WELCOME TO THE MELBOURNE FOOTBALL CLUB - CHRISTIAN PETRACCA

[beelzebub 23,383]

How many competitive games did Hogan play last year compared to McCartin? A big preseason could see McCartin picked before Hogan!

Hogan will have particpated in the better part of 3 preseasons before he hits the grass in 15. Not a squeaky clean progress though out all of that but thats a bit of a difference as compared to where anyone else will start from.

As part of the " we dont need another saviour" maxim now entrenched at the club we dont need Mccartin to start the season. We do need to develop him or whoever into playing AFL

[Machsy 2,858]

How many competitive games did Hogan play last year compared to McCartin? A big preseason could see McCartin picked before Hogan!

Yeah, nah.

[beelzebub 23,383]

Ever thought of picking/not picking him on form? Roos has form on this. JKH.

That would overcome this rather brainless discussion of whether he deserves a game round 1 and your premise that "good clubs would do". Good clubs would pick him if he was in the best 22. If he's in ours he plays.

Sorry to hear youre brainless Bob, must make life hard.

Theres a vast difference between selecting a KPF and an ancillary role player. Wouldnt you say ?

[Jesse Christ 2,884]

What if Hogan does his back in again?

[rpfc 28,779]

Maybe apart from Hogan, he is better. Gawn is a ruck, Pedersen & Fitzpatrick depth.

Now for one thing we might not even have McCartin and if we do I wouldn't be ruling a line through him just yet. I wouldn't be gifting games to Pedersen, Gawn or Fitzpatrick because they've been around a while.

I am sick of gifting games to players who don't deserve it be they kids or experienced campaigners.

Is he better? Or will he be better?

Pedersen would be his little play thing for a couple of years if they went head to head.

You say Pedersen and Fitz are depth? I say McCartin is depth too - until he proves himself to be more than that.

We are a terrible team with a compromised list - there are going to guys being gifted games, there should now be an emphasis on properly preparing talent before exposing them to AFL.

All I will say is that McCartin will earn his place in the 22 because Roos has a history of not playing kids simply because they are 'supposed' to be better than the journeymen that are currently in the team.

I can see a team with Gawn, Hogan and Pedersen as tall forwards in Rd 1 being the best combination the list has at that present time.

[Demon Disciple 12,274]

What if Hogan does his back in again?

Then i'm afraid it will look like this.

[nutbean 8,838]

I actually hope we do have to pick him because his early form warrants it. That would mean that ready to play round one means ready to play round one - (who would have thought !)

I hope he kicks the door down and jumps up and down on it for next 10 years - it means we got ourselves a really good draft pick (w ho would have thought)

[beelzebub 23,383]

What if Hogan does his back in again?

What if he does, what if he doesnt. I seriously dont see that as an automatic 'pick the noobie' case scenario

as RPFC has highlighted there are others , already established and experienced to fulfill these roles whilst the new kid gets some education.

[rjay 25,091]

All I will say is that McCartin will earn his place in the 22 because Roos has a history of not playing kids simply because they are 'supposed' to be better than the journeymen that are currently in the team.

Not playing anyone unless he has a good reason and they deserve their spot.

Pedersen would be his little play thing for a couple of years if they went head to head.

Not sure what you're meaning here 'rpfc' but if they went head to head McCartin wouldn't be a play thing, that bit I can guarantee you.

Edited November 24, 2014 by rjay

[Jesse Christ 2,884]

What if he does, what if he doesnt. I seriously dont see that as an automatic 'pick the noobie' case scenario

as RPFC has highlighted there are others , already established and experienced to fulfill these roles whilst the new kid gets some education.

Yeah I know, my comment was just referring to the fact that anything could happen.

Would a year out of football make one rusty enough to the point where they almost have to learn the game again, or is it all ingrained?

[beelzebub 23,383]

Yeah I know, my comment was just referring to the fact that anything could happen.

Would a year out of football make one rusty enough to the point where they almost have to learn the game again, or is it all ingrained?

Now thats a very good question. I think it does depend on the individual as we all rebound somewhat differently.

What he JH HAS learnt cant really be un-learned. His experience is still experience. His condition might go to another question , related though.

I would have thought, and yes is just my h-o , that as Jesse ramps up his training and does his preseason then hed be pretty ripe to go .

I suppose its up to others to climb walls ad kick down doors but even then they'll only get noticed, no guarantee , nor real "NEED" to pick them round 1

[Bossdog 2,002]

I can't believe you guys are arguing over wether a player will play round 1 when we hav'nt even drafted him yet.

Sorry.....Keep going...

[beelzebub 23,383]

Who's this bloke Petracca btw ??

[rpfc 28,779]

Not playing anyone unless he has a good reason and they deserve their spot.

Not sure what you're meaning here 'rpfc' but if they went head to head McCartin wouldn't be a play thing, that bit I can guarantee you.

He's a kid.

If he earns it, then great.

Personally, I hope he doesn't play AFL in 2015.

I want Pedersen to continue his form and give us something over and above what a teenager could give. And I want that teenager to learn how to play against men in the VFL.

[Deestroy All 14,266]

Then i'm afraid it will look like this.

Bernie Vince approves this post.

[Wrecker45 3,378]

How many competitive games did Hogan play last year compared to McCartin? A big preseason could see McCartin picked before Hogan!

How many leading goal kicking tittles and best and fairest's has McCartin won at Casey in the VFL playing against men?

[Norm Smith's Curse 2,602]

https://mobile.twitter.com/sam_mcclure/status/536757770507137025

[beelzebub 23,383]

https://mobile.twitter.com/sam_mcclure/status/536757770507137025

am not unhappy

[Demon_JB 1,385]

This excites me.

[DistrACTION Jackson 9,245]

We can't lose. We either get two good mids who compliment each other.

Or we get a good mid and a big forward.

[Jesse Christ 2,884]

How many leading goal kicking tittles and best and fairest's has McCartin won at Casey in the VFL playing against men?

How many full seasons has McCartin been injured for?

[Ted Lasso 19,549]

Developing under roo while he is there, no players of that type/quality in the next draft,

Massive chance we land petracca here

[wattsup 470]

I'm glad we don't have the decision it's kind of refreshing

[P-man 13,366]

https://mobile.twitter.com/sam_mcclure/status/536757770507137025

If we land Brayshaw and Petracca....

I'm too excited to finish that sentence.

[Machsy 2,858]