My 3 word player analysis V The Hawks

[joeboy 2,955]

Trengove - just a game

N.Jones - wonderful first half

Watts - time to decide

Dawes - impressed and delivered

Frawley - great under duress

McKenzie -below required standard

Dunn - struggled for effectiveness

Rodan - justified his inclusion

Strauss - rarely imbued confidence

Garland - continued toiling manfully

Pederson - not all negative

Macdonald - was rarely sighted

Evans - had few possessions

Kent - some promising touches

Tapscott - had limited opportunities

Davey - classy but restricted

Howe - classy when involved

Jamar - not the worst

Bail - was the worst

M.Jones - couldn't get going

Terlich - composure was needed

Fitzpatrick - cause for optimism

[deeflog 679]

Bail- Back to Casey

Mckenzie- should join Bail

[Kenny Powers 90]

Trengove - just a game

N.Jones - wonderful first half

Watts - time to decide

Dawes - impressed and delivered

Frawley - great under duress

McKenzie -below required standard

Dunn - struggled for effectiveness

Rodan - justified his inclusion

Strauss - rarely imbued confidence

Garland - continued toiling manfully

Pederson - not all negative

Macdonald - was rarely sighted

Evans - had few possessions

Kent - some promising touches

Tapscott - had limited opportunities

Davey - classy but restricted

Howe - classy when involved

Jamar - not the worst

Bail - was the worst

M.Jones - couldn't get going

Terlich - composure was needed

Fitzpatrick - cause for optimism

Always a pleasure Edited June 2, 2013 by DeeInWa

[RalphiusMaximus 6,000]

Surprisingly upbeat from you Joeboy. Not that I disagree. As I keep saying, that was about the best 95 point loss I've ever seen.

[demonchris 162]

Bit harsh on Trengove, I feel he is actually starting to hit some form. Today he had 16 touches and 7 tackles, not bad and that is improving from week to week.

[Norm Smith's Curse 2,086]

Couldn't believe fitzy was unmanned for periods of the game. Insulting.

[RalphiusMaximus 6,000]

Couldn't believe fitzy was unmanned for periods of the game. Insulting.

They didn't have to worry. nobody could kick to him. One of the few times someone spotted him in space they lobbed a high up-and-under on his head and allowed three Hawks to close in and smash him.

[Triple Jack 13]

Pickles Evans: ripper goal though

[spirit of norm smith 13,577]

ranked in order

Dawes – tough. Marked well. Gave a target. Can move between FF & CHF. 21 disposals, 12 marks and a goal
Frawley – great game. Nullified and chased down Franklin
N.Jones – only AFL top quality midfielder on our list. 28 disposals and 11 clearances.
Garland – held Roughhead. Good game.

Howe – not enough but is good AFL standard
Watts – must play in Forward 50
Jamar – up to standard. Needs more around the ground.
Davey - classy and must play Forward 50
Pederson – solid CHB. Must keep building
Trengove - improving
Dunn – battled.
Terlich – settled in.
Strauss – some good. Some bad. Needs to learn to tackle.
Evans – hmmm. Battles.
Kent – yes some glimpses. Keep in.
Tapscott – sub. Got involved.
M.Jones – quiet.
Fitzpatrick - cause for optimism

Rodan – up/down, circles, fumbles, good tackles. Missed sitter of a goal.Hmmm.
Macdonald – battled.
McKenzie -below required standard (casey??)
Bail - was the worst

[autocol 448]

Macdonald may not have touched it much, but he certainly did a good job keeping Mitchell quiet.

[Kenny Powers 90]

Macdonald may not have touched it much, but he certainly did a good job keeping Mitchell quiet.

im a fan of j mac, he's one of the only players who shows aggression

[Swampfox 190]

ranked in order

Dawes – tough. Marked well. Gave a target. Can move between FF & CHF. 21 disposals, 12 marks and a goal

Frawley – great game. Nullified and chased down Franklin

N.Jones – only AFL top quality midfielder on our list. 28 disposals and 11 clearances.

Garland – held Roughhead. Good game.

Howe – not enough but is good AFL standard

Watts – must play in Forward 50

Jamar – up to standard. Needs more around the ground.

Davey - classy and must play Forward 50

Pederson – solid CHB. Must keep building

Trengove - improving

Dunn – battled.

Terlich – settled in.

Strauss – some good. Some bad. Needs to learn to tackle.

Evans – hmmm. Battles.

Kent – yes some glimpses. Keep in.

Tapscott – sub. Got involved.

M.Jones – quiet.

Fitzpatrick - cause for optimism

Rodan – up/down, circles, fumbles, good tackles. Missed sitter of a goal.Hmmm.

Macdonald – battled.

McKenzie -below required standard (casey??)

Bail - was the worst

Agree with that

[faultydet 7,593]

Surprisingly upbeat from you Joeboy. Not that I disagree. As I keep saying, that was about the best 95 point loss I've ever seen.

Good call Ralphius.

I agree with that. Never thought I would feel that way after a 16 goal loss, but there you go.

I hope Neeld stays, and is given a chance with an improved midfield list.

[PJ_12345 1,098]

Trengove - just a game

N.Jones - wonderful first half

Watts - time to decide

Dawes - impressed and delivered

Frawley - great under duress

McKenzie -below required standard

Dunn - struggled for effectiveness

Rodan - justified his inclusion

Strauss - rarely imbued confidence

Garland - continued toiling manfully

Pederson - not all negative

Macdonald - was rarely sighted

Evans - had few possessions

Kent - some promising touches

Tapscott - had limited opportunities

Davey - classy but restricted

Howe - classy when involved

Jamar - not the worst

Bail - was the worst

M.Jones - couldn't get going

Terlich - composure was needed

Fitzpatrick - cause for optimism

Great effort by J Mac. Kept an inform Mitchell who has been over the past 3 games averaging 15 kicks, 34 disposals, and a goal to a relatively quiet 8 kicks, 24 disposals and nothing on the score board.

One of the highlights for me today. Good on him.

[jackaub 1,402]

im a fan of j mac, he's one of the only players who shows aggression

Couldnt agree more he did his job and makes it hard for his opponent I wish we had a few more who show that agro

[nutbean 8,837]

Couldnt agree more he did his job and makes it hard for his opponent I wish we had a few more who show that agro

His kicking and decision making can be poor but you always know you are going to get 100% from J Mac.

[deeko 937]

I love Joely Mac just for his attack on the pill and have been saying for a while he should be played as a defensive half forward.

The reasons being not only he works his backside off to beat his man one on one but his kicking and decision making won't hurt us so much if he is putting it forward rather than clearing from defence.

I think he offers a lot more there than Dunn and his wannabe agro.

[chookrat 3,851]

JMac is really important to our list because he sets an example on the field for competitiveness. With Dawes, Garland and N Jones setting benchmarks for competitiveness, players like Terlich, Howe, M Jones and Evans improving and with Silvia, Grimes, Byrnes and Clark coming back Im feeling much better about our team for the second half of the season.

The inclusion of each AFL standard player will have a massive impact to our onfield performance.

[Josh 1,420]

Great effort by J Mac. Kept an inform Mitchell who has been over the past 3 games averaging 15 kicks, 34 disposals, and a goal to a relatively quiet 8 kicks, 24 disposals and nothing on the score board. One of the highlights for me today. Good on him.

It was a great effort but how sad is it that 3 or 4 of our players are playing "shut down/run with" roles every week. Jones is the only bloke opposition teams have to tag and honestly Sewell showed today that it's just as affective going head to head.

Untill we have at least 3 or 4 players for other teams to worry about we will be chasing tail from the first bounce.

[DemonFrog 1,347]

I am finally starting to see the game plan of the MFC.It is to get toally smashed in the first two quarters so as to catch the other team off guard in the second half. Just need a little more fitness in the four quarter and we should have them.

I so loved the 51 point comeback against Fremantle in 2008 and just know they team can do better given the chance.

Loved how Buddy was contained. Also there are a few players who did show they can play, but its always hard to judge when the team gets totally outplayed in so many positions.

[DeeZee 6,905]

Thought Fitzy was terrible, for a bloke trying to prove himself, fumbly, couldnt take a mark, turned the ball over, shocking.

[Coup Cooper 610]

Bail- Back to Casey

Mckenzie- should join Bail

Too true!!