknowledge it formally as you could well argue it cost us a match this week.

Paul Roos confirmed Jack Watts was pretty crook before the game, Jack Fitzpatrick pulled out of the VFL game because he too was pretty crook, Toumpas was also pretty ill on the weekend and Jayden Hunt the week before.. so something definitely went through the club.

[rjay 25,012]

Can somebody point me in the direction of anything official at all that talks about this supposed virus that swept the club, apparently affecting multiple players at both the MFC and Casey? Is this just a Demonland rumour or something more? If it is in fact true, I would suggest the club acknowledge it formally as you could well argue it cost us a match this week.

Roos made mention of it last night on 360 in passing. Said it effected players but a lot of clubs have to deal with it at this stage of the season..

[daisycutter 29,627]

Can somebody point me in the direction of anything official at all that talks about this supposed virus that swept the club, apparently affecting multiple players at both the MFC and Casey? Is this just a Demonland rumour or something more? If it is in fact true, I would suggest the club acknowledge it formally as you could well argue it cost us a match this week.

someone said roos made mention of jw being sick during week and touch and go if he played

fitzy didn't come up for magoos

comments (dl) re toumpas was crook with a cold

but nothing from club about large numbers being infected during week

these days a 5% drop-off can make a huge difference in your score/performance

[old dee 23,805]

someone said roos made mention of jw being sick during week and touch and go if he played

fitzy didn't come up for magoos

comments (dl) re toumpas was crook with a cold

but nothing from club about large numbers being infected during week

these days a 5% drop-off can make a huge difference in your score/performance

Yes dc during 2012/3 we had the worse flu ever

[praha 11,240]

Watched the game last night. Was in transit when it was on so missed it. Would have been there otherwise.

Few notes:

- Dawes undoubtedly played his best game for the club, and probably his best game since vs Adelaide in 2014

- Tyson was in and out but his decision making was better

- Brayshaw's mark, run and goal in the 3rd made me orgasm. He is going to be spectacular. Seems like he needs a rest, though

- Viney is having a fantastic second half of the year

- Our defensive breakdowns aren't structural or coachable: they're issues that persist among experienced players

- Jones has been blanketed by the tag on more occasions this year than on others

- Vince's inability to get into the game cost us dearly

- Gawns was great but soundly beaten. Great learning game

- Jack Grimes and Viv Michie are depth players. We severely miss Kent and Salem

- Garlett was disappointingly shallow and lazy. I thought he's been great for most of the year with his second-efforts and forward defense but he was very poor. We needed him to be more involved

All in all, I actually thought it was a very enjoyable game. Winnable, but unsurprising they got over us. I thought our experienced players cost us many goals in the first quarter. Quite telling that it's now an issue of how poor our experienced players are, rather than how inexperienced we are. We were let down by 100+ game players on Sunday.

Edited August 11, 2015 by praha

[P-man 13,366]

Praha - Not sure if you've read elsewhere but there were a few who were hit with the flu during the week which provides context as to why some were a little down on their standard output on the weekend. Vince I think would be one as he was no where near the level he's been for the past 5 weeks. Jones may have simply been well contained by Jacobs.

[Guest]

Praha - Not sure if you've read elsewhere but there were a few who were hit with the flu during the week which provides context as to why some were a little down on their standard output on the weekend. Vince I think would be one as he was no where near the level he's been for the past 5 weeks. Jones may have simply been well contained by Jacobs.

From a personal connection, I can assure you Nate Jones was pretty sick last week. I actually mentioned it pre-game on the gameday thread. You could notice how it was taking him longer to bounce back up from the hits he was taking during the match too.

[monoccular 17,444]

IMO the major reason we lost this game was once again our poor kicking.

For the umpteenth game this year we kicked ourselves out of it.

Poor field kicking contributed to a lot of turnovers.

Until we up the Kicking skill level of the group we will remain the bottom third of the competition.

Recent recruiting has been of footballers who are also athletic, rather than athletes who we hope we can teach football.

Huge change there.

ALL the newbies this year look as if they know the game and can at least kick the ball.

Huge change there.

The others will move on one way or another.

Up forward wasn't the problem so much as down back in the first quarter when brown and petrie had their way, but upon reflection, that was more a problem with how easy they were walking it out of the middle in that first quarter.

Hypothetical of course, as he couldn't play due to illness, but would a fit on song Fitzy have made a difference.

Hypothetically?

someone said roos made mention of jw being sick during week and touch and go if he played

fitzy didn't come up for magoos

comments (dl) re toumpas was crook with a cold

but nothing from club about large numbers being infected during week

these days a 5% drop-off can make a huge difference in your score/performance

A point I was trying to make to some of the residual JW haters, and to whichever 'loyal supporter' it was that said (or implied) than Nathan was having a sook.

From a personal connection, I can assure you Nate Jones was pretty sick last week. I actually mentioned it pre-game on the gameday thread. You could notice how it was taking him longer to bounce back up from the hits he was taking during the match too.

vide supra

Edited August 12, 2015 by monoccular