Post Match Discussion - Round 8

[Akum 2,660]

pretty similar to this one last year id say

Yep, almost identical. Cheap shot on someone too far away from the play to be expecting it.

Did Douglas get weeks?

[ChaserJ 5,005]

Difficult to rate Toumps game for me. The good was excellent, the bad was face palming. Problem is he panics in certain situation and gives up goals from it. Last night he got 2 of his own so that's a good output from him. It may well be a slow build with him getting him confident in his abilities. Part of me thinks he's still got Neeld's voice in his head at times.

Yeah, Toumpas made errors. The encouraging thing for me was that he kept putting in the effort and tried to make up for his errors.

Not long after his fluffed handpass for the Stringer goal, I recall him battling for a possession on the wing, winning the contest and forcing the ball forward. Can’t remember if it led to a stoppage in our fifty or a clean possession for one of our players, but he was determined to win the ball and move it forward.

Errors will come from developing players, it’s the response that shows the character and hopefully the learning. I was happy with the way Jimmy followed up. There have been times in the past where he makes a mistake and is pretty much anonymous afterward. Hopefully what we saw on Sunday is his new standard.

[nutbean 8,838]

Obviously the Bail missing 20% was that dreadful kick for goal at three quarter time.

At the time he marked the ball there was a MFC player 12 metres out on his own and Bail ignored him.

A goal then would have snuffed out the Dogs before the last quarter started.

Fortunately the Dees went on to win easily in the end so everyone forgets about Bail.

Sorry - i think you are off the mark on this one. There is enough to criticise Bail for- I thought the pass off was risky.

He was right to go back and take the shot - he let himself down with the kick and that will always be the knock on him.

I thought both he and Jones added good forward defensive pressure but the best way to create defensive pressure on running backs like Murphy is get the ball yourself - it keeps them more honest. Neither got enough of the ball themselves.

After a sluggish start I thought Vinces job on Bont was fantastic. Because Vince not only stiffled his output but started to get so much of the ball himself he had Bontempelli second guessing himself whether to defend or attack and ended up doing neither well.

[Grimes Times 1,278]

Yep, almost identical. Cheap shot on someone too far away from the play to be expecting it.

Did Douglas get weeks?

Refereed direct to Tribunal and given 4 weeks, reduced to 2 for good record and guilty plea.

[monoccular 17,413]

After watching the game again Fitzpatrick had a perfect game. Kept Boyd to 1 handball and had 100% efficiency with 14 touched and a lot of good marks.

I didn't see that coming - did anyone else? Would have expected Tom to take the million dollar man but full credit to Fitz, and to Roos et al for giving him the responsibility and putting their faith in him.

[old dee 23,777]

Sorry - i think you are off the mark on this one. There is enough to criticise Bail for- I thought the pass off was risky.

He was right to go back and take the shot - he let himself down with the kick and that will always be the knock on him.

I thought both he and Jones added good forward defensive pressure but the best way to create defensive pressure on running backs like Murphy is get the ball yourself - it keeps them more honest. Neither got enough of the ball themselves.

After a sluggish start I thought Vinces job on Bont was fantastic. Because Vince not only stiffled his output but started to get so much of the ball himself he had Bontempelli second guessing himself whether to defend or attack and ended up doing neither well.

Obviously we will never know nutbean

[Demon trucker 1,800]

They dogs should of gone after mcafter muck cheaper and more mole

[barneymfc 152]

will win the next 2 cant wait to beat the hair pies

[old dee 23,777]

They dogs should of gone after mcafter muck cheaper and more mole

What?

[ManDee 7,124]

They dogs should of gone after mcafter muck cheaper and more mole

NAA, are your thumbs tired? I have no idea what that means.

Edit:

Translation? The dogs should have gone after McAffer, much cheaper and ???????

Edited May 25, 2015 by ManDee

[Dr. Gonzo 24,162]

Isn't hind sight a wonderful thing.

I think it has all been said on to next week.

No, not hindsight. When he took the mark I saw he had a loose man on in the goal square but was hoping he would go back and take the shot in fear of the siren going with the ball mid air. I was conscious it had been a long quarter as were the people sitting around me who had been saying for the last minute or so "when is the siren going to go" and pointing out the time on the clock.

