My 3 word player analysis V Richmond

[joeboy 3,164]

N.Jones - what an inspiration

Grimes - composed and focused

Salem - a smooth mover

Watts - opportunistic and effective

Toumpas - worked into game

Dawes - provided presence again

Viney - courageous and bullocking

Tyson - indefatigable and vital

Dunn - the backline general

Cross - great tagging game

Garland - composed and calm

Pederson - eye opening performance

Vince- great second half

Kennedy - Harris - had an impact

McDonald - reliable and steady

Riley - likes the ruggedness

Gawn - played his part

Howe - skilled and creative

Jamar - commanding in centre

Bail - provided forward pressure

M.Jones - great first half

Terlich - tough and brave

[nutbean 8,838]

Glad you loved everyone this week ! I certainly did.

[Bang Bang Bang 5,802]

Disagree on Grimes, always gives his all but he was a liability at times today. Otherwise, pretty much spot on. You can bet your bottom dollar that every game we win under Roos will have everyone playing their part. A gun coach.

Edited May 17, 2014 by Sylvia Saint

[nutbean 8,838]

Disagree on Grimes, always gives his all but he was a liability at times today. Otherwise, pretty much spot on. You can bet your bottom dollar that every game we win under Roos will have everyone playing their part. A gun coach.

One bad clanger does not make him a liability.

[Wrecker45 3,378]

Dom Tyson - A budding superstar

[Bang Bang Bang 5,802]

One bad clanger does not make him a liability.

There was more than one.

[Earl Hood 6,082]

I thought Salem struggled a bit in his first full game today. Eight possessions, He got caught twice in tackles when I thought he would sense the player coming behind him. Got pinged on the second one which was appalling umpiring but I expected him to slip that tackle. Anyway early days, probably struggling for fitness levels at this stage.

[RalphiusMaximus 6,024]

Grimes should not be taking kickouts, nor should he be used as a short target when someone else takes one. His kicking just isn't suited to that situation. He seems to be better in general play than he is with those spot kicks.

[RalphiusMaximus 6,024]

I thought Salem struggled a bit in his first full game today. Eight possessions, He got caught twice in tackles when I thought he would sense the player coming behind him. Got pinged on the second one which was appalling umpiring but I expected him to slip that tackle. Anyway early days, probably struggling for fitness levels at this stage.

Got pinged twice, incorrect call on both occasions. I think he may have run over that Umpire's cat.

[Earl Hood 6,082]

Got pinged twice, incorrect call on both occasions. I think he may have run over that Umpire's cat.

My main point was I thought he would be able to slip both tackles but he kept running in a straight line and got caught.

[deeflog 679]

Tyson- three brownlow votes

N jones- two brownlow votes

Pederson- one brownlow vote

[Maldonboy38 6,390]

N.Jones - inspirational and tough

Grimes - interceptions and turnovers

Salem -just a game

Watts - reward from running

Toumpas - steady not brilliant

Dawes - intimidating physical focus

Viney - tough natural footballer

Tyson - poised midfield machine

Dunn - clam, reliable, effective

Cross - great tagging game

Garland - composed and influential

Pederson - amazing work rate

Vince- great second half

Kennedy - Harris - keeps on impressing

McDonald - effective but scary

Riley -not too bad

Gawn - very important role

Howe - skilled and creative

Jamar - strong feeds midfield

Bail - just a game

M.Jones - best forward spreader

Terlich - good and bad

[Bitter but optimistic 22,220]

No duds today!

[Maldonboy38 6,390]

No duds today!

Bitter, this is the difference. We have had some players this year to have shockers, but in the main we are producing an even spread of team football across the 22.

[picket fence 17,060]

TERLICH. Still not sure

M JONES. Hit and miss

Mc DONALD. disposal a worry

TOUMPAS. Wasted draft pick

[daisycutter 29,604]

TERLICH. Still not sure

M JONES. Hit and miss

Mc DONALD. disposal a worry

TOUMPAS. Wasted draft pick

you don't give roos much credit do you

look at the 'duds' he's already turned around

come back in another 10 rounds and then make your big prognostications champ

[KingDingAling 3,752]

Dom Tyson GUN!

[nutbean 8,838]

you don't give roos much credit do you

look at the 'duds' he's already turned around

come back in another 10 rounds and then make your big prognostications champ

Not sure why you bother.

Writing toumpas off after a bit over season, McDonald just 21, jones in his second season, Terlich in his second full season.

Amazing.....

[picket fence 17,060]

you don't give roos much credit do you

look at the 'duds' he's already turned around

come back in another 10 rounds and then make your big prognostications champ

ROOS, BLOODY SENSATIONAL!

[Dinosaur Rover 197]

N.Jones - inspirational and tough

Grimes - interceptions and turnovers

Salem -just a game

This is about right we won but there was plenty to improve

Watts - reward from running

Toumpas - steady not brilliant

Dawes - intimidating physical focus

Viney - tough natural footballer

Tyson - poised midfield machine

Dunn - clam, reliable, effective

Cross - great tagging game

Garland - composed and influential

Pederson - amazing work rate

Vince- great second half

Kennedy - Harris - keeps on impressing

McDonald - effective but scary

Riley -not too bad

Gawn - very important role

Howe - skilled and creative

Jamar - strong feeds midfield

Bail - just a game

M.Jones - best forward spreader

Terlich - good and bad

[Curry & Beer 5,444]

some peeps are getting a bit carried away

we were very, very lucky to win today

and our opponent wasn't much chop at all

a lot of our blokes did not have a great day

obviously I'm rapt we still got up and it's another 4 points but sheesh we didn't climb everest today, let's keep it in our pants shall we

and never forget the false dawn of 2010/11

ok had to say it.. as you were

[picket fence 17,060]

PICKET FENCE!? Just my opinion!

[Elusive Tunbridge 795]

PICKET FENCE!? Caps Lock stuck.

[picket fence 17,060]

you don't give roos much credit do you

look at the 'duds' he's already turned around

come back in another 10 rounds and then make your big prognostications champ

10 Rounds, what about the last 50 years ?? I'll give you the fact that yes, some duds have been very very good .. But after 50 years how's your patience,??

[nutbean 8,838]

some peeps are getting a bit carried away

we were very, very lucky to win today

and our opponent wasn't much chop at all

a lot of our blokes did not have a great day

obviously I'm rapt we still got up and it's another 4 points but sheesh we didn't climb everest today, let's keep it in our pants shall we

and never forget the false dawn of 2010/11

ok had to say it.. as you were

I don't think we were lucky today. We deserved to win.

I would suggest some of our players didn't have a great day but here's the thing.... In the past we had a whole lot of players who were poor...actually liabilities. Today Salem was quiet as was bail but neither were poor or a negative to the team just little impact.

I don't think anyone here is saying finals ... Just enjoying the win..

That's my say.