To me Heater doesn't have a "culture" problem. He has a "Buckley" problem. As Does Dale Thomas, Chris Dawes, Wellingham. Players never used to actively try to leave collingwood. Im quite happy to have Heater at our club. We don't have a decent running half back. This guy is one of the best in the business in this position.

No as well

So a 4 year 2mil deal tabl;ed! Thoughts?

So a 4 year 2mil deal tabl;ed! Thoughts?

"tabled" still getting over yesterday! Bad headache!

We're spending $2 million on a player who won't solve our midfield problems.

Interesting.

Who says he can't play midfield? He is a superb defender but could do damage in the middle!!

We can't afford Dustin Martin but we can afford Shaw? Come on Dees, get the priorities straight.

Shaw is apparently keen to play midfield so who knows. He is an undoubted toolbag, but if Roos wants him, I want him.

In Roos we trust.

Not surprised by the offer as Roos loves Shaw and we have next to no run coming off half back. Culture stuff aside he would be fantastic for us but I wouldn't have thought he would be that interested in playing for the MFC.

Shaw is apparently keen to play midfield so who knows. He is an undoubted toolbag, but if Roos wants him, I want him.

In Roos we trust.

God I hate that term, every time someone puts it out there we get another failure.

God I hate that term, every time someone puts it out there we get another failure.

That was 'I believe in.'

The failure you are referring to is God. As in 'In God we trust'...

Surprises me! Thought Dusty would be a better fit (for the bad sss's) but if Roos sees something he can work with we have to go with it! An offer is a long way from a signature though!

4 years is way too much. Didnt Roos say Shaw was worth a top 6 pick?? 2nd rounder at best for Shaw.

How old is he?

How old is he?

Google is your friend.

That was a bit of a rhetorical question! I can't believe we arfe offering 4 year deals to a risng 28 year old!

That was a bit of a rhetorical question! I can't believe we arfe offering 4 year deals to a risng 28 year old!

Where does this 4 yr $2mil offer come from? Who mentioned this offer, because the only place I have seen it stated was in your other post at the top of the page. Am I missing something?

Yeah.

You should disregard just about everything he says.

I was told today we had offered him $500,000 pa over 4 years. Announced on radio. Is it just a roomer?

Jay Clark article saying we could be offering collingwood pick 2 in return for Shaw and pick 10.

If this happens i will seriously lose my [censored]! We can do much better then heath shaw!

Edited September 29, 201312 yr by dazzledavey36

Midfielders!!!! Not back flankers.

Jay Clark article saying we could be offering collingwood pick 2 in return for Shaw and pick 2.

So we get Shaw for free ?

So we get Shaw for free ?

Edited

Jay Clark article saying we could be offering collingwood pick 2 in return for Shaw and pick 10.

If this happens i will seriously lose my shit! We can do much better then heath shaw!

Relax. It's Jay Clark.

I have skipped a bit on this thread.

But an acquaintance of mine friend a dyed in the wool pies man.

Told me that the problem with Shaw is he suffers from ADHD. The medication required to stabilise his condition

is a banned substance.

Any clues. When was coke banned?