[old dee 23,777]

No, not hindsight. When he took the mark I saw he had a loose man on in the goal square but was hoping he would go back and take the shot in fear of the siren going with the ball mid air. I was conscious it had been a long quarter as were the people sitting around me who had been saying for the last minute or so "when is the siren going to go" and pointing out the time on the clock.

I am not changing my view and neither are you Dr so i guess the discussion is over.

lets hope Bail can kick the next one from point blank.

[Bimbo 940]

Watching Toumpas and Watts delivering the ball yesterday and with Salem to come back there is plenty of reason to hope for much better movement into the forward line. Will help remedy one of the more obvious long term problems.

[Uncle Fester 2,848]

I can't wait for the Carlton game. Bruise free footy, eh? Bet they won't be able to say that with a large chunk of the MCG in their mouths.

[Grimes Times 1,278]

The bump was fair. Jones had a terrible lack of awareness in the situation.

Won't go,

Bet ?

No eye dear

Edited May 25, 2015 by Grimes Times

[jazza 1,323]

No 31,looks like a decent chap.

[old dee 23,777]

No eye dear

Blind antelope right!

[Curry & Beer 5,444]

I can't wait for the Carlton game. Bruise free footy, eh? Bet they won't be able to say that with a large chunk of the MCG in their mouths.

well Mitch Robinson is now at Brizzy, but we should smash them also

[old dee 23,777]

No 31,looks like a decent chap.

Yes Ron is a decent chap

[Farmer 875]

I just got home from the match and although i predicted a win I didn't think it would be such a good one.

The tackling was superb.

Fitzy and Spencer were awesome.

Garlett is a class above,as is the Hulk.

Jones is a pure gladiator.

Toump is a gun kick,terrible handballer.

Howe earned his cheque today.

Vanders awesome.

The only really terrible games came from Matt Jones and Ro Bail .

Oh -Pedersen was outstanding.

Well yes, Garlett is a class act, but he shouldn't have been kicking from outside the boundary line in the first place.

Watts made an outstanding lead, was completely on his own, and the angle would have been more than halved.Garlett ignored it to Watts' disgust.

It was a great goal but selfish play

There again, if you thought Matt Jones was poor, have a look at the replay. How much did Bob Murphy do?

[mordja 187]

As soon as he stopped I knew a behind would be the result

I can only assume one of three things given your self declared precognition; 1) that things improve dramatically for us in the coming years, 2) you are a masochist, or 3) you want to sound smarter than you are.

I'm fairly sure the latter is the short odds. If not, feel free to PM me the lotto numbers for the weekend.

[Uncle Fester 2,848]

well Mitch Robinson is now at Brizzy, but we should smash them also

He spoke as a representative of Carlton when he said it, therefore they will pay for his sins.

But I do agree we should smash Brisbane just to be sure.

[DeeSpencer 25,444]

Bookmarked.

Left nut is safe. Should've put some money on it.

[Farmer 875]

Nope. Grimes should go. His disposal and decision making is still VFL standard. And go around again, Gus. We need you.

What absolute crap! Of course Grimes plays. He is a seriously good defender. He messed up ONE kick yesterday.He hit a number of targets from a considerable distance .His courage is inspiring

[DeeSpencer 25,444]

Bail and Matt Jones contributed to the win. But they left 3 or 4 goals out there with misses, poor shots, turnovers and lack of understanding of forward play.

Right on half time one of them could've simply tapped the ball over to Garlett who would've run in to an open goal yet instead took possession. Jones gave away a careless high free to Murphy and had his quota of fumbles. Bail let quite a few tackles slip.

I'm glad Roos deployed them as role players and they did the role. Watts and Toumpas filled the much needed roles for some run and skill up the ground. Brayshaw does a bit of both, Pedersen and Hogan provide the big targets, Howe the versatile option and Garlett chips in with some finishing skills.

Viney and Jetta have to come in and then the question should be asked whether we can use other players (say Viney and Newton) in the roles Bail and Jones did or if they are worth keeping as they have pace, endurance and discipline.

Dropping guys who have done their job is always a tough ask. But personally I'd go for the skilled players but make it known that Matt Jones and Bail are there in reserve and if you don't work hard enough they'll get your spots as they've shown an ability to do a job for the team even if it did come with some errors